I've had the opportunity to be at Paisano's a couple of times, and the level of quality is unmatched. I've tried a couple things on the menu and I've never been disappointed with my decisions. It's always a relaxing atmosphere; never too loud or sounding like a library. Even when they were first open, the service itself seemed as if they had been open for a dozen years. I have yet to be disappointed and look forward to the next opportunity I get to return.
Carson T.
Went to the plaza to get froyo, and we couldn't ignore the smell coming from piesanos. So we decided to check them out and we can't stop going back now. Can't recommend enough
Dan L.
Fantastic! The food was amazing, the service was great, and the place has a nice ambiance. It was Friday night and the place was hoppin. They quoted us a 25 minute wait but we actually got seated on under 10. We will be back soon!
David Y.
I'll be darn, that was some good food. The waiter Joey was amazing, very helpful and great to talk with. Service was also fantastic
Leah H.
I was looking forward to trying this place. I ordered the 12 inch deluxe pizza in thin crust. I ordered it to go and asked for ricotta to be added on it. The pizza looked great. Some of the edges were burnt, but I understand that happens with thin crust pizzas that have more than a couple of toppings on them. I noticed that they did not give me the ricotta that I paid for ($5 to have ricotta added, by the way is bonkers!), but the cashier was accommodating and sent the pizza back. At that point, they put on too much, but I appreciate them trying to accommodate me. Overall the pizza tasted good and I look forward to going back and trying entrées on their menu.
E. P.
A very good addition to Tallahassee. The menu is varied and good. More attention needs to be given to training the wait staff.
Sara C.
Had dinner here two days ago. Wish I could do 2.5 stars...3 seems generous. Good service but food was meh... Best dish we ordered was the meatball appetizer. Calamari was ok and the supreme pizza was fine. Rigatoni alla vodka was really disappointing. Noodles were cooked perfectly but the sauce was thin and lacking flavor. Felt like a total waste of calories to eat. Unfortunate because we ordered that particular dish based on a recommendation. They also never gave us the complimentary rolls, but we didn't realize until after we left. Hopefully it was just an off night, because the reviews have been so good!
Francisco San Juan
I was at the restaurant for a birthday dinner and it was 6 of us but they didn’t accommodate us the food was cold the chicken cover cooked and the waiter never replenish the drinksAs we were leaving they accommodate a party of 8 with no problem moving tables and made it happenThanks for ruining our special day will never go back again
Overpriced for the quality/portions of food and service. Food lacked flavor, waitress needs more training. Whole family agreed this is a place we won't be returning to. Bought into the hype and came away disappointed.
My husband and I went for the first time this weekend. The food was awesome especially the Calamari, Buffalo Chicken pizza, and the Meat Eater Pizza (with jalapeños). We also enjoyed the Cucumber Lemonade. It was so refreshing. Our waitress Isabel was amazing. After we told her it was our first time there, she made sure we were satisfied with everything. Definitely love the atmosphere. And of course, I had to check out the bar and definitely loved the set up. We definitely will be going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari, Garlic Rolls
Mike Joyner
Get the meatball
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Travis Williams
Service was a nightmare. Management seems to be a toxic affair. Did not get the impression that the servers had really any direction. We had four different ones cycle through before they finally settled on one. The food was fine. Not bad. Better than pizza hut. I'd recommend Solle's pizza. Not sure about THEIR service but the food there would be worth walking over broken glass for.Parking: They share a parking lot with Publix so plenty of spaces most of the time.Kid-friendliness: They have good fries and chicken tenders for the youths.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Garlic Broc Cappellini
Pat Rusnak
Restaurant is immaculately clean and organized. The pizza is absolutely delicious, and the rolls with dipping sauce were great. There were ample servers, allowing for minimal wait time. Our server, Christina G., was very personable and attentive. Dining at Piesano’s was a very positive experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Rolls, Pepperoni Pizza
Amy B.
They were very busy when I was there. I walked in and got food to go, medium pizza with pineapple. The pineapple was in large chunks but generous. It tasted really good. I didn't eat in but there was a line in the separate take out area. The dining area looked nice although it was packed.
