Taste of New York Pizzeria

A friend and I stumbled across a eatery called Taste of New York, serving Italian and Latin food. Being new in Kissimmee from Brooklyn, NY what luck. I could go on and on. The environment made me home sick especially the bathrooms. The decor was filled with NYC memories. The owners were wonderful and proud of the work they put in. I was offered a homemade NY slice of pizza which deserves return visits. The taste of garlic sets the pizza off! This eatery will be one of my favorites, I've eaten plenty of pizza across NYC, give this place a try. The Taste of New York will put you in a time machine especially if you are NYC kid! What a blessing. Tip well, the service is great!

Definitely my family's fav pizza spot in New Tampa

Highly recommend.New York style pizza tastes very good.

Great NY style pizza. One of the best in the area. Certainly better than most.

Authentic and excellent pizza. Cant go wrong here, I grew up on corner store slices in Jersey city and this hits the exact same

Best damn NY style pizza I’ve ever had. 2 slices + a soda for $6 all day is a steal and definitely saving us in this economy.

Perfect. Made a special request and they filled it perfectly. I want a crust between thin and pan, crispy and it was spot on. To know they actually follow the order matters.

Now Uber didn’t bother to ring the doorbell and put my pie on the ground I can’t blame Taste of New York Pizzeria for that. I’ll just go in next time.

Best pizza in Tampa area! Thin crispy under carriage. Cheese has that flavor typically only found in the north east United States iykyk. Staff is very friendly and cheerful. 2 cheese and a can soda for $6! Forget about it!

The slices are legit. That's all you need to know. It's real NY pizza.

This place is great.

Great experience, the people there are great (including pepe)

Very good pizza, thin crust, very toasty and flavorfull!! A taste of New York indeed!
Highly recommend!❤️

Their plain cheese pizza is amazing. The sauce cheese crust everything is immaculate. Im fork the North East I know about good pizza! And this place is it!

Awesome place. Side salad was big! Meatballs and the sauce were on point. The pizza slices were awesome. Then to top it off the staff was super friendly. Must try this place!

Listen… I thought I was just grabbing a quick slice on my lunch break. What I didn’t expect was to walk into a whole fantasy.

First off, the customer service? Unreal. Like, where did they find these angels? Friendly, fast, and flashing smiles that had me forgetting I was even hungry. Honestly, the service alone deserves five stars—and maybe my phone number.

Then there’s the pizza. Crispy crust, bold sauce, toppings so fresh I thought they had a garden out back. Every bite had me making those little “mmph” noises you hope no one hears. But let’s be real—I was too distracted by the view behind the counter to care.

Now let’s talk about these men. Because whew—this wasn’t just a pizza place, it was a full-on flavor and flirtation experience. Cute? Check. Confident? Yup. That one with the smirk and the rolled-up sleeves? Sir, I came for carbs, not feelings. And yet…

I left full, flustered, and 99% sure I need to come back tomorrow. Not for the food (okay, yes, that too)—but to see if the spicy pepperoni was the only thing bringing the heat.

Final word? This place serves piping hot pizza and energy that could start a rom-com. 10/10. Will be back. Might bring lip gloss next time.