I've Always loved Papa Johns, but I've never been to this location as I recently moved to this area of town. And I have to say unfortunately, that it was the worst pizza I have ever had in my entire life. The crust was so burnt yet rubbery that we couldn't even eat it. We had to pull the toppings off and eat them, which had absolutely no flavor and since the pizza was overcooked, the stuffed crust was terrible. I don't hardly ever order out anymore as I'm a widow on a very low income, So I was splurging and ultimately spent, including delivery fee and tip, $25 on one large pizza that was horrible. I should've just saved my money and bought groceries with that. I've learned my lesson.... don't go back to Papa Johns.
Food: 1
Abraham Sumler
Parking: I would say it just needs to be redone.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Epic Stuffed Crust Create Your Own Pizza, Italian Papadia, The Meats Pizza, BBQ Chicken Bacon Papadia, Papadias
Joshua Durden
Got a pizza that tasted slightly "off" but figured it could have been anything. That anything turned out to be the ingredients being bad. I spent the night rushing to the bathroom a few times with a sharp pain in my stomach and explosive diarrhea.For a place that pretends to have fresh ingredients and charges a premium price compared to other "fast food" pizza places, the quality is no where what you'd expect. I'd rather pay the extra few dollars and get pizza from a local place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Nada
I really appreciate the manager (Q) she really gave us exceptional service and very fresh tasty pizza as a replacement for night shift which I dbt knw why it tasted so funny. But I called and let her know how the service was last night and she took care of it like the great person/management should. Very nice/professional and didn't give us any issues. I will make sure to order in the daytime while she's there because the pizzas she sent were so gd I can't even explain it. Even the pepperchinis were fresh vs last night they were bitter and dry. She made sure everything was fresh! You are definitely a great manager and advancement for this company. Thankx again Q....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathy Duval
Ordered for a church dinner. Service was great and on time, very pleased!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thomas Jaffrė
Very goodCheap
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gail Fuhrman
Delivery was wrong topping and wrong dipping
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: ESC Create Your Own
Todd Twilley
Email said 30 minutes. After 1 hour tracker said 4 hours. No one will answer the phone to cancel order. Update: Pizza arrived at room temperature and without any sauce, for which extra was ordered and paid. So taking money without providing anything of value = theft.
Food: 2
Service: 1
M J
Pizza not as good as it once was. Been 3 years since I had papa John's and I didn't miss it. 1 perk from them is they include garlic butter with each
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
stacy timmons
Manger Darrel is beyond rude …. I’m a door dasher after waiting 25 mins on an order he told me would take 5-8 I if mins I began to become frustrated …. I let the nice lady up front know I was becoming frustrated an trying to stay calm as I do have mental health issues I deal with an I was staring to feel very triggered….. I was talking with her when Darrell approached an inserted HIMself in OUR conversation telling me I could leave they were busy….. I asked the nice lady if anything I said offended her in any ways in which she replied NO. I then stated I’d be calling the general manager an corporate offices to inform them of this injustice ….. Mr Darrell must of felt some type of way , I asked him several times to stop speaking to me a trying to have to have the last word . It’s like he was trying to prove me to get out of character! I even stated that!!! The lobby was full of customers by the way…the customers food was ready Darrell refused to give the food to me to be delivered causing the customers food to now become cold…. And get this I was thrown out of the store . Darrell wouldn’t even answer the phone for door dash so the order could be cancelled on my end from being the delivery driver … I arrived here @ 6:45 pm Wednesday night am still here at7:20 an I can’t leave til the order has been cancelled….. but Darrell won’t answer the papa John phone for doordash even after I went an nicely ask him …if you hate your job Darrell just say that !!! I hope u have better days an learn to deal with stressful situations better than I what witness tonight … unless you trespass me you will see me again, so next time u better act right or it’s gonna be the same thing. Darrell stop trying to have the last word , that don’t make you or what your saying right…. A good manger knows how to be a leader , that was leadership I seen ?Even your store rep said you was dead wrong …. Ijs do better or get a better job that doesn’t have you so stressed out that you take it out on your customers or drivers …. One thing about it you’ll need me to deliver for you again , to be honest that’s gonna be a order I decline . Do better Darrell papa John’s needs to hire better mangers all the store talk about how bad the Monroe an tharp location is ….. Word gets aroundUpdate : last night anther door dasher who was present during this escapade can into me at another location an asked me if I was alright after all that…. People notice ……
Normally this location does a good job, tonight was awful. We were given a very thin crust made from dough that was way past blown. We had ordered the new "epic" garlic stuffed crust. Not epic, pathetic at best. The gentleman who first helped me and said he was going to make my pizza was rude and still had not done so 30 minutes later. The young lady who did eventually make it, wrong and poorly made as it was, was an absolute gem.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Kevin Edwards
Visiting the Tallahassee area and had a craving for pizza. This Store was the closest to our Hotel. We ordered carry out and received our pizza hot and fresh when we returned to our room. Awesome job! The pizza was what we expect when ordering from Papa John's. The friendly "Young" lady working the Front counter has a great attitude and is a great customer service face for the Location. I would order again from this store on N. Monroe should I ever visit again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ja Quell Cox-Howard
Pizza was good but it's a hit or miss on this place. It just depends on who is working and who makes your pizza that day. We've ordered here several times and I can honestly say that my pizza has not always been what we were expecting but I can say that it's never been to the point where we wanted to take it back or not eat it. Just depends on who makes it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Juan G
Service is great but pizza isn't. Marco's and Costco pizza still above
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Kathie
I always love a good Papa John's pizza! Get extra sauce, it is delish!