I've had the opportunity to be at Paisano's a couple of times, and the level of quality is unmatched. I've tried a couple things on the menu and I've never been disappointed with my decisions. It's always a relaxing atmosphere; never too loud or sounding like a library. Even when they were first open, the service itself seemed as if they had been open for a dozen years. I have yet to be disappointed and look forward to the next opportunity I get to return.
Went to the plaza to get froyo, and we couldn't ignore the smell coming from piesanos. So we decided to check them out and we can't stop going back now. Can't recommend enough
Fantastic! The food was amazing, the service was great, and the place has a nice ambiance. It was Friday night and the place was hoppin. They quoted us a 25 minute wait but we actually got seated on under 10. We will be back soon!
I'll be darn, that was some good food. The waiter Joey was amazing, very helpful and great to talk with. Service was also fantastic
I was looking forward to trying this place. I ordered the 12 inch deluxe pizza in thin crust. I ordered it to go and asked for ricotta to be added on it. The pizza looked great. Some of the edges were burnt, but I understand that happens with thin crust pizzas that have more than a couple of toppings on them. I noticed that they did not give me the ricotta that I paid for ($5 to have ricotta added, by the way is bonkers!), but the cashier was accommodating and sent the pizza back. At that point, they put on too much, but I appreciate them trying to accommodate me. Overall the pizza tasted good and I look forward to going back and trying entrées on their menu.
A very good addition to Tallahassee. The menu is varied and good. More attention needs to be given to training the wait staff.
Had dinner here two days ago. Wish I could do 2.5 stars...3 seems generous. Good service but food was meh... Best dish we ordered was the meatball appetizer. Calamari was ok and the supreme pizza was fine. Rigatoni alla vodka was really disappointing. Noodles were cooked perfectly but the sauce was thin and lacking flavor. Felt like a total waste of calories to eat. Unfortunate because we ordered that particular dish based on a recommendation. They also never gave us the complimentary rolls, but we didn't realize until after we left. Hopefully it was just an off night, because the reviews have been so good!
I was at the restaurant for a birthday dinner and it was 6 of us but they didn’t accommodate us the food was cold the chicken cover cooked and the waiter never replenish the drinksAs we were leaving they accommodate a party of 8 with no problem moving tables and made it happenThanks for ruining our special day will never go back again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Parmesan
Wonderful!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Overpriced for the quality/portions of food and service. Food lacked flavor, waitress needs more training. Whole family agreed this is a place we won't be returning to. Bought into the hype and came away disappointed.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband and I went for the first time this weekend. The food was awesome especially the Calamari, Buffalo Chicken pizza, and the Meat Eater Pizza (with jalapeños). We also enjoyed the Cucumber Lemonade. It was so refreshing. Our waitress Isabel was amazing. After we told her it was our first time there, she made sure we were satisfied with everything. Definitely love the atmosphere. And of course, I had to check out the bar and definitely loved the set up. We definitely will be going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari, Garlic Rolls
Get the meatball
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Service was a nightmare. Management seems to be a toxic affair. Did not get the impression that the servers had really any direction. We had four different ones cycle through before they finally settled on one. The food was fine. Not bad. Better than pizza hut. I'd recommend Solle's pizza. Not sure about THEIR service but the food there would be worth walking over broken glass for.Parking: They share a parking lot with Publix so plenty of spaces most of the time.Kid-friendliness: They have good fries and chicken tenders for the youths.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Garlic Broc Cappellini
Restaurant is immaculately clean and organized. The pizza is absolutely delicious, and the rolls with dipping sauce were great. There were ample servers, allowing for minimal wait time. Our server, Christina G., was very personable and attentive. Dining at Piesano’s was a very positive experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Rolls, Pepperoni Pizza
They were very busy when I was there. I walked in and got food to go, medium pizza with pineapple. The pineapple was in large chunks but generous. It tasted really good. I didn't eat in but there was a line in the separate take out area. The dining area looked nice although it was packed.