Was somewhat disappointing. Menu was small. Food was ok. Nothing exceptional. It was super cold so wear something warm. Service was average; nothing exceptional. Probably wouldn't go back.
Aaron
Forgotten Tonic was very well decorated in a Halloween theme. Our server was nice and attentive. The food and drinks were unique but expensive. It was a fun one-time experience, but I don't think we'll be going back.
kate
Ordered so many things because we couldn't decide but everything was phenomenal! LOVE the staff, LOVE, the food, LOVE the ambiance. Will be back soon!!
Madison
Forgotten Tonic is our favorite place in town. It's our go to place that never disappoints. We had an amazing anniversary dinner with delicious food and great cocktails. Our server Phoebe was phenomenal and personable. We loved the Black Lagoon pop up too!
Kamli
My favorite restaurant in town! Best food, drinks and overall vibe. The hostess and wait staff are always so accommodating. Forgotten Tonic will continue to be my go-to spot. Love it there!
Kelly
I have chosen not to go into details; however, I will never return. Management was involved and attempted to resolve however it was unfixable.
Opentable Diner
I'm so grateful to Forgotten Tonic for offering creative plant-based dishes alongside excellent options for omnivores like my husband. It's so rare for me to find a restaurant where I have more than one truly plant-based option to choose from—and every bite was delicious! We celebrated our 24th anniversary here and had a fantastic experience. We'll definitely be back!
Maria
Our food was magnificent. The service was great and I really enjoyed the atmosphere. We had the Montenegro meatballs as an appetizer. I highly recommend them. And when my pasta special arrived, my first thought was "Wow, that's a small portion", but I was so wrong. The dish was incredibly flavorful and filling. I couldn't even fathom having another drink or dessert. Best meal we've had in a long while.
Helen
I'm so glad we went here. The food was amazing! And the portions were huge! Best service ever!
Chris Niesen
Had an amazing evening at the Forgotten Tonic. The drinks were creative and well made. The food was to die for, we are considering replacing pumpkin pie with pumpkin bread pudding at Thanksgiving this year thanks to our experience. The whole night was enhanced by our lovely server Tamara. She was professional, knowledgeable, and an absolute angel. We will be returning in the future and recommending The Forgotten Tonic to anybody who cares to listen.
My favorite bar in Saint Augustine! The food looks great, but haven’t actually eaten here yet.. The raising Cane cocktail were both wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dave
We enjoyed drinks at the bar and the bartender was just awesome. Great conversation and great drinks. We will be back again just because of him. Next time we will order from the amazing menu!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Braswell
Pricy for what’s offered. $20 for house salad that appears to be a Publix bagged salad. Really nothing special. Other choices looked good. Service was ok but not exceptional - maybe a function of their included service charge. Could have just been an off day, but I have many other favorites in St Augustine to pick from.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Samantha Eaves
The kimchi martini is killer! Great bartenders with both sides of knowledge/skill as well as curiosity/personability. I want to try allll the cocktails here and also enjoy the custom drinks they dream up!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Bree Dietel
Incredible, inventive cocktails and great service. I'm bummed I spent money on the tuna tartare -- just not good at all. But I would go again just to drink!
Was somewhat disappointing. Menu was small. Food was ok. Nothing exceptional. It was super cold so wear something warm. Service was average; nothing exceptional. Probably wouldn't go back.
Forgotten Tonic was very well decorated in a Halloween theme. Our server was nice and attentive. The food and drinks were unique but expensive. It was a fun one-time experience, but I don't think we'll be going back.
Ordered so many things because we couldn't decide but everything was phenomenal! LOVE the staff, LOVE, the food, LOVE the ambiance. Will be back soon!!
Forgotten Tonic is our favorite place in town. It's our go to place that never disappoints. We had an amazing anniversary dinner with delicious food and great cocktails. Our server Phoebe was phenomenal and personable. We loved the Black Lagoon pop up too!
My favorite restaurant in town! Best food, drinks and overall vibe. The hostess and wait staff are always so accommodating. Forgotten Tonic will continue to be my go-to spot. Love it there!
I have chosen not to go into details; however, I will never return. Management was involved and attempted to resolve however it was unfixable.
I'm so grateful to Forgotten Tonic for offering creative plant-based dishes alongside excellent options for omnivores like my husband. It's so rare for me to find a restaurant where I have more than one truly plant-based option to choose from—and every bite was delicious! We celebrated our 24th anniversary here and had a fantastic experience. We'll definitely be back!
Our food was magnificent. The service was great and I really enjoyed the atmosphere. We had the Montenegro meatballs as an appetizer. I highly recommend them. And when my pasta special arrived, my first thought was "Wow, that's a small portion", but I was so wrong. The dish was incredibly flavorful and filling. I couldn't even fathom having another drink or dessert. Best meal we've had in a long while.
I'm so glad we went here. The food was amazing! And the portions were huge! Best service ever!
Had an amazing evening at the Forgotten Tonic. The drinks were creative and well made. The food was to die for, we are considering replacing pumpkin pie with pumpkin bread pudding at Thanksgiving this year thanks to our experience. The whole night was enhanced by our lovely server Tamara. She was professional, knowledgeable, and an absolute angel. We will be returning in the future and recommending The Forgotten Tonic to anybody who cares to listen.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
My favorite bar in Saint Augustine! The food looks great, but haven’t actually eaten here yet.. The raising Cane cocktail were both wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We enjoyed drinks at the bar and the bartender was just awesome. Great conversation and great drinks. We will be back again just because of him. Next time we will order from the amazing menu!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pricy for what’s offered. $20 for house salad that appears to be a Publix bagged salad. Really nothing special. Other choices looked good. Service was ok but not exceptional - maybe a function of their included service charge. Could have just been an off day, but I have many other favorites in St Augustine to pick from.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
The kimchi martini is killer! Great bartenders with both sides of knowledge/skill as well as curiosity/personability. I want to try allll the cocktails here and also enjoy the custom drinks they dream up!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Incredible, inventive cocktails and great service. I'm bummed I spent money on the tuna tartare -- just not good at all. But I would go again just to drink!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Loading...