Though cash only, this spot serves up the best pizza I've ever had. Definitely recommend
Jessica Teter
Born in PA, live in GA, I yearn & crave for good authentic pizza!!! Visiting FL we came across this place and I KNEW they were it!! The pizza available in the display alone was to die for... but the actual slices and the garlic knots and the dipping marinara sauce was truly to die for. Yes, its a little pricey, but what isn't in FL?! You actually get a giant serving !! CASH ONLY!!! The guy taking my order was polite and the line and process is organized and quick... their system works well and IDK if it was pops, the owner or what, but he was a true Italian and was so kind and gave my child a free soda and it was just awesome!!! The marinara dipping sauce alone, 🤤. Pizza!!! Knots!! Thank you for serving us and satisfying my deepest craving from back home.... now I need a sub... what ya say🥰
NoSoup4You
Right off the pedestrian historic district... Pretty authentic NY pizza by the slice, all the meat pizza was excellent, cheese is high quality mozzarella 👍🏻 garlic rolls were very good. Small treek salads were excellent. Potato ball with red sauce was meh... I would skip that, along with Sicilian pizza with free mozzarella, the pizza is better. Everything else was great. My only complaint was the price gouge on soda - $5 for a soft drink? Way too much! While I enjoyed dinner, it would be 4 stars if the drinks were reasonable (disappointing!).
Christopher Daly
If your looking for great pizza in St Augustine, look no further. Truly the best pizza I've had in Florida in a long time. But bring cash as they didn't take credit cards.
Bobby Sack
i paid $20.77 for 2 slices of very normal pizza, what a rip off
Tony Jenkins
EXPENSIVE SLICE! Honestly not worth the price. Over 8 bucks for a margherita slice. They don’t even have Parmesan to sprinkle. I understand higher prices due to the are but obviously a cheap tourist trap.
Donna Deck
Omg the pizza was the best I've had in Florida like I was in Brooklyn!
Ezra Kuhr
Big skip. Super overrated and even more expensive. They have a variety of premade slices that has been sitting out for god knows how long that they’ll heat up for you at $10 per slice. Save your money. I wouldn’t go back.
Simon
$10 a slice? Better be the best pizza you’ve ever had…. Unfortunately not. Maybe ok for a quick solve of plain, other than that, it’s a no for me. Cash only
Rebecca M
This is what Italian food should taste like!!! Phenomenal pizza, garlic knots and potato ball! Soooo goooddd! I highly recommend!
I did not like the service at all! They are extremely abusive with customer service!! And to top it off, a hair on the pizza! I do not recommend it at all!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Nancy Marquez
The mistreatment, bad service and arrogance of the owner and manager of the premises is the worst I have ever seen. Since the lines are very long, the owner thinks he owns the world. I went with my family, when I sat at a table the manager approached me and yelled at me horribly, telling me that I couldn't sit down without the pizza in my hand, I told him my husband is paying for this by hitting the table and he didn't care who he was with. The children grabbed my arm and told me to leave the premises. I really had a super miserable time, it's a place to never return to.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Jesus Dario Anez
The worst moment of my life. After waiting in a long line to buy food for my wife and my aunt, an elderly lady, they sat at a table while I paid and waited for the food. The waiter rudely approached them, yelling and telling them to leave. When I realized what was happening, I went to see what was going on, and the same waiter came to me aggressively, without caring that I was with my 10-year-old son, who started crying. As all the other tables turned to see the commotion, the restaurant owner came out and told us to leave, saying he would refund our money because “there are plenty of people in line, and I don't care about the situation.” Honestly, that place should be shut down for such disrespect toward women.
