CARIBBEAN PIE COMPANY
2245 Bee Ridge Rd, Sarasota
(941) 882-4589
Customers' Favorites
Tropical Fruit Key Lime Pie
Raspberry Key Lime Pie
Classic Key Lime Pie
Chocolate Silk Pie
Chocolate Key Lime
Menu
Photos
+33 photos
+32 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This is my fourth year ordering from Caribbean. I ordered four pies for Thanksgiving pecan pie, chocolate mousse, pumpkin pie, and key lime pie. The pecan pie is absolutely delicious, the chocolate mousse is super good, and the pumpkin and key lime pies are amazing as well. Everything was perfect!
We picked up key lime pie on a stick and was disappointed. Especially after hearing they are “award winning”. We have high expectations after having the absolute best ones in the FL Keys. I ate mine in the middle of day, in the sun, and the chocolate just didn’t melt, it also didn’t taste like chocolate. The pie was tasty, crust a bit too thick. But the chocolate not melting ruined it. The ones in the keys are extremely chocolaty, you have to eat quickly, and the...
After 2 different florist shops failed to deliver flowers for a birthday gift, Caribbean pie company was able to come through and save the day. They delivered locally on the day that I requested and were easy to communicate with.
You May Also Like
Magnum Wine and Tastings - 2300 Bee Ridge Rd UNIT 102
![]()
Bar, Wine Bar
Focaccia Sandwich + Bakery - 2300 Bee Ridge Rd
![]()
Bakery, Salad