Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine - Murabella
5330 FL-16, St. Augustine
(904) 788-7900
Customers' Favorites
Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Build Your Own Calzone
Appetizers and Salads
Build Your Own Pizza
Holy Shiitake Pie
GF Veg Out Pizza
Funky Q Chicken
Pretzel Bites
Chicken Wings
Meatball Trio
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We like Mellow Mushroom and have been to several different locations. This one was skimpy on the topping for us. So I just took off one star. As for the atmosphere: I’ve always enjoyed each individual restaurant. Our waitress was on top of everything even tho she had to do table while also running the bar.
Victoria Marie was absolutely amazing! She made me so many unique drinks I’d never even heard of — from pumpkin beer with Fireball to a chocolate Old Fashioned, Godiva Mojito, Pixie Stix, and even a Banana Bread Margarita. Every one was incredible! Hands down the best bartender in town. I had such a great time and will definitely be back!
The Mellow Mushroom is very good, especially their appetizers such as garlic bread with beer cheese or pretzel bites with beer cheese and I recommend extra beer cheese. My only recommendation is to check your bag because they have been known to forget the extra paid for items. The calzones are ok but do not have much ricotta and you cannot pay for extra. I do not recommend the brownie. It is very expensive for what it is (and I am one that pays for good food). The brownie is so...
You May Also Like
Zaxbys Chicken Fingers & Buffalo Wings - 5350 FL-16
![]()
Chicken, Fast Food, Salad, Chicken Wings
McDonald's - 103 Tuscan Way
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers, Coffee & Tea
Pizza Hut - 52 Tuscan Way #208
![]()
Chicken Wings, Pizza, Fast Food, Italian