NY Times Square Pizza

226 E Bearss Ave, Tampa
(813) 962-0400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Chema

I'm delighted with this place. The food is delicious, pure, and authentic Italian flavor. A clean place with first-class service. The freshness of the ingredients is palpable. This place is my favorite for Italian food. And most importantly, prepared to your liking!!🥰💯

Gopi Krishna

I had a fantastic experience at this pizza shop! The veggie pizza is absolutely amazing – loaded with fresh toppings, perfectly seasoned, and baked to perfection with a deliciously crispy crust. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and the flavor speaks for itself.

What really made the visit special, though, was the hospitality. The owners themselves were working in the shop, and they were incredibly friendly, welcoming, and attentive. It’s clear they care deeply about their food and their customers. Highly recommend stopping by – I’ll definitely be coming back!

leona myers

Owers such a lovely kind couple.

Maria Parlette

What a great experience the food was amazing great taste the atmosphere was nice and the restaurant was clean the owner was so accommodating we came here for my nephews graduation dinner highly recommend. The owner. The pizza was just like New York style pizza

Charles Williams

We do takeout here most of the time. We have tried most of their items based on the outstanding recommendations from customers we have met there. We have ordered their pizza, calzone, Philly cheese and other oven baked sandwiches, spaghetti and other Italian dishes, sausage lentil soup, and their regular and Greek salads (the best in the Tampa area). We have never been disappointed with the quality of the food or customer service. When they are busy it is worth the wait for the great food quality and excellent food preparation. The husband and wife are always courteous and friendly. We love going there and recommend this pizza place to our friends and others and rate it a solid 5 STARS!!!!

Delano Jovan

The food was absolutely delicious. Definitely going to be my go to spot from now on.

Jesselyn De Jesus

Best pizza spot in town! Highly recommend the wings with their house made hot wing sauce. Staff treats you like VIP!!!

Estelle Farias

Whenever you want an authentic taste of New York/New Jersey style pizza, this is where you want to go!

Linda Grandrino

Pizza was amazing. We stop for a quick bite for our daughter's birthday and it was amazing. The owner was super nice and sweet. Definitely will be coming back!

Imag!ne Everyth!ng

Delivered pizza for an event. Delivery guy was super nice and the pizza was delicious.

S G

Really, really good pizza and great service

Wilmil “WILMIL” Wilmil

This is the best pizza in Florida. Do not buy into that Eddie ans Sams pizza is. I have tried over 25 pizza shops and this one tops them all. Me and my wife gladly drive 50 minutes to get here and we do it with a smile. The servers are very attentive as well. The place is also clean.

angela Perez

Best pizza , worth the 50 min Drive

Alexis Kargakos

Absolutely loved this place! This is the closest you can get to authentic New York style pizza in Tampa! The crust was perfectly crispy with just the right amount of chew, and the sauce was the perfect combination of tangy and sweet. The cheese was gooey and melted to perfection. The prices were also amazing for how much pizza we got! Will definitely be back for more. Five stars all the way!

Roman Dynasty Cleaning

Hands down best pizza and wings around. The service is always great and food is fresh. Highly recommend

Loading...