Casa Maya

Name: Casa Maya
Address: 22 Hypolita St, St. Augustine, Florida, 32084, US
Telephone: (904) 823-0787
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.5

$$ • Seafood, Mexican, Salad

Hours:
22 Hypolita St, St. Augustine
(904) 823-0787

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Casa Maya

Casa Maya offers a delightful dining experience with delicious local cuisine, including the popular cucumber jalapeño marg, shrimp ceviche, and local catch. The restaurant is somewhat off to the side, making it a chill spot for those looking for a break from crowds. Guests enjoy fresh margaritas and quality tequilas, and the chips and queso are highly praised. The lively atmosphere, complete with live music, creates the perfect setting for a casual Sunday night. Attentive service enhances the experience, with servers providing great recommendations. Visitors have praised the fresh seafood, such as raw oysters and ceviche, and the drinks, especially the passion fruit margarita prepared by the bartender Christian, which is described as perfect and not overdone with syrup, allowing the tequila flavor to shine. The venue often features live music, adding to the vibrant vibe, though some guests feel the music could better match the lively setting. Overall, Casa Maya is considered one of the best restaurants in the area, especially on weekends when the friendly atmosphere and good food make it a top choice. The restaurant’s own hot sauce is a favorite among guests, and the owner is happy to sell bottles to visitors. Casa Maya remains a popular spot for both casual dining and special gatherings.