I ordered food for the first time from Nutmeg’s Cafe and the Tuna Melt was outstanding!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ The cold pasta side was also delicious. 🤤 Can’t wait to try more!
Sebring Computers
Always amazing food at Nutmeg's. I have been enjoying their food since they were across from my old office years ago. This is the Roast Beef Philly and my other go to is the Pulled Pork Panini.
Mary Morales
Hi My name is Mary you say I rude when go over there you treating nasty if someone wanna talk look yourself first before you judge someboy
Yvette Griggs
I don’t often leave reviews, but Nutmeg’s Cafe has truly earned it. This place may be small, but it’s such a cozy, welcoming spot with a charm all its own. I’ve only been a few times, but every visit has been a great experience. The food is always spot on - fresh, flavorful, and served piping hot. You can tell that the kitchen really cares about the quality of each dish, and it's clear they use top-notch ingredients.
What really makes Nutmeg’s stand out, though, is the service. The guy managing the front is always so kind and attentive, but never in a rush. He makes sure to check in and see if you need anything, which makes the experience feel personalized. It’s rare to find a place where the staff genuinely cares about your comfort and satisfaction, but at Nutmeg’s, that’s exactly what you get.
The atmosphere is another big plus - it’s a perfect balance of relaxed and inviting, and I’ve always felt like I could linger over my meal without any pressure. Whether you're popping in for a quick bite or planning to stay a while, Nutmeg’s Cafe has this perfect energy that makes it a great place to unwind.
If you're looking for a place where the food is consistently great, the service is impeccable, and the atmosphere makes you feel at ease, I highly recommend Nutmeg’s Cafe. It's one of those hidden gems you’re happy to find!
Naomi Rebeca
This place is a NO go. Service was a joke and the coffee was disgusting and cold. Wawa is next door, go there. You’re welcome.
Josh
Stopped here for a bite and some coffee and wanted to support a local small business.
Twenty minutes and two lukewarm lattes later this was a mistake.
Go to Starbucks for better customer service and coffee that is served hot.
Also, during the week, they stop serving breakfast at 10:30am despite it not being printed on their menu. I guess a breakfast burrito is too much effort for 11:10am.
Avoid this place.
Robert
Great food
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Soup
Sharon Franklin
Everyone was so friendly and helpful and the sandwiches were GREAT. Unusual combinations and different side dishes...be sure to try the beet salad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Julie Whitmire
Just had the chicken salad on top of salad greens with raspberry vinegarette dressing and fresh fruit on the side. It was phenomenal! I love Nutmegs and try to stop in every chance I get. Great food!
Christina Burke
What a find! So many choices for food and smoothies. Lovely staff. They let us sit with our dog in the enclosed porch area. Thank you!!
Vegetarian options: Minimal vegan options, but vegetarians should be very happy.
I enjoy coming to Nutmeg's Cafe I can not get enough hands down this is by far one of the best places I've been to in Highlands County. I get something different everytime and they have two menu's and so much to choose from and my meal is always on point and fresh.
If you are starving or in a hurry pass this place by As of now I’m sitting in empty place waiting 20 minutes for daily special and bowl of sour tho soup was not edible who puts raw onion in tomato bisque? Didn’t eat wasn’t offered refund Will not return This is an edit I was in there at almost 3 o’clock. I ate two bites of that nasty soup and left it there. The lady took it away and asked me you were full. I said no it was nasty. She didn’t offer me any refund so yes on the way out I said the soup is nasty. I didn’t eat it. It was nasty and I think you’re the lady that waited on me and you’re nasty too. You were rude. Oh I forgot your soup. I guess I’m an airhead is what you said so don’t even start with me, lady.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Soup
Alexia Segura
My first time here! Great food and service ! I had the turkey and bacon avocado sandwich with the chicken and rice soup ! Yummm and they had the cutest macaroons today. Pumkin spice and oreo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Soup
Linda Jones
Try to get a little breakfast this morning. The place was empty. There were two people working in the back one doing dishes and one on the phone. Nobody seemed to have time to take my order. My son would’ve loved the headbanging music they were playing but me not so much. I left.
