You cannot go wrong here... The burgers here are so diverse and creative! If you have time try them all, if you are feeling bold and want to be rewarded for it, get the PB&J burger. Don't forget to add an egg to it!
Kohatha Vaughn
Yall I was a little skeptical but I wanted something I had never had for my birthday and this place did not disappoint! My wife had the pb&j burger and I had the pulled pork burger and they were both absolutely amazing!!! The staff was friendly and attentive and we will be back!
jerahme ryan
Takes a minute to get the food but damn that Piggly Wiggly burger is awesome!
Eric K.
A really nice local place to eat at in Tallahassee! The burger combinations are awesome. My favorites are the Gator Hater, The Panhandle, and the PB&J burger. Order the sweet potato fries as a side and thank me later! It was newly renovated and the outside looks deceiving, as there's tons of space inside and on the back patio
Lauryn Feliciano
Excellent service and friendly staff. The burgers were juicy and the outside seating are is a really nice Place to take a date or hang out with friends. Had the Mac and cheese burger and was not disappointed!
Jim Tolbert
Out of all the burgers, I chose the Panhandle. It is like a patty melt because it comes on sourdough toast. The sauce on the burger is a housemade BBQ sauce that is more tangy than sweet. It also has bacon, cheddar cheese, and roasted red peppers. I added chipotle mayo to mine to give it a better kick.
Amanda K.
Ummmm...I don't get the hype. This is one of those times I want to force everyone that reviewed this as the best burger place in Tallahassee to pay me back in both money and calories. After combing through tons of reviews and seeing that this was indeed the BEST, we decided we absolutely had to eat here. I'm going to go ahead and assume that everyone that thinks these are the best burgers in Tallahassee has only recently started eating meat and has never actually eaten a burger before. Like ever. So they have nothing to compare them to. The staff is super friendly, so all the stars for a great staff. The restaurant is small and a little grimy. As for the food, I was so excited to eat here I was like - order everything off the menu!! So we ordered a lot. We started with the loaded fries. They were good in the way that cheap food is good when you're hungover or when you've never had food made with real ingredients. Frozen fries topped with melted cheap cheese and bacon that does not stick to the fries but falls off on the plate so you just end up with a dry over cooked fry no matter what you do. And the bbq or smoke flavor is just a powdered seasoning. They were underwhelming. The burgers are the real bummer. Maybe more so because of all the "this is the best burger ever" talk. When we ordered, we were asked to what temperature we'd like them cooked, although not sure why that mattered since neither came out anywhere near what we requested and they were both frozen and a little raw in some spots. I don't finish my burger because it was gross. My mom couldn't finish hers because it was frozen. I got the one with peanut butter and jelly and my mom got the Gator Hater. Mine was just downright disgusting. Granted, that could have been the toppings and I fully recognized that. There was so much peanut butter on my burger, I could have made at least three school lunches for some kids. So after half, I scraped all the toppings off and went for just the meat. The meat is flavorless, cheap, and nothing special. We actually saw an employee walk out with a stack of frozen burger patties and throw them on the griddle...so we know they aren't freshly made or seasoned in any way. We could also tell they were frozen based on the ice shards in our burgers. My mom's toppings were less cloying than mine, but hers wasn't anything great and the flavors just weren't there. All in all, the burgers were quite the letdown. Certainly not the best burger I've had. Not even one of the okayest burgers I've had. Nope, I'm going to have to put it firmly in the worst I've had category. BUT the most disgusting thing on this menu, and I absolutely have to mention it, is the macaroni and cheese. That is like hot trash in a cup. We both paid the up charge for it. We both were so excited for it. I almost threw up the second it was in my mouth. Have you ever had macaroni salad? You know, the cold kind your grandma makes with a s*** load of mayo. Imagine that but your grandma lost her marbles and put it in the oven and thought it was macaroni and cheese. That is what it tasted like. I've never had bad macaroni and cheese until here. Either this is made with hot mayonnaise or they do not clean out their refrigerator and this stuff was about 3 months old. Either way, humans should not be eating it. So. In conclusion, the reviews have me flabbergasted. This place was quite possibly one of the ones I was most looking forward to visiting while also being one of the worst restaurants I've eaten in. Maybe we came on their worst ever, let's serve everyone all of our expired food night, and this explains why it was so god awful and it was just a random glitch, or maybe it just really is this bad. Either way, you deserve consistency and good food. You won't find it here.
