Peace Pie
$$ • Ice CreamAbout Peace Pie
Customers' Favorites
Salted Caramel Apple Ice Cream Sandwich
Chocolate Mint Ice Cream Sandwich
Boston Cream Cookies N' Cream
S'Mores - Regular Price
Salted Caramel Brownie
Peanut Butter Cup
Key Lime Pie
Cookie Dough
Peace Pies
Rocky Road
Peace Pie Reviews
231 ratings
Share your opinion about Peace Pie
Great place. Quick in and out and well organized. Menu is tricky to find online, but here are the flavors in Oct 2022.
Absolutely delicious!!! This has become a must stop for my family every time we’re in Cape May!!!
My personal favorite is the pecan pie, a shortbread cookie and pecan ice cream covered with molasses and cinnamon!!!! 😋
My personal favorite is the pecan pie, a shortbread cookie and pecan ice cream covered with molasses and cinnamon!!!! 😋
This place in Cape May is amazing!! The owner is a super awesome guy with great ethics! The ice cream sandwiches are a MUST HAVE!!!! We have already mail ordered twice and they come super well packaged and frozen in dry ice!! THIS STUFF IS THE BOMB AND A MUST HAVE IN CAPE MAY!! ❤️❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥
Hours
| Monday | 2 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 2 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 2 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 2 - 9PM |
| Friday | 12 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
Peace Pie, located in downtown St. Augustine, is a delightful treat. This ice cream sandwich shop offers a variety of flavors, including coconut cream pie and Pecan Pie with caramel Vanilla ice cream. With a cute and cozy atmosphere and colorful wall paintings by owner Mary Rose, it's a must-visit spot for those looking for a sweet treat while exploring the historic district. The ice cream sandwiches are huge, with cookie grahams that have a perfect crunch and soft chewiness balance. Friendly staff share ghost stories and local history, making it more than just an average ice cream parlor. Great value and a destination pick, though gluten-free options are currently limited.