New York New York Pizza
11203 Sheldon Rd, Tampa
(813) 926-6969
Customers' Favorites
Half Pepperoni and Half Extra Cheese Pizza
Two Pepperoni Pizza Slice & Drink
Cheese Pizza and White Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Fried Mushrooms
Buffalo Chicken
Antipasto Salad
Stuffed Shells
Grandma Pizza
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I just found this location! Which is way closer to me. I a slice of buffalo chicken pizza because I couldn't resist and it was great! Also ordered a Med Half pepperoni/Cheese pizza and it was amazing! Nothing like a good New York Style Pizza!!! I give it a 10! Everyone was super nice! Billy was just amazing! Great atmosphere, fast service and extremely clean! I have no complaints! I will definitely be back soon
I'm from the NE where we know good pizza. I grew up on Philly & NYC pizza. This is as good as I've had down in Tampa. The extra cheese was loaded with cheese. The peperoni was plenty ample. Most places down here are chincey with the toppings.
A+
A+
I've had their pizza from their other locations and it's really good. However, this time I ordered from their Sheldon location and something didn't taste the same. Not sure if they changed one of their ingredients or if they had to deal with what they had since it was just a few days after the hurricane. It didn't taste bad, but it didn't taste as great as it usually taste. Other then that the staff were very nice.
You May Also Like
Rice & Spice - 11625 Sheldon Rd
![]()
Sushi, Asian Fusion, Sushi Bar, Laotian, Vegan
Minano Ramen - 11909 Sheldon Rd
![]()
Bubble Tea, Izakaya, Ramen