John DuBravec
My wife and I couldn't decide where to go to dinner and I found Wells Brothers to be very close by with great reviews. Now we know why, it's an excellent bar & grill. I had the Gator Hater burger and my wife the PB&J burger. Both were fantastic. The wait staff was also very friendly and attentive. We will definitely be going back when we're in town.
Leonela Bravo
Awesome burger!!!!
Melissa S.
We had the PB&J burger, rueben, gator hater and mac daddy burgers. Wow! So delicious and juicy. Fries were perfect. Service was fabulous. Will definitely be back when in town again!
Owned by the same peeps who own midtown caboose, similar menu yet somehow I swear this spot is better. We had lunch here today and the slaw was to die for, nice cold drinks and a gluten free bun that didn't not taste any different. If I had to describe this place in one word it would be comfortable for sure! Can't wait to come back!
Ryan Hicks
This used to be my hands down favorite restaurant in town but ever since they reopened its been a disappointment. They halved the size of the menu, but more importantly they reduced the quality of the food. The burgers used to be big and like 1.5” thick and now they are about half that size, and they switched from real cheese to what appears to be Kraft slices (really??). The prices however are the same, why would I pay $13 for a burger the same quality as a $6 one at relish down the street? They also changed the inside, it used to be kinda cool and cozy inside with old wood tables and dark red paint, but know it feels like I’m in a psychiatric ward as they painted it off-white and replaced the wood tables with cheap plastic ones. I really don’t know why they changed the place everyone liked it before, I hope they return to their old menu and ingredients before people stop coming back.
Micheal Erwin
Stopped in for lunch - the burgers were awesome and HUGE! I had the Lip Smacker with a side of pasta salad. Absolutely delicious. They have a patio area in the back that is shaded with picnic tables and tables with umbrellas. Highly recommend this place to anyone wanting amazing food in a fun, laid back environment.
Vignesh Sitaraman
Wonderful place. The burgers are amazing, the option of being able to build your own burger is quite cool. The range of options can be intimidating but it's super fun to do. The staff are also quite helpful. Also they have a 25% discount for FSU/DAMU/TCC students who have a valid id! Definitely recommend it.
You cannot go wrong here... The burgers here are so diverse and creative! If you have time try them all, if you are feeling bold and want to be rewarded for it, get the PB&J burger. Don't forget to add an egg to it!
Yall I was a little skeptical but I wanted something I had never had for my birthday and this place did not disappoint! My wife had the pb&j burger and I had the pulled pork burger and they were both absolutely amazing!!! The staff was friendly and attentive and we will be back!
Takes a minute to get the food but damn that Piggly Wiggly burger is awesome!
A really nice local place to eat at in Tallahassee! The burger combinations are awesome. My favorites are the Gator Hater, The Panhandle, and the PB&J burger. Order the sweet potato fries as a side and thank me later! It was newly renovated and the outside looks deceiving, as there's tons of space inside and on the back patio
Excellent service and friendly staff. The burgers were juicy and the outside seating are is a really nice Place to take a date or hang out with friends. Had the Mac and cheese burger and was not disappointed!
Out of all the burgers, I chose the Panhandle. It is like a patty melt because it comes on sourdough toast. The sauce on the burger is a housemade BBQ sauce that is more tangy than sweet. It also has bacon, cheddar cheese, and roasted red peppers. I added chipotle mayo to mine to give it a better kick.
