Best NY Pizza of Wesley Chapel

Could use a deep clean

These prices are higher than me at 2am.

I’ve been going here for over 10 years… generally the quality of the food goes down the longer you go… not here. It actually has gotten better recently which I thought was not possible. Prices are up, but up everywhere. Overall this is my top spot in WC..

Their not kidding best Ny style pizza for sure, I loved this place 5 years ago, and I still love them. Made a 20-minute drive just to get pizza. I used to get a couple of large pizzas, but today, I just got a personal cheese pizza for Mama's days. Don't m8nd the picture because, like I said, a 20-minute ride. I had to start eating, 😆.

I recently ordered from this pizzeria through Uber Eats and accidentally selected a pepperoni pizza when I meant to order cheese. Totally my mistake but when I called the restaurant to see if anything could be done, the manager was incredibly understanding and went above and beyond by remaking the order for me. The level of customer service was outstanding, and they handled the situation with so much kindness and professionalism. The food was delicious, and the experience left a lasting impression. I truly appreciate their generosity and top-notch service this kind of care is rare and deserves to be recognized. Highly recommend!

Service was okay. Pizza was delicious! We bought the combo. The canolis were delicious! The ambiance could have been better. During our time there, we had to listen to the ladies at the counter gossip about the guy with the french bulldog that came in to order takeout. The manager tried to kick him out. The blond girl pretended to be friendly, but engaged in negative gossip after he left and we had to hear all about this. The Greek Salad was lacking. No potato salad. Wrong dressing. Ordering is easy. The wait time was reasonable. Overall, it was okay.

Best pizza in Wesley Chapel, authentic taste, and super fast service.

This place is great! I go to the Wesley Chapel location. It's my go-to spot after work... The food is great, and the service is phenomenal. We had Izabella, who was attentive to our needs and very familiar with the menu. I'd highly recommend Best NY Pizza!

Arrived when first opening for the day, not bad at all, however, the menu prices are much higher than what is shared here. Orders were placed and I didn't want to be that guy arguing about the prices so early. Let's be more responsible when posting, spending was than $10 - $20 a person. Previous shared pics had item's priced as $10 - $20, I paid a lot more than that.

Ordered a pepperoni and sausage, I got a black olives and sausage.I do not like black olives. I would never make the mistake of ordering black olives. Check your boxes before you leave. $50 for a large and a gluten free. 20 minutes away. Yay. Thanks guys.

Overall, a pleasant experience and would recommend it to others, When we went, we ordered The Spaghetti and Meatballs meal, and it was the BOMB! So was the the garlic bread and the pizza!
The restaurant had little to no people when we first arrived but started filling up by the minute, Our Waitress Lacey was nice and friendly. The restrooms were clean, The service was fast and the food was great! This is a great place and again, We would really recommend this place to others!?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza by the Slice

We stopped in to this pizza place the day after hurricane Milton ripped through Florida. The staff here were absolutely SWAMPED with orders and literally running around delivering food to tables and handing out takeout orders, as well as answering phones and taking in-person orders. I cannot imagine them being any busier. They were taking so much attitude from people who were annoyed by their wait times. I didn't not hear or see a single
incidence of rudeness. They were all so kind and apologetic, even though people were abhorrently nasty to them. Not one ounce of irritation from a service person there in return.

Oh, and the pizza was delicious. This is our new favorite pizza place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Best Pizza

Good pizza! We get take out all the time but it's nice to come in and sit too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Best Pizza

This is good pizza

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Asked for a LIGHTLY baked pizza and received a raw dough pizza . Then was told that it was baked to their standard of “lightly baked” and was refused a refund . I should’ve listened to the bad reviews. Ridiculous.

Food: 1

Service: 1