Brickyard Pizzeria

Really lives up to the hype from the Tally pizza bracket!

BEST NY style Pizza in Tally, hands down! Calzones are great, too...

Felt like the staff was extremely rude for no reason.

The food was ok... no real complaints... but nothing great or exceptional... there is no dine in.. a surprise...note.. sign is missing on the front of building and at the street but Google maps was accurate

Is a little to expensive for what it is

This place is only for takeout and it is far above average. The cost is up there, but it’s worth it. The food is delicious. The pizzas are to die for and the Greek salad is amazing. Literally everything on their menu is delicious.

The slice is the bomb and there's more to the place than pizza TV games on TV. Don't take my word for it

Despite the information on Google maps, the picture, the check mark next to "dine in", this restaurant does NOT have dine in. I, along with two others following me, drove up there from the middle of town through all that horrendous traffic only to find out there was no seating. Great. We went down the road to Red Elephant and had a great sit down dinner. Update your info people, do better. I won't eat from here no matter how good the food.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Disgusting, will never eat there again. Woke up throwing up. Got the calzone with pepperoni and it was filled with grease, loaded up with way too much cheese. Not my cup of tea idk how people eat here

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

The best NY style pizza in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

2 medium pizzas, individual greek salad and 6 garlic "knots" ( actually just rolls from the grocery store ). But $70? Not including the TEN dollar delivery fee. Plus an hour and half wait. Do better. And if you are reading this, don't waste your time or money.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Pizza

Best pie in Tallahassee. I love a number of pizza joints in town, and I had never heard of brickyard (no idea why), but it's right by the house amd I gave it a try. It is now our ONLY pizza that we get.

My son always wants to do the Dave Portnoy "1 bite" rules when rating pizza, so we ordered the specialty cheese, with crispy crust last night.

I scored it a 9.1 (my no 1 in town) and my son scored it 9.5 (his highest score ever)

Zero bend in the crust, not greasy, fantastic flavor.

Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Meatball, Pizza

Use to be very good, but unfortunately I think they switched to premade crusts :(

Food: 3

Service: 5

One of the best ,

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calzone, Meatball

My wife and I came here based on other positive reviews. Our experience did not match the other reviews. The veggies on our pizza weren’t fresh and the “garlic knots” were bland. Canned ingredients on “Authentic Italian” pizza is not a good look.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2