New York New York Pizza
5509 E Fowler Ave, Temple Terrace
(813) 252-9900
Customers' Favorites
Grandma Pizza Florentine Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza by the Slice
Fried Mozzarella
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Small Pizza
Large Pizza
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Wanted a take out pizza, did a search & found many choices. Chose this as it was close to the hotel I was staying at - and I am so glad I did. The pizza I ordered was phenomenal, best I have had in Florida, not just Tampa. It came still hot (wrapped in one of those thermal blankets - a bit earlier than promised - and I loved it. Tony, who took the order was friendly & explained how things worked there. Good guy. All in all, the food & service were excellent - I...
It hasn't been hard to find good pizza places, but it has been a challenge to find good wings. NY NY has BOTH! The pizza was amazing, of course, but their WINGS.... Man! It caught me by surprise because every other place has been subpar. I'm from Memphis, and I take my well-done, with extra wet wings, seriously. NY NY nailed everything. Thank you, Guys. ?
This is the closest thing to real NYC pizza you will get in Florida. They were really good. I stopped in while on a business trip and had to go back befor I left town. It's a must for real pizza fans. Plus NYC slice prices. 2 cheese and a drink for $6.00. Love it.
You May Also Like
Chenji Noodle House - 5505 E Fowler Ave
![]()
Asian, Chinese, Noodles
Carrabba's Italian Grill - 5515 E Fowler Ave
![]()
Italian, Seafood, Vegetarian
Tsaocaa Tampa 朝茶 - 5503 E Fowler Ave
![]()
Bubble Tea, Chicken Wings, Waffles