Gaines Street Pies

Can we give this 6 or 7 stars??? I need this in Texas!?!? We stopped in Tallahassee for the night, on our way to Orlando. Our favorite part of our road trips, is finding places to eat we can’t find at home. And pizza is my husband’s fave. I don’t normally gravitate to pizza, but this menu had my attention! We ordered the Honey Pig and and pepperoni with marinated portabella mushrooms. These were, simply put, the best pizzas we have had to date on a road trip! Hands down! If I could come back through on the way home and order two more to take home, I would! Awesome job, KEEP GOING!!!!! And whoever is reading reviews , trying to decide, JUST ORDER IT! You won’t be disappointed!

Wow, this place has went downhill. The Pizza is gross. The staff seems very unhappy. Seems like very poor management.

love love love the calzones <3 front of house staff is super nice & it’s clean!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This restaurant lost us as loyal customers today. I cannot eat gluten or dairy but I love pizza. We have been ordering from here a couple times a month as it’s the best gf/dairy free I’ve found in town. Every once in a while they mess up and give me mozzarella instead of vegan cheese. This happened a couple weeks ago and at the time it was handled beautifully. They cooked the pizza over again and sent their driver to deliver the remake free of charge. I was super grateful that they had been so accommodating and they explained there was a new cook that had messed up. Fast forward to today, we ordered a gf/df pizza for me and was told on the phone it would be ready in 15-20 minutes. My boyfriend shows up about 25 minutes later and when going to the register to pay and pickup the pizza he was told by the young lady working there that he hadn’t paid for any of the pizzas from our previous order and that the pizza that was incorrect last time was actually correct and we we’re essentially lying. He was made to pay for the previous order and the current order, including the pizza they had supposedly given us to make up for the one that was made incorrectly. Also, they hadn’t even made the current order and had him sit there waiting for 25 minutes AFTER the pizza should have been ready. I’ll be finding a new pizza restaurant, being treated awfully for the restaurant’s mistakes is not something I’m willing to tolerate.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Waited over an hour in the restaurant for a cold pizza. Then was lied too about it. AND then when asked why the pizza was cold got a huge attitude and then some employee had the audacity to say some rude remark under her breath as she walked by. Yeah i spent 70 dollars on this order and wanna make sure its right. Lmao

If i could give a 0 star review this would be it

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Absolute garbage lol, such a bad experience I can’t even type it all out. Will never ever be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The pizza that we order here is always good, my only complaint with this place is that the hummus platter is always served different, there is no consistency. This time I got 3 slices of cucumber last time the dough was raw. They will give me platters with only a few of the different toppings or much more than needed. Other than that, the food here is pretty good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheesy Bread, The Cheesecake Calzone

I stopped here on my way to the airport because I was craving pizza. I’m so glad I stopped! I got the special with two pizzas and a drink. I ordered both the pepperoni and the sausage. They were SO good, hot, and delicious. I’ll definitely stop back there the next time I’m in Tallahassee!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Slice

Excellent pizza and ingredients. Garlic knots could have had more seasoning but given the special, we felt were a good compromise.

If I could be critical, I'd ask to ditch the paper straws. Nobody does this anymore, people hate them, the get soggy, stick to your lips and get droopy.

A solution is to bring your own I guess, or collect them from Starbucks or something and keep them in your glovebox.

Decor was fine, staff was prompt and polite. Plenty of clean bathrooms (Surprisingly cleaner than a competitor....Paisanos)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome pizza!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice

The individual with lavender hair who took our order today seemed to be annoyed to take our order. While eating our food, the same individual was sweeping the floor and used the broom to sweep off the table next to us. We lost our appetite, and I asked for a manager to bring this up but there wasn't one available for the pizza side so I'm writing this with the hopes the management team sees this.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

We just tried this place out for the first time. All I can say is wow! This is hands down the best pizza I've ever had. When I think of what a pizza should be, what they are serving is what comes to mind. I don't want pizza from anywhere else. I've been looking for in a pizza place of this caliber for so long, and didn't realize it was right around the corner. I want quit my job and work for you guys. Bravo!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots

Extremely overpriced pie, hope you don't enjoy sauce on your pizza either cause there won't be any. Low quality ingredients on even lower quality pizza dough... please please save your money and don't waste it on the God awful pizza.

Pizza was okay, and the server brought out the order promptly.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

My most recent experience here wasn't the best, I split an eighteen inch pepperoni pie and I was surprised to see how thin the slices were, they were paper thin! Like I ordered thin crust. I remember their slices being thicker a few years ago. Also they really skimped on the pepperoni, they could've put more on the pie, $3.50 extra for pepperoni and they barely put any on. The amount they put on was NOT worth the extra charge, Shrinkflation? I won't be going back, I'll just make pizza at home.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3