Tally Mac Shack

824 W Jefferson St, Tallahassee
(850) 296-9317

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Meg C

As a mac and cheese lover, I used to absolutely love this place and was so excited to have it in Tallahassee. I’d been to their brick-and-mortar location at Happy Motoring, as well as when they started out as a food truck. I found myself on FSU campus, so I was excited to try it out, especially the Tikka Masala bites featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives. I ordered the “What’s the Dilly” and the Tikka Masala bite combo. I was disappointed by the lack of flavor of both items, and had to add salt and my own sauce. The mac tasted vaguely of dill, but was overall flavorless. It felt like there was quite a bit missing from the Tikka Masala bites as well, as I could hardly taste the spices, jackfruit kofta, or even the Cheeto crust. I will say that the consistency and texture of both items were great.

I understand that this is an on-campus location, but the quality of mac and cheese was more like generic bar food, rather than a restaurant that specializes in mac and cheese.

I will say however that the food was very reasonably priced, the service was extremely quick, and the seating area was great.

sashie veltrie

i love their mac and cheese its very quick, convenient and tasty!! they have lots of interesting mac options to try.

Иван Лепесий

Unbearably overpriced... I paid $10 for an Alfredo bowl, assuming it had chicken in it.. It does not, its and addon that costs $2. The person taking my order didn't even ask if I wanted it. It was good before, but after they changed the menu it's not worth the money.. Do not go

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Christopher Bernhardt

It's kind of a shame, I spent $15 on my own Mac bowl and they put so much gorganzola in it that it just tasted like salty slop. I added garlic butter and there was so much it was like an added cm of butter above the actual food. Tasted terrible. I appreciate the large servings but think about what you're making.Also, there are no menus, you can't scan a menu, and while you order the display of the menu constantly changes so good luck remembering what you want. Everyone just sits there awkwardly while waiting for the menu to flash back as you get another 10 seconds to order.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 5

Gary

Couldn’t find the place. I went looking for like 20 minutes. No dice.

Joslyn Connor

0 stars…….This place does not exist. I drive around for 20 mins trying to figure out where it is and it’s closed.

Joslyn Whitfield

0 stars…….This place does not exist. I drive around for 20 mins trying to figure out where it is and it’s closed.

Patrick Wolfe

Update your hours if you are going to be closed.

E

you know the food is good when you eat half a pound of pasta and cheese in two minutes

Joseph Sanders

Great Mac!

Eu'Stacia Trawick

Absolutely delicious.

Elliott Garcia

you know the food is good when you eat half a pound of pasta and cheese in two minutes

Stacy Munford

The food was ok,It was a little warm,could have been hot

Bubba Henry

It was a nice little Mac n cheese bowl. They need to season the water with salt when cooking the pasta. Otherwise, solid comfort food. We tried the Buffalo chicken and the BBQ one.

Erica Wiborg

We used Tally Mac’s food truck for our reception. They custom designed more gourmet style Mac and cheese for our special event, and had gluten free and vegan options. They were set up on time and left our guests very happy with the food. Guests didn’t stop raving about it!

Loading...