Ummmm...I don't get the hype. This is one of those times I want to force everyone that reviewed this as the best burger place in Tallahassee to pay me back in both money and calories. After combing through tons of reviews and seeing that this was indeed the BEST, we decided we absolutely had to eat here. I'm going to go ahead and assume that everyone that thinks these are the best burgers in Tallahassee has only recently started eating meat and has never actually eaten a burger before. Like ever. So they have nothing to compare them to. The staff is super friendly, so all the stars for a great staff. The restaurant is small and a little grimy. As for the food, I was so excited to eat here I was like - order everything off the menu!! So we ordered a lot. We started with the loaded fries. They were good in the way that cheap food is good when you're hungover or when you've never had food made with real ingredients. Frozen fries topped with melted cheap cheese and bacon that does not stick to the fries but falls off on the plate so you just end up with a dry over cooked fry no matter what you do. And the bbq or smoke flavor is just a powdered seasoning. They were underwhelming. The burgers are the real bummer. Maybe more so because of all the "this is the best burger ever" talk. When we ordered, we were asked to what temperature we'd like them cooked, although not sure why that mattered since neither came out anywhere near what we requested and they were both frozen and a little raw in some spots. I don't finish my burger because it was gross. My mom couldn't finish hers because it was frozen. I got the one with peanut butter and jelly and my mom got the Gator Hater. Mine was just downright disgusting. Granted, that could have been the toppings and I fully recognized that. There was so much peanut butter on my burger, I could have made at least three school lunches for some kids. So after half, I scraped all the toppings off and went for just the meat. The meat is flavorless, cheap, and nothing special. We actually saw an employee walk out with a stack of frozen burger patties and throw them on the griddle...so we know they aren't freshly made or seasoned in any way. We could also tell they were frozen based on the ice shards in our burgers. My mom's toppings were less cloying than mine, but hers wasn't anything great and the flavors just weren't there. All in all, the burgers were quite the letdown. Certainly not the best burger I've had. Not even one of the okayest burgers I've had. Nope, I'm going to have to put it firmly in the worst I've had category. BUT the most disgusting thing on this menu, and I absolutely have to mention it, is the macaroni and cheese. That is like hot trash in a cup. We both paid the up charge for it. We both were so excited for it. I almost threw up the second it was in my mouth. Have you ever had macaroni salad? You know, the cold kind your grandma makes with a s*** load of mayo. Imagine that but your grandma lost her marbles and put it in the oven and thought it was macaroni and cheese. That is what it tasted like. I've never had bad macaroni and cheese until here. Either this is made with hot mayonnaise or they do not clean out their refrigerator and this stuff was about 3 months old. Either way, humans should not be eating it. So. In conclusion, the reviews have me flabbergasted. This place was quite possibly one of the ones I was most looking forward to visiting while also being one of the worst restaurants I've eaten in. Maybe we came on their worst ever, let's serve everyone all of our expired food night, and this explains why it was so god awful and it was just a random glitch, or maybe it just really is this bad. Either way, you deserve consistency and good food. You won't find it here.
My wife and I couldn't decide where to go to dinner and I found Wells Brothers to be very close by with great reviews. Now we know why, it's an excellent bar & grill. I had the Gator Hater burger and my wife the PB&J burger. Both were fantastic. The wait staff was also very friendly and attentive. We will definitely be going back when we're in town.
Awesome burger!!!!
We had the PB&J burger, rueben, gator hater and mac daddy burgers. Wow! So delicious and juicy. Fries were perfect. Service was fabulous. Will definitely be back when in town again!
Restaurantji Recommends
Owned by the same peeps who own midtown caboose, similar menu yet somehow I swear this spot is better. We had lunch here today and the slaw was to die for, nice cold drinks and a gluten free bun that didn't not taste any different. If I had to describe this place in one word it would be comfortable for sure! Can't wait to come back!
This used to be my hands down favorite restaurant in town but ever since they reopened its been a disappointment. They halved the size of the menu, but more importantly they reduced the quality of the food. The burgers used to be big and like 1.5” thick and now they are about half that size, and they switched from real cheese to what appears to be Kraft slices (really??). The prices however are the same, why would I pay $13 for a burger the same quality as a $6 one at relish down the street? They also changed the inside, it used to be kinda cool and cozy inside with old wood tables and dark red paint, but know it feels like I’m in a psychiatric ward as they painted it off-white and replaced the wood tables with cheap plastic ones. I really don’t know why they changed the place everyone liked it before, I hope they return to their old menu and ingredients before people stop coming back.
Stopped in for lunch - the burgers were awesome and HUGE! I had the Lip Smacker with a side of pasta salad. Absolutely delicious. They have a patio area in the back that is shaded with picnic tables and tables with umbrellas. Highly recommend this place to anyone wanting amazing food in a fun, laid back environment.
Wonderful place. The burgers are amazing, the option of being able to build your own burger is quite cool. The range of options can be intimidating but it's super fun to do. The staff are also quite helpful. Also they have a 25% discount for FSU/DAMU/TCC students who have a valid id! Definitely recommend it.
It was awesome. We had the place to ourselves