I've Always loved Papa Johns, but I've never been to this location as I recently moved to this area of town. And I have to say unfortunately, that it was the worst pizza I have ever had in my entire life. The crust was so burnt yet rubbery that we couldn't even eat it. We had to pull the toppings off and eat them, which had absolutely no flavor and since the pizza was overcooked, the stuffed crust was terrible. I don't hardly ever order out anymore as I'm a widow on a very low income, So I was splurging and ultimately spent, including delivery fee and tip, $25 on one large pizza that was horrible. I should've just saved my money and bought groceries with that. I've learned my lesson.... don't go back to Papa Johns.
Food: 1
Parking: I would say it just needs to be redone.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Epic Stuffed Crust Create Your Own Pizza, Italian Papadia, The Meats Pizza, BBQ Chicken Bacon Papadia, Papadias
Got a pizza that tasted slightly "off" but figured it could have been anything. That anything turned out to be the ingredients being bad. I spent the night rushing to the bathroom a few times with a sharp pain in my stomach and explosive diarrhea.For a place that pretends to have fresh ingredients and charges a premium price compared to other "fast food" pizza places, the quality is no where what you'd expect. I'd rather pay the extra few dollars and get pizza from a local place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
I really appreciate the manager (Q) she really gave us exceptional service and very fresh tasty pizza as a replacement for night shift which I dbt knw why it tasted so funny. But I called and let her know how the service was last night and she took care of it like the great person/management should. Very nice/professional and didn't give us any issues. I will make sure to order in the daytime while she's there because the pizzas she sent were so gd I can't even explain it. Even the pepperchinis were fresh vs last night they were bitter and dry. She made sure everything was fresh! You are definitely a great manager and advancement for this company. Thankx again Q....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered for a church dinner. Service was great and on time, very pleased!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very goodCheap
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delivery was wrong topping and wrong dipping
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: ESC Create Your Own
Email said 30 minutes. After 1 hour tracker said 4 hours. No one will answer the phone to cancel order. Update: Pizza arrived at room temperature and without any sauce, for which extra was ordered and paid. So taking money without providing anything of value = theft.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Pizza not as good as it once was. Been 3 years since I had papa John's and I didn't miss it. 1 perk from them is they include garlic butter with each
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
Manger Darrel is beyond rude …. I’m a door dasher after waiting 25 mins on an order he told me would take 5-8 I if mins I began to become frustrated …. I let the nice lady up front know I was becoming frustrated an trying to stay calm as I do have mental health issues I deal with an I was staring to feel very triggered….. I was talking with her when Darrell approached an inserted HIMself in OUR conversation telling me I could leave they were busy….. I asked the nice lady if anything I said offended her in any ways in which she replied NO. I then stated I’d be calling the general manager an corporate offices to inform them of this injustice ….. Mr Darrell must of felt some type of way , I asked him several times to stop speaking to me a trying to have to have the last word . It’s like he was trying to prove me to get out of character! I even stated that!!! The lobby was full of customers by the way…the customers food was ready Darrell refused to give the food to me to be delivered causing the customers food to now become cold…. And get this I was thrown out of the store . Darrell wouldn’t even answer the phone for door dash so the order could be cancelled on my end from being the delivery driver … I arrived here @ 6:45 pm Wednesday night am still here at7:20 an I can’t leave til the order has been cancelled….. but Darrell won’t answer the papa John phone for doordash even after I went an nicely ask him …if you hate your job Darrell just say that !!! I hope u have better days an learn to deal with stressful situations better than I what witness tonight … unless you trespass me you will see me again, so next time u better act right or it’s gonna be the same thing. Darrell stop trying to have the last word , that don’t make you or what your saying right…. A good manger knows how to be a leader , that was leadership I seen ?Even your store rep said you was dead wrong …. Ijs do better or get a better job that doesn’t have you so stressed out that you take it out on your customers or drivers …. One thing about it you’ll need me to deliver for you again , to be honest that’s gonna be a order I decline . Do better Darrell papa John’s needs to hire better mangers all the store talk about how bad the Monroe an tharp location is ….. Word gets aroundUpdate : last night anther door dasher who was present during this escapade can into me at another location an asked me if I was alright after all that…. People notice ……
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Normally this location does a good job, tonight was awful. We were given a very thin crust made from dough that was way past blown. We had ordered the new "epic" garlic stuffed crust. Not epic, pathetic at best. The gentleman who first helped me and said he was going to make my pizza was rude and still had not done so 30 minutes later. The young lady who did eventually make it, wrong and poorly made as it was, was an absolute gem.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Visiting the Tallahassee area and had a craving for pizza. This Store was the closest to our Hotel. We ordered carry out and received our pizza hot and fresh when we returned to our room. Awesome job! The pizza was what we expect when ordering from Papa John's. The friendly "Young" lady working the Front counter has a great attitude and is a great customer service face for the Location. I would order again from this store on N. Monroe should I ever visit again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was good but it's a hit or miss on this place. It just depends on who is working and who makes your pizza that day. We've ordered here several times and I can honestly say that my pizza has not always been what we were expecting but I can say that it's never been to the point where we wanted to take it back or not eat it. Just depends on who makes it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Service is great but pizza isn't. Marco's and Costco pizza still above
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
I always love a good Papa John's pizza! Get extra sauce, it is delish!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Pepperoni Pizza