Tanya & Matt's Ice Creamiest

They had 2 sorbet flavors (orange / lime && raspberry) and 2 ice cream flavors (Oreo && cinnamon sugar) - on the menu it also said chocolate but it was not available during our visit . Flavors rotate weekly. Updated from previous review on 2025-01-26

Best Cookies & Creme EVER!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

First time in this place and Debrielle took care of us, wow.. outstanding customer service, she told us about the most popular flavors, the new ones, also offered us to try them before order, a smile always with every interaction, she also came out and cleaned the table.. about the flavor... Uffff amazing

Best ice cream & helpful assistance

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone

This is a classic neighborhood ice cream shop. If you live in the area you are a regular, if you don’t live in the area you are greeted like you are a regular! They have a wide variety of flavors and a handful of sugar free flavors as well. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the ice cream never disappoints! The only suggestion we have is more seating options. They offer booths and some outdoor seating but any parties larger than 4-5 it can be difficult to all sit together. We can’t wait to come back!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Waffle Cone, Peanut Butter Blast, Cookie Monster, Strawberry

the worst customer service

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Banana Split

Debrielle was so nice & Welcoming here!! She made the perfect milkshake for me & Was super kind!! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great variety and good portions

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

?‍☠️Arrr, mates! Let this ol’ sea dog regale ye with tales of sweet treasures found at Tanya and Matt’s Ice Cream, right here in the fair port of Carrollwood, Florida—a place where ye can plunder flavors so rich, even Blackbeard himself would blush!

From the moment ye step through the door, ye’ll be feelin’ the warm embrace of a creamy delight that’ll make ye weak in the knees, much like a siren’s song after too long at sea. The ice cream be as smooth as a mermaid’s... scales, if ye catch me drift. Aye, one lick, and ye’ll be beggin’ for more, just like a sailor at port after a long voyage without... the finer things in life.

Now, the variety, ye say? Ah, the flavors be as plentiful as a chest of Spanish doubloons, and they’ll have ye dippin’ yer spoon deeper and deeper, explorin’ pleasures ye never knew existed! Whether ye fancy somethin’ fruity, nutty, or downright decadent, there’s somethin’ here to tickle every taste bud. And if ye be cravin' somethin' extra thick and creamy, well... let’s just say Tanya and Matt know how to deliver the goods.

The cones, mates, oh the cones! Crisp and ready to handle whatever load ye throw their way, they’ll hold up better than a well-trained crew in a storm. And if ye fancy a sundae, ye’ll find the toppings piled high, makin’ yer mouth water in anticipation of the sweet, sticky mess that’ll leave ye satisfied yet yearnin’ for more.

The service, ye ask? Aye, the crew here be friendly and quick with a smile, treatin’ ye like the captain ye are. They know just how to handle yer... order, whether it be large or small, and they’re more than happy to oblige any special requests.

So if ye find yerself in Carrollwood and in need of somethin’ cold and creamy to fill yer gullet, set a course for Tanya and Matt’s Ice Cream. Ye won’t be disappointed, and ye may even find yerself comin’ back for another round... or two. Arrr, but careful, lads and lasses, ye may end up spendin' more time here than ye ever intended, gettin' lost in the pleasures of the deep!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great lil ice cream shop. Every flavor I have tried is delicious. My fave is the UBE.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Update August 2024: More improvements. Friendly staff and at an adequate staffing level. More flavors. I had the nanna’s banana pudding - so good.

2022: Much improved with new ownership. Friendlier, cleaned up inside, nicely done order window and then place where they put your order for pick up, nice selection of flavors - and an added bonus - no more creepy Matt at the store

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I discovered Tonya and Matt during the pandemic. I wanted so much to feel normal with everything closed down. I appreciate the outside seating, but most of all, the customer service and the product itself. This was our go to outing almost daily. The ice cream Orders were taken from a window, and the young ladies brought them out to the customer through the door. my favorite combinations were Lucuma, Ube, and Ginger. Ube is still my favorite ice cream next to ginger I not pair it with coconut as well as vanilla cherry. I have yet to find another location of these flavors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a blast! The ice cream was great, as was the service. We’ll definitely come back the next time we’re nearby.

Kid-friendliness: Many ice cream flavors with appealing colors. There are cute decorative items.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We tried to get simple cones at the Northdale location today. Unfortunately your team members couldn’t be bothered to take our order. In stead they stood gabbing with one another. What gives Matt???

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I had the pleasure of being led through an ice cream journey by Bella. Her enthusiasm was contagious, and her knowledge was unparalleled.
Bella’s guidance made me feel like an ice cream connoisseur in training. She didn’t just serve scoops; she crafted an experience.
Thanks, Bella, for turning a simple scoop into a memorable expedition!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5