I ordered food for the first time from Nutmeg’s Cafe and the Tuna Melt was outstanding!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ The cold pasta side was also delicious. 🤤 Can’t wait to try more!
Always amazing food at Nutmeg's. I have been enjoying their food since they were across from my old office years ago. This is the Roast Beef Philly and my other go to is the Pulled Pork Panini.
Hi My name is Mary you say I rude when go over there you treating nasty if someone wanna talk look yourself first before you judge someboy
I don’t often leave reviews, but Nutmeg’s Cafe has truly earned it. This place may be small, but it’s such a cozy, welcoming spot with a charm all its own. I’ve only been a few times, but every visit has been a great experience. The food is always spot on - fresh, flavorful, and served piping hot. You can tell that the kitchen really cares about the quality of each dish, and it's clear they use top-notch ingredients.
What really makes Nutmeg’s stand out, though, is the service. The guy managing the front is always so kind and attentive, but never in a rush. He makes sure to check in and see if you need anything, which makes the experience feel personalized. It’s rare to find a place where the staff genuinely cares about your comfort and satisfaction, but at Nutmeg’s, that’s exactly what you get.
The atmosphere is another big plus - it’s a perfect balance of relaxed and inviting, and I’ve always felt like I could linger over my meal without any pressure. Whether you're popping in for a quick bite or planning to stay a while, Nutmeg’s Cafe has this perfect energy that makes it a great place to unwind.
If you're looking for a place where the food is consistently great, the service is impeccable, and the atmosphere makes you feel at ease, I highly recommend Nutmeg’s Cafe. It's one of those hidden gems you’re happy to find!
This place is a NO go. Service was a joke and the coffee was disgusting and cold. Wawa is next door, go there. You’re welcome.
Stopped here for a bite and some coffee and wanted to support a local small business.
Twenty minutes and two lukewarm lattes later this was a mistake.
Go to Starbucks for better customer service and coffee that is served hot.
Also, during the week, they stop serving breakfast at 10:30am despite it not being printed on their menu. I guess a breakfast burrito is too much effort for 11:10am.
Avoid this place.
Great food
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Soup
Everyone was so friendly and helpful and the sandwiches were GREAT. Unusual combinations and different side dishes...be sure to try the beet salad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Just had the chicken salad on top of salad greens with raspberry vinegarette dressing and fresh fruit on the side. It was phenomenal! I love Nutmegs and try to stop in every chance I get. Great food!
What a find! So many choices for food and smoothies. Lovely staff. They let us sit with our dog in the enclosed porch area. Thank you!!
Vegetarian options: Minimal vegan options, but vegetarians should be very happy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Soup, Veggie Wrap
Restaurantji Recommends
I enjoy coming to Nutmeg's Cafe I can not get enough hands down this is by far one of the best places I've been to in Highlands County. I get something different everytime and they have two menu's and so much to choose from and my meal is always on point and fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Quiche, Reuben, Erica's Panini, Cobb Salad, Blackened Shrimp Wrap, Pasta Salad, Cupcake, Ham & Pear Panini, Chicken Salad Croissant, Greek Salad, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Veggie Wrap, Tuna Melt
If you are starving or in a hurry pass this place by As of now I’m sitting in empty place waiting 20 minutes for daily special and bowl of sour tho soup was not edible who puts raw onion in tomato bisque? Didn’t eat wasn’t offered refund Will not return This is an edit I was in there at almost 3 o’clock. I ate two bites of that nasty soup and left it there. The lady took it away and asked me you were full. I said no it was nasty. She didn’t offer me any refund so yes on the way out I said the soup is nasty. I didn’t eat it. It was nasty and I think you’re the lady that waited on me and you’re nasty too. You were rude. Oh I forgot your soup. I guess I’m an airhead is what you said so don’t even start with me, lady.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Soup
My first time here! Great food and service ! I had the turkey and bacon avocado sandwich with the chicken and rice soup ! Yummm and they had the cutest macaroons today. Pumkin spice and oreo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Soup
Try to get a little breakfast this morning. The place was empty. There were two people working in the back one doing dishes and one on the phone. Nobody seemed to have time to take my order. My son would’ve loved the headbanging music they were playing but me not so much. I left.
The food is amazing. Best salads ever!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Salads
Loading...