50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Treasure Island

“The pizzas are great we ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and it was fantastic. But the pasta entrees are my family’s favorite. The pasta puttanesca is truly amazing. We have been here a few times and we order it with shrimp or blackened chicken. The portions are American Italian so you will have some to take home. The house salad is also excellent. The Italian Margarita is a refreshing drink after a few hours in the burning sun.“

“Delicious and gluten free if you’re into that kind of thing!“

“The food was absolutely great, we had subs, pizza and salad. My favorite is the steak sub. You have to try it if you are in Largo. The service was also absolutely 💯 👌. Loved the outside area. The restaurant was the cleanest I've ever seen.“

“I love eating here when I’m on a break from class. The lunch menu is phenomenal. I love the choices they offer with a slice of pizza. The chocolate cake is honestly my favorite👌🏾“

“This is my go to spot for pizza in St Pete! Eddie always does it right!!“

“Great Staff love the daughter to death Sardo. He’s crazy but in a great way great jokes the only one recommendation is don’t order ranch dressing with your pizza. Other than that the atmosphere is great. The pie is great. I grew up in the Pizza business for many many years And I definitely recommend this place as one of the best in Pinellas County. Maybe even in the TampaBay area, God bless them.“

“I’ve never eaten there, but I can tell you that I know Kelley. And Kelley is the kindest soul and she knows how to make pizzas. I will be making a stop next time I’m back in the Burg. Support friend’s small businesses 🫵🏻“

“😁We discovered Flippers during our evacuation from the Hurricanes. Great Pizza and appetizers. Red was our server and she was terrific - attentive, knowledgeable about the menu and considerate of our situation. We weren't rushed and enjoyed our experience. Thanks, Red!“

“Great selection of beer and wine to choose from. They really do support small breweries and have a large local craft selection too. The brunch was delicious and wait times for a large group were pretty minimal. Great experience and a place where anyone could find something they'd like.“

“Hands down the best pizza we’ve eaten…fast, fresh and super friendly service!!“

“We vacationed in Largo 2 years ago and discovered this place. I’m pretty sure we ordered from here at least 3 times! We arrived yesterday and that was the first thing we wanted for dinner on our first night of vacation! Food is amazing!! We will definitely have it again before we leave and anytime we are back in the area!“

“Review for Mama Rose Pizza

Outstanding! Honestly, words hardly do this place justice. From my very first visit to now countless returns, Mama Rose Pizza has never failed to impress. Their specials are legendary—especially the 99-cent cheese slices that taste like pure New York nostalgia.

The heart of this place comes from the owners, Mama Rose and Uncle Vinny. They bring so much energy and warmth that you instantly feel like part of the family. On just my second visit, Uncle Vinny remembered my name and even listened to my suggestion about offering his homemade ranch in larger bottles so I could enjoy it at home. That kind of care is rare.

The atmosphere is electric—from Yankees games on the TV to the authentic New York/New Jersey vibes in the air. And let’s talk about the food: the homemade sauce is packed with flavor, and the cook in the back reminds me of my Nana. She pours her spirit into the dough, and I swear there’s a secret ingredient—maybe a mix of sugar, spice, and sunshine—that makes it perfect every time.

The whole staff is incredible. Even during a rush, the cashiers greet you with a smile, making every visit a bright spot in my day. The place keeps evolving and renovating, and I can’t wait to see what’s next.

For me, Mama Rose Pizza is more than just a restaurant—it’s a little escape. A slice of home that takes me right back to New York. I’m even holding out hope for a pickle sandwich on the menu one day for my low-carb moments!

Pizza can be found anywhere, but it’s the people who make a place special. That’s what Mama Rose Pizza is all about: great food, greater people, and a true sense of family. ❤️“

“Came here on vacation, the only thing better than the pizza was the service. Will come again if ever in the area“

“My favorite pizza place ever! ❤️“

“Very good, so good we had to order two of the five days we were there 😉🤣“

“Excellent Pizza, wings and Burgers. Great daily specials. Tommy and his staff are wonderful. Good spot!!“

“Great staff and always good food.“

“While visiting downtown St. Pete last week, we decided to have pizza in our room instead of going out one night. We called Joey Brooklyn's and then walked the two blocks to pick it up. WOW, it was the best decision we could have made. Awesome Pizza!!! Thank You!“

“Treviso's Pizza & Grill is tasty and stands out from the mediocre "pizza" around town. Staff is very friendly. Their two-slice special has generous portions, and their Fried Zucchini and dipping sauce is the best I've had around here! Will definitely be back to try their other menu items soon! Thanks, Treviso's!“

“This establishment is undoubtedly one of my go-to spots whenever I am in town. It offers the finest pizza I have encountered in over thirty years. Eddie and his wife Rena, both dedicated small business owners, invest their heart and soul into every dish they prepare. They are an extraordinary couple who take immense pride in their culinary craft and are genuinely appreciative of their customers. Their commitment to quality and passion for their work truly enhances the dining experience.“

“The best Italian food.. I have tried all their variety of foods and I recommend it.. it’s.. flavor is exquisite go and try it to see for yourself“

“I have gotten take out several times from Nicko’s. The food is always fresh and delicious no matter whether it’s a Specialty Pizza, the 2 slice/drink for a quick grab and go, or their subs!!!! Their prices are great, the staff is super nice, service is fast and the food is delicious!!! It is just the gem we needed on the Southside!!!“

