A Slice of Paradise
$ • Pizza, Italian, Vegan
Hours:
24458 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key
(305) 744-9718
About A Slice of Paradise
Customers' Favorites
A Slice of Paradise Reviews
Share your opinion about A Slice of Paradise
Just ordered a large pizza a garden salad, boneless wings and garlic nots. $80 of the worst food I’ve ever eaten. Pizza was soggy. The garden salad consist of Romain lettuce a hint of spinach most of it was yellow a bad tomato soft croutons and 2 pieces of onion. The boneless wings were just horrible, burnt and tasted like they had been cooked hours ago. Garlic nots dry and no garlic taste and the marinara was gross as well! Again $80 and didn’t even eat it! Never again. 🤢🤢...read full review
Absolutely disgusting. Cold pizza and my chicken was burnt. Don’t waste your time
The Best Pizza in town, if you are looking for the best tasting pizza come to this place you wont be disappointed!
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
People in Summerland Key Also Viewed
A Slice of Paradise is a cozy, canal-side restaurant that offers delightful pizza and other delicacies. The pizzas, including the popular pepperoni option, showcase unique flavors with a standout crust and sausage. Calzones are also a hit among customers. While some items like chicken tenders and breadsticks may not impress, the pizzas consistently satisfy. This gem is perfect for a quick lunch or takeout, with limited outdoor seating, allowing guests to enjoy a slice by the canal or on the go.
The restaurant has received mixed reviews, with some customers reporting issues with the cooking and pricing, while others praise the improved quality and friendly service. The third-party app used for ordering has been acknowledged as misleading, and the restaurant has admitted to this. Customers are advised to communicate their preferences, such as requesting a "well-done" pizza, to ensure a satisfactory dining experience.
The restaurant has received positive reviews for its food, with customers praising the perfect crust and variety of flavors, including meat lovers, four cheese, margarita, and pepperoni. The outdoor seating by the marina has also been highlighted as a pleasant dining experience. However, some customers have found the crust to be bland, suggesting the need for more seasoning in the dough.