Johnny C's Italian Eatery

Hailey was our waitress and she was fantastic. So friendly and always with a smile. The food was very good and I highly recommend the pizza. Double pepperoni with the Mikes hot honey.

Johnny C’s is fantastic! It was my first time dining here as it was strongly recommended by my brother and sister in law. From the moment we walked in, the coz, clean and intimate atmosphere made us feel right at home. The star of the evening, however, was Hailey, her service was nothing short of perfect. She anticipated every need, I made specific requests and she paid attention to every detail. She made our dining experience truly special.

And the food? Incredible. The Chicken Parmesan was perfectly cooked, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. If you’re looking for a warm, welcoming spot with standout service and amazing food, Johnny C’s is a must-visit. Ask for Haley, you won’t regret it!

Had an amazing experience at Johnny C’s Restaurant! The food was absolutely exquisite, every dish was flavorful and beautifully presented. A special shoutout to Hailey, our extraordinary waitress, who went above and beyond with her warm, attentive service. She made our night unforgettable. Can’t wait to come back!

Fresh delicious food and very clean restaurant. Great service thanks to Hailey who was our amazing waitress. We love coming here!

Bought a large 3 topping on a Monday showed up and no one was there, I say this because they were in no way busy... they burnt the pizza. This was first time trying and this place is 3 4 bucks more expensive than capri down the street. Hard to taste the good tasting pizza when crust is black.
Came back almost a month later and were able to get another pizza. Chef Eric was awesome and hooked us up, the pizza was extremely tasty and we will be going back.

Just had some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. It was tossed and cooked perfectly. The atmosphere in the restaurant was exactly what we were looking for. One of the chefs, Cade, came out to say what’s up and he was just awesome. He was so kind and funny, and you could tell that he really cares about what he does. I will definitely be back!

I visited Johnny C's last month and was blown away by the service and quality of the food. I got a specialty pizza and garlic knots and the food was delicious! I asked who made the pizza and they pointed to me to a man named Cade. I will be sure to ask for him to make my pizza the next time I dine-in. Both the pizza and knots were cooked to perfection and tasted very fresh. The service was also outstanding! I will definitely be back here and next time I will be sure to bring a couple friends with me as well!

We just recently discovered this restaurant and decided to venture here on one of our date nights. It did NOT disappoint. This is the best italian food I have ever had. The alfredo, the garlic parm wings, the pizza, the garlic knots with the meat dipping sauce. Every single item was out of this world. The food was great but our waitress Amanda was also just as wonderful. She was very friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed the entire meal. This will be a new regular place for us.

I stopped by Johnny C’s recently and was so impressed. The pizza was incredible — perfectly crisp crust, the right amount of sauce, and super fresh toppings. Easily one of the best slices I’ve had in a long time.
I was even able to meet the pizza maker Cade who was a great guy and clearly knows his way around a pizza oven. You can tell he puts real care into what he makes.
Definitely recommend checking this place out if you’re anywhere nearby. I’ll be back soon for sure.

The calzone appears huge. However, the outer edge is a thick dough with no filling. The inside filling was mostly ricotta. The flavor was just okay.

UPDATE: I was offered a complimentary calzone for a future visit and I got it today. Much, much, much better. This new one looked better and tasted delicious!; from the dough to the cheese filling. I would definitely reorder it again. Thank you for being a company that wants to make things right. *6/6/25 picture is the most recent calzone.

Amanda gave exceptional service and the linguine Alfredo was amazing

Great family atmosphere with delicious food. Amanda’s service was quick and friendly. We’ll definitely be back!

Amanda was amazing! Thank you for great food and service!

We had the wings, calamari and the Staten Island pizza - it was all delish! Even with a graduation party going on, everything came out quickly and our server was super attentive! Will be back for more of the things we couldn’t fit in our belly that looked amazing!

Very injoyabel time