The worst moment in my life. After a long queue to buy my bride and I had a lady from the third party and they met at a table while I was paying and they entreated me the lady and the beggar spoke in a big way and asked her grittily. At the end of the day I was to see what day it was and the little mesonero was the first time I cared that I was with my 10 year old son who I can cry about and when all the meals stopped before me I went up to the restaurant saying that we were going to meet them we donated the money “that many people do the truth is that the situation doesn't matter to you, "in truth they should try to avoid the respect to the ladies
The worst moment of my life. After a long line to buy something for my wife and aunt, an elderly lady sat at a table while I paid and waited for my food to be delivered. The waiter stopped them rudely, shouting at them. When I noticed this, I went to see what was happening, and the same waiter lashed out at me, not caring that I was with my 10-year-old son, who started crying. When all the tables stood up to see what was happening, the owner of the restaurant came out saying we had to leave, that he would give us our money back, and adding, “I have a lot of people in line and I don't care about the situation.” Really, that place should be shut down for the lack of respect towards women.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Juan Anez
People are really rude in here pls don’t come here
Though cash only, this spot serves up the best pizza I've ever had. Definitely recommend
Born in PA, live in GA, I yearn & crave for good authentic pizza!!! Visiting FL we came across this place and I KNEW they were it!! The pizza available in the display alone was to die for... but the actual slices and the garlic knots and the dipping marinara sauce was truly to die for. Yes, its a little pricey, but what isn't in FL?! You actually get a giant serving !! CASH ONLY!!! The guy taking my order was polite and the line and process is organized and quick... their system works well and IDK if it was pops, the owner or what, but he was a true Italian and was so kind and gave my child a free soda and it was just awesome!!! The marinara dipping sauce alone, 🤤. Pizza!!! Knots!! Thank you for serving us and satisfying my deepest craving from back home.... now I need a sub... what ya say🥰
Right off the pedestrian historic district... Pretty authentic NY pizza by the slice, all the meat pizza was excellent, cheese is high quality mozzarella 👍🏻 garlic rolls were very good. Small treek salads were excellent. Potato ball with red sauce was meh... I would skip that, along with Sicilian pizza with free mozzarella, the pizza is better. Everything else was great. My only complaint was the price gouge on soda - $5 for a soft drink? Way too much! While I enjoyed dinner, it would be 4 stars if the drinks were reasonable (disappointing!).
If your looking for great pizza in St Augustine, look no further. Truly the best pizza I've had in Florida in a long time. But bring cash as they didn't take credit cards.
i paid $20.77 for 2 slices of very normal pizza, what a rip off
EXPENSIVE SLICE! Honestly not worth the price. Over 8 bucks for a margherita slice. They don’t even have Parmesan to sprinkle. I understand higher prices due to the are but obviously a cheap tourist trap.
Omg the pizza was the best I've had in Florida like I was in Brooklyn!
Big skip. Super overrated and even more expensive. They have a variety of premade slices that has been sitting out for god knows how long that they’ll heat up for you at $10 per slice. Save your money. I wouldn’t go back.
$10 a slice? Better be the best pizza you’ve ever had…. Unfortunately not. Maybe ok for a quick solve of plain, other than that, it’s a no for me. Cash only
This is what Italian food should taste like!!! Phenomenal pizza, garlic knots and potato ball! Soooo goooddd! I highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Really good pie. I’ll give it a 7.8.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I did not like the service at all! They are extremely abusive with customer service!! And to top it off, a hair on the pizza! I do not recommend it at all!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The mistreatment, bad service and arrogance of the owner and manager of the premises is the worst I have ever seen. Since the lines are very long, the owner thinks he owns the world. I went with my family, when I sat at a table the manager approached me and yelled at me horribly, telling me that I couldn't sit down without the pizza in my hand, I told him my husband is paying for this by hitting the table and he didn't care who he was with. The children grabbed my arm and told me to leave the premises. I really had a super miserable time, it's a place to never return to.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
The worst moment of my life. After waiting in a long line to buy food for my wife and my aunt, an elderly lady, they sat at a table while I paid and waited for the food. The waiter rudely approached them, yelling and telling them to leave. When I realized what was happening, I went to see what was going on, and the same waiter came to me aggressively, without caring that I was with my 10-year-old son, who started crying. As all the other tables turned to see the commotion, the restaurant owner came out and told us to leave, saying he would refund our money because “there are plenty of people in line, and I don't care about the situation.” Honestly, that place should be shut down for such disrespect toward women.
The worst moment in my life. After a long queue to buy my bride and I had a lady from the third party and they met at a table while I was paying and they entreated me the lady and the beggar spoke in a big way and asked her grittily. At the end of the day I was to see what day it was and the little mesonero was the first time I cared that I was with my 10 year old son who I can cry about and when all the meals stopped before me I went up to the restaurant saying that we were going to meet them we donated the money “that many people do the truth is that the situation doesn't matter to you, "in truth they should try to avoid the respect to the ladies
The worst moment of my life. After a long line to buy something for my wife and aunt, an elderly lady sat at a table while I paid and waited for my food to be delivered. The waiter stopped them rudely, shouting at them. When I noticed this, I went to see what was happening, and the same waiter lashed out at me, not caring that I was with my 10-year-old son, who started crying. When all the tables stood up to see what was happening, the owner of the restaurant came out saying we had to leave, that he would give us our money back, and adding, “I have a lot of people in line and I don't care about the situation.” Really, that place should be shut down for the lack of respect towards women.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
People are really rude in here pls don’t come here
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...