“Amazing dinner tonight! We loved everything we had! Amazing menu with so many options. Such fresh ingredients! We had the white pizza, chicken Parmesan, spaghetti and meatballs, pepperoni/meatball Stromboli, mozzarella sticks, knots and medium wings! Can't wait to come back and try more things!♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️“

“Definitely a diamond in the rough!! There were 5 in our party and even tho we waited awhile it was definitely worth it. Our waitress was excellent and let us know from the beginning that she was backed up but would be back to us as soon as she could check on the other tables. She was actually the only server on duty!! The food was also excellent and well worth the wait and the price was very reasonable. We also sat where we could watch the kitchen staff working their butts off handling table orders as well as a stream of take out orders. All 5 of us agreed our experience was worth every minute. While we were there I didn't hear any complaints at all, which is highly unusual when you have any kind of wait. HIGHLY RECOMMEND. We even tipped the kitchen staff for their hard work.“

“I usually love everything that I've ordered but today I ordered 10 chicken wings with medium sauce from the Seminole location and they were horrible unless you like pepper on your wings. I'm not a fan of pepper and when I called to ask if I received the correct order was informed that this location adds pepper and you have to request no pepper. Wasted money on them today. It should be on the menu that they do this to all of the wings. Disappointed 😞“

“I Love Going To Gianni NY Pizza with my Mom it’s Always A Fun Time With Her Haven’t Been There In A Few Months But It’s Worth The Reive Across Town.“

“The food is Always delicious. Always. And the staff all work hard and are very friendly.“

“Soooo refreshing to enjoy a true, delicious, fresh Italian Pizza! This little gem in the plaza with Publix is tucked away, but what a gem. Calzoni, meatballs, chianti, tiramisu, cappuccino… absolute heaven! So happy to have discovered it :) Bon Appetit!“

“Our friend ordered pizzas from here today, and this was my first time trying it. I built my own pizza with house-made tomato sauce, whipped ricotta, oven-roasted peppers, and baby arugula. We were shocked at how good it was—so delicious and full of flavor and truly a New York Style Pizza! I’ll definitely be going there for more. 😋🍕“

“Passed this place for too long. Ordered an 18 inch pepperoni. Price was great. Pizza was even better! Delivery was fast. Very good. Thanks 4th St. Pizza!“

“Last time I’m ordering from you due to the delivery driver. Time to replace him! Can you not hire a friendly individual?“

“Very good, so good we had to order two of the five days we were there 😉🤣“

“Buona ristorante (aka Buona pizza) advertises themselves as a classy Italian restaurant. This place is nothing more than a pizza joint. Extremely small inside with paper table cloths that they tear off from a big roll on the back wall. Ordered garlic bread and calamari for appetizer. Garlic bread was OK, calamari was so tough you could not even chew it. My mom's OSSO BUCO ALLA MILANESE (pork shank) was seasoned good, but I could tell it was cooked earlier and then heated up. The outside of the pork was warm, but the middle was stone cold. My wife and I got a Hawaiian pizza. It is thin crust and extremely soggy. Could not even pick up the pizza slice it was so soft. Had a horrible, weird tast me to it, almost like a sour tomato sauce. Barely even ate one slice and left the rest of it there. Went there for birthday dinner, and it was ruined. I guess our first red flag should have been that on a Saturday evening, it was not even busy.“

“this is my favorite pizza place in St. Pete! wait times are long even if you call right when they open but, it's so worth the wait!“

“Absolutely the best delicius We love my family and friends Reasonable price,“

“Stopped in for a quick bite, food was delicious 🤤 🤤🤤“

“Very lovely. The staff is friendly, the place, apparently isn't Irish food but PIzza. It's based on a family tradition from Connecticut? The place played relaxing Christmas music, old fashioned style and classic style. I was there in the afternoon...may get louder at night but enjoyed my experience.:) will definitely come try the pizza sometime! Thank you Nick and Mark! You guys have a Merry Christmas!“

“The pizza was AWESOME! We got a pesto mushroom pizza, the bigger size was perfect for two (we ate half at the restaurant and half later). Good beer and liquor selection. The staff was warm and inviting and the place itself was cozy. We sat inside but there was outside seating as well. Overall, great experience.“

“Sooooo good! The Greek salad and the Godfather was amazing! Service was top notch. Amelia was so attentive and friendly.“

“Always great service and awesome food! Don’t forget to get a brownie 😃“

“Great pizza, easily became regular customers.“

“First try, never knew this place was here.. hidden Gem.. food is decent, portion size is fantastic. I got ravioli, didnt know it came with garlic bread and a salad.. I was so full!! I'd pay 10 bucks for all that, any day... versus 12 at McDonalds.. yuck.. this was great!“

“Super fantastic the real cheese extra pepperoni the chicken real chicken wings carmalized with garlic the maranier sauce real bread.it was worth the wait.delivery“

“If you're looking for a fresh take on pizza with top-notch ingredients, best pizza by far and have lived here 25 years, you absolutely have to check out
Slice of Gulfport! It's already become a new favorite spot for a delicious pie, Thank you. Sven“

“We ate here for the first time this week. After we left, my daughter mentioned that the man with dark hair in the back, the cook ? was peering through the kitchen wide open glassless window at her and made her uncomfortable. She said he continued to gaze at her and she requested to leave soon after. She is a minor, not appropriate.“

“Great pizza!! New York style at its best !!“

“This pizza 🍕 is the best!!“

“Shout out to Sara Lee for the delicious Spiced Apple Sangria recommendation!! Make sure you ask for her when you visit!!“

“Took care of us after the hurricane. Great people!“