This is our first time trying Goodfella’s and it did not disappoint. We ordered take out. The pizza is very good! No flop, good sauce, and good semi crunchy buttery crust. It’s bussin
Raqib Hammond
Great food, great customer servive, and clean atmosphere.
Robert Kowal
If you think this is good pizza, you have never had good pizza. Gross.
John Darling
ordered pizza for delivery by phone. was told 30 to 35 minutes. after an hour I called. was told my pizza was supposed to be picked up. I couldn't get there, told girl I specified delivery. told them to keep it. This is the 2nd time in a couple of months, will now go elsewhere
Frank Tulumello
I stopped here for lunch today and ordered the spinach lasagna which came with a house salad. There was no skimping on the amazing salad they brought me. It was a nice sized salad with a very generous amount of freshly sliced tomato, cucumber, onion. Im certain all was freshly sliced before being brought to me. The lasagna was very good and the sauce was fantastic. The only thing they need to improve is their silverware dishwasher. I went through 3 sets that were wrapped in napkins on the same table. All were dirty so I just washed a set myself with water and a napkin instead of making a big deal about it. All in all the service was great and the food was great so I would not hesitate going back. The pizza looked really good so I'll probably try that next time. Thank you for a great lunch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shamiah Bass
I love it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Woodin
It's a shame The Goodfellas in Fort Pierce is so much more efficient. I was placed on hold for over 7 minutes and never answered. So we gave up and went to eat somewhere else. If the owner knew how bad management is treating customers that call on the phone and the money they're losing is substantial, they probably would clean house and hire new people. We won't bother going there anymore. Save yourself the pain!
Service: 1
Joey Guancione
Great pizza....oversized slices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza Rolls, Steak Stromboli Small
Madalin Teter
We have always got pizza to go, but today we ate in. Staff was super cool and friendly. We had draft beer, and it was a fun experience.
Got diarrhea after eating pizza here. Place not clean
The health department needs to go monitor them!
Bad/ rude service from young dark hair short female!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lorenzo Timothy
Awesome place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Troy
Great pizza and wings. Love the garlic knots too. Friendly and polite service. Our whole family has been eating here for years and it has been a consistently excellent experience every time at every location. With so many restaurants lately having lost their minds with their menu prices, Goodfellas stands out as a local shop who actually cares about its community and patrons. Wish we had more places like this.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jack C
Uhhh yeah.. we asked for a garlic sauce and this is what we got… this was about a month ago so I hope things have changed but I won’t order from this location ever again. The amount of straight up minced garlic is ridiculous. Almost comical
Food: 1
CakeSnake Acosta
I ordered Uber Eats delivery and when I opened my pizza box there were 5 small live cockroaches in the pizza box. I immediately killed them all and called the restaurant. I was not even accusing them necessarily as it’s possible they could have came from the drivers car, I simply wanted to let them know the situation. Instead of a professional response, they immediately denied any possibility that it came from them and all but called me a liar. I’ve managed restaurants for most of my life and please believe the last thing I want to do is to leave a bad restaurant review. But based off their response, or lack thereof, I need to warn people in the area of a possible roach infestation at this location.
Great pizza but they didn’t add my pineapple
This is our first time trying Goodfella’s and it did not disappoint. We ordered take out. The pizza is very good! No flop, good sauce, and good semi crunchy buttery crust. It’s bussin
Great food, great customer servive, and clean atmosphere.
If you think this is good pizza, you have never had good pizza. Gross.
ordered pizza for delivery by phone. was told 30 to 35 minutes. after an hour I called. was told my pizza was supposed to be picked up. I couldn't get there, told girl I specified delivery. told them to keep it. This is the 2nd time in a couple of months, will now go elsewhere
I stopped here for lunch today and ordered the spinach lasagna which came with a house salad. There was no skimping on the amazing salad they brought me. It was a nice sized salad with a very generous amount of freshly sliced tomato, cucumber, onion. Im certain all was freshly sliced before being brought to me. The lasagna was very good and the sauce was fantastic.
The only thing they need to improve is their silverware dishwasher. I went through 3 sets that were wrapped in napkins on the same table. All were dirty so I just washed a set myself with water and a napkin instead of making a big deal about it. All in all the service was great and the food was great so I would not hesitate going back. The pizza looked really good so I'll probably try that next time. Thank you for a great lunch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a shame The Goodfellas in Fort Pierce is so much more efficient. I was placed on hold for over 7 minutes and never answered. So we gave up and went to eat somewhere else. If the owner knew how bad management is treating customers that call on the phone and the money they're losing is substantial, they probably would clean house and hire new people. We won't bother going there anymore. Save yourself the pain!
Service: 1
Great pizza....oversized slices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza Rolls, Steak Stromboli Small
We have always got pizza to go, but today we ate in. Staff was super cool and friendly. We had draft beer, and it was a fun experience.
Restaurantji Recommends
Got diarrhea after eating pizza here.
Place not clean
The health department needs to go monitor them!
Bad/ rude service from young dark hair short female!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Awesome place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and wings. Love the garlic knots too. Friendly and polite service. Our whole family has been eating here for years and it has been a consistently excellent experience every time at every location. With so many restaurants lately having lost their minds with their menu prices, Goodfellas stands out as a local shop who actually cares about its community and patrons. Wish we had more places like this.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Uhhh yeah.. we asked for a garlic sauce and this is what we got… this was about a month ago so I hope things have changed but I won’t order from this location ever again. The amount of straight up minced garlic is ridiculous. Almost comical
Food: 1
I ordered Uber Eats delivery and when I opened my pizza box there were 5 small live cockroaches in the pizza box. I immediately killed them all and called the restaurant. I was not even accusing them necessarily as it’s possible they could have came from the drivers car, I simply wanted to let them know the situation. Instead of a professional response, they immediately denied any possibility that it came from them and all but called me a liar. I’ve managed restaurants for most of my life and please believe the last thing I want to do is to leave a bad restaurant review. But based off their response, or lack thereof, I need to warn people in the area of a possible roach infestation at this location.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...