First time here to try New York Pizza in Tampa. I must say, yall did that! I really enjoyed it. Coming from Chicago with their "square cut pizzas" I was happy I can finally "fold" a pizza ? ? yahoooo ❗️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Bobby Cook
Best Slice in Tampa
Leiby Sanchez-Erazo
Great selection of pizza. A place to grab a quick bite. The deserts are also good.Enough area to sit and eat your pizza. They also do take out and delivery. Place is not fancy but it is a good place to eat.Parking: During the daytime, it could be difficult to find parking in front of the location. But it is downtown so parking could be tricky
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Jorge Soto
I finally tried Eddie & Sam's after hearing people claim it as the best NY style pizza in Tampa Bay. I visited during the lunch rush on Friday, and it was very crowded as expected. You can only order through kiosks and grab a pager with a number. I ordered one 10-inch cheese and a 10-inch meat lover with 10 wings and 2 drinks(free refills). My total was $60 plus the $12 I had to pay for parking makes for a very pricey lunch. The two counter people wouldn't answer any questions they just kind of nodded at me, expect no customer service because everything is self serve fyi. I rarely add anything to pizza, but I had to literally add every seasoning on the table to be able to taste anything. The crust was near perfection and didn't make me feel bloated. The wings came out almost immediately after ordering them, and they were cold and soggy. If I am in the area and already paid for all-day parking, I would visit again and try more of their specialty pizza, but I wouldn't make the drive just for this place. Frattelis and Via Italia are much better pizza in my opinion.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Shane Samon
Best pizza in all of Tampa Bay. So many choices and all are just as good as the next.
Food: 5
Grant Langhus
Same old Eddie and Sam's since I started going there 12 years ago. And that's a good thing! While I no longer live in Tampa, I go out of my way to eat here when I'm in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Theresa She
Ok love your pizza,I live on Long Island and the best I have had so far. So when are you going to hire a bagel baker? You have the ovens and the water,what more do you need????Vegetarian options: Try sesame seed on the crust with mozzarella inside the crust that you hold very yummy
Food: 5
Jayda Olson
If in the area I recommend! Decent prices, and good pizzas. Crust is a little bland but I like that it’s thin. Having just visited NY this lives up to it! Bathroom was kinda icky, and they only have one. Staff was nice but un-coordinated.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Lover Pizza, Slice of Pizza
Dale Follis
The regular and buffalo slices were great. Cheap and quick meal. Will be back.
PSG Security Academy
Best Pizza in Downtown Tampa!! Had some great Za after the St Patrick's Day Parade.
Pizza is great but the place always looks so run down and dirty. All the tables are always disgusting and the bathroom . Good pizza
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Monica
Pizza is amazing. Staff don't say much. Kind of like self-service ...table got wiped immediately after group's left. And trash was being pulled up on sidewalks, which I thought was odd cause people with their dogs had to stop for their dog to come one when it shouldn't be blocked. Anyways. There are a couple of little issues that can be fixed, in all the food was Amazing ?Parking: The pay parking lot is right across from the pizza place , and of course, throughout the town, they have street parking you have to pay.Kid-friendliness: A lot of families really loved it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Jodi McAllister
Please try one time you will go back I promise you that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Juice
Absolutely the BEST GLUTEN FREE pizza I have had to date so the fact that it's NEW YORK pizza just makes it that much better!! I highly recommend it.Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free pizza Available
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Kevin Hitt
Great location, great pizza. Easy ordering experience & great vibe / atmosphere on weekdays and
First time here to try New York Pizza in Tampa. I must say, yall did that! I really enjoyed it. Coming from Chicago with their "square cut pizzas" I was happy I can finally "fold" a pizza ? ? yahoooo ❗️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Best Slice in Tampa
Great selection of pizza. A place to grab a quick bite. The deserts are also good.Enough area to sit and eat your pizza. They also do take out and delivery. Place is not fancy but it is a good place to eat.Parking: During the daytime, it could be difficult to find parking in front of the location. But it is downtown so parking could be tricky
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
I finally tried Eddie & Sam's after hearing people claim it as the best NY style pizza in Tampa Bay. I visited during the lunch rush on Friday, and it was very crowded as expected. You can only order through kiosks and grab a pager with a number. I ordered one 10-inch cheese and a 10-inch meat lover with 10 wings and 2 drinks(free refills). My total was $60 plus the $12 I had to pay for parking makes for a very pricey lunch. The two counter people wouldn't answer any questions they just kind of nodded at me, expect no customer service because everything is self serve fyi. I rarely add anything to pizza, but I had to literally add every seasoning on the table to be able to taste anything. The crust was near perfection and didn't make me feel bloated. The wings came out almost immediately after ordering them, and they were cold and soggy. If I am in the area and already paid for all-day parking, I would visit again and try more of their specialty pizza, but I wouldn't make the drive just for this place. Frattelis and Via Italia are much better pizza in my opinion.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Best pizza in all of Tampa Bay. So many choices and all are just as good as the next.
Food: 5
Same old Eddie and Sam's since I started going there 12 years ago. And that's a good thing! While I no longer live in Tampa, I go out of my way to eat here when I'm in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ok love your pizza,I live on Long Island and the best I have had so far. So when are you going to hire a bagel baker? You have the ovens and the water,what more do you need????Vegetarian options: Try sesame seed on the crust with mozzarella inside the crust that you hold very yummy
Food: 5
If in the area I recommend! Decent prices, and good pizzas. Crust is a little bland but I like that it’s thin. Having just visited NY this lives up to it! Bathroom was kinda icky, and they only have one. Staff was nice but un-coordinated.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Lover Pizza, Slice of Pizza
The regular and buffalo slices were great. Cheap and quick meal. Will be back.
Best Pizza in Downtown Tampa!! Had some great Za after the St Patrick's Day Parade.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is great but the place always looks so run down and dirty. All the tables are always disgusting and the bathroom . Good pizza
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Pizza is amazing. Staff don't say much. Kind of like self-service ...table got wiped immediately after group's left. And trash was being pulled up on sidewalks, which I thought was odd cause people with their dogs had to stop for their dog to come one when it shouldn't be blocked. Anyways. There are a couple of little issues that can be fixed, in all the food was Amazing ?Parking: The pay parking lot is right across from the pizza place , and of course, throughout the town, they have street parking you have to pay.Kid-friendliness: A lot of families really loved it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Please try one time you will go back I promise you that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely the BEST GLUTEN FREE pizza I have had to date so the fact that it's NEW YORK pizza just makes it that much better!! I highly recommend it.Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free pizza Available
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Great location, great pizza. Easy ordering experience & great vibe / atmosphere on weekdays and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza