Potbelly's

459 W College Ave, Tallahassee
(850) 322-2598

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ashley Rainbolt

WAYYYY too loud, causes tinnitus, impossible to talk or hear anyone. Makes everyone sick around the general area too.

Glory Bee

Potbellys is a great venue in Tally for all 18 and up! We have attended multiple times and for parent's weekend booked a VIP table. So worth it!!! I recommend if you have a group of 8 or more for sure. Service was amazing and high energy. This is a college bar so if you are expecting calm and quiet...not for you. Go and enjoy the atmosphere and experience the college life with your students. A great time will be had. They have live entertainment regularly so check the calendar. Shout out to C & A who helped work with me on the VIP table. Excellent follow up and we were so glad we did it.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Paul Scanlon

the worst bar in town , terrible service avoid like the plague

Malia Leah

Steven was the best bartender ever

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Howard Spiegel

I live a full BLOCK away from here, yet their music is so absurdly loud, it is able to make my windows shake. I can’t ever get sleep with it playing late at night, even past midnight.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

PKA Entertainment

Long wait time did not answer phine

Julie Paulk

Such a fun club in Tallahassee

Atmosphere: 5

Tomika Jackson

A great venue for the spring/summer

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Lewis Thurston II

The venue to be and stay for a great time. The concert sound was superb! I really enjoyed the different vibes and how they space accommodates all type of people who want to enjoy a great dance music experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Stephen French

Pot bellys on Madison and Macomb!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

hunter rawls

In the heart of Tallahassee, where the sun shines so bright,
There's a place called Potbelly's, a true delight.
With every sip of their drinks, my heart starts to soar,
But it’s Albert beside me that I truly adore.

His laughter's like music, a sweet, soothing sound,
In his warm embrace, my happiness is found.
We share all our moments, both big and small,
With him and Potbelly's, I feel like I have it all.

So here’s to the joy, the love, and the fun,
To Albert and Potbelly's, where our hearts have begun.
In this lovely Tallahassee, my heart's forever true,
For it’s love that I treasure, and it all starts with drew.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dave Sie

We had pre purchased tickets yet we were kept over two hours in the line. Most of us resorted to leaving for pizza instead. Total scam and inefficient crowd control.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

M A L

Do not order Tito’s Vodka here! One shot is $18! The bottle of beer charge varies from $5-7 per bottle of the same beer! I’m not even a college student and I was totally taken advantage of!

Jose Ramos

I visited this venue on Friday night, 1/14/2025. I arrived at around 1:00AM, just wanted to check the place out. They were to close at 2:00AM. The girl at the door charged me a $15 cover fee. Yet, she charged people behind me a cheaper cover. By the look in her face, I can tell this is not her first time doing so. That is a tricky game to play. She never knows who she is charging at the door, or who they know. Chill venue, just too young of a crowd for my taste, but music is good. Seems like a college vibe. Bartenders were very attentive and fast. Drinks were normal, low quality. To the owner please assure your staff charges everyone the same/fair cover, it's only right and avoids a lawsuit.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Olivia Washington

security is horrible, kicked me & my friends out of white boy Drew w a blue jacket on didn’t even try to figure out the problem out kicked me & my friends out without figuring out the problem which was rlly some random that we didn’t know. weird and racist.

Loading...