Michelli's Pizzeria

Delicious pizza and stuffed shells, baked ziti! Garlic rolls omg!

Tonight, I visited Michelli’s Pizzeria, and to be honest, the interior design wasn’t anything fancy. It has more of a casual, laid-back vibe. Based on the staff’s recommendation, we ordered the supreme pizza, but it took over 30 minutes to arrive. When it finally came out, it was huge—more than enough for three people—but unfortunately, the taste didn’t stand out. It wasn’t bad by any means, just kind of average. It was, well, just pizza.

One thing I did appreciate, though, was how welcoming and friendly the staff were. They had a lot of customers, which was nice to see, but overall, I don’t think I’d go back again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 4

Absolutely delicious!!! We ordered pizza, salad and pasta by delivery. Everything was hot, fresh and cooked to perfection.
Best in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salads, Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots

Wow very sad to see that they raised there prices by double... this way a good place to get good food. Large cheese pizza and knots was only about 15 $ but know they want 30$ that's disappointing

This is truly great pizza. Crisp bottom, nice bite to the crust. The flavors in the sauce and the freshness of their ingredients really make this the best pizza in town. If you’ve never had great Sicilian pizza, try the grandma pie!

Food: 5

Great to

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food and service! Everything is always great here from the dough to the dinners!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza, Salads, Garlic Knots

Best pizza in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We ordered a mild wings and pizza, got home and there was no sauce on the wings. We called the store and I kindly explained there was no sauce on the wings and could I come back and get an order with sauce on them. “Didn’t I give you a cup of sauce?” Yes, I asked for an EXTRA side of sauce. I didn’t ask for the sauce on the side and not on the wings! Not to mention it was a tiny cup of sauce. That does nothing for a 10 piece wing. I said yes but that was supposed to be an extra sauce so can I come get a new wing with sauce. “You can come get another side of sauce.” Are you kidding me? At that point the wings and pizza were going to be cold and nasty. We live 20 minutes away and were already home. & on the phone call not one I’m sorry about that or an inkling of remorse. She could care less. Very poor customer service from the lady that answered my phone call. There was no reason to have an attitude, and I’ve worked in customer service, the simple fix would of been to just say oh yeah no problem we can do that for you and to at least pretend you care.
Without being in sauce the chicken is very dry. My boyfriend didn’t even want to eat them so it was a waste of our $, gas & time.
I never ever leave negative reviews like this but after how I was treated on the phone here we are!
We go here usually every week too so that’s even more frustrating. There are so many other pizza places & We will be finding another one.

I ordered 2 meatball grinders to go which cost almost $28.00 dollars and got 2 small 6” subs ridiculous price for what you get the pic below is one sub.

I can’t say anything about the atmosphere because I had ordered a pizza delivered to my home. But I have been in search for a great pizza place for a long time about a month ago. I ordered a medium meat, lovers pizza and it was great my next-door neighbor came over and enjoyed it so I said finally. I finally found a great pizza place. I ordered a small pizza today Came to me an hour and a half later was cold and the pizza wasn’t even cooked. The dough for the pizza was gummy. I had to reheat my oven to put the pizza back in my oven. I’m so sad because I thought that this was gonna be my pizza place and now I have to move onto another place , what you order maybe larger pizza but I live alone so I don’t order more than what I can eat. Very sad will continue looking.

Food: 2

Service: 2

Ever since I had pizza in New York I’ve been really picky where I buy my pies. This place is as close as it gets to a great New York style pizza and the staff is really welcoming and friendly. Highly recommended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza, Salads, Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots

GREAT FOOD - GREAT SERVICE - QUICK IN AND OUT
http://cash7.us

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza hands down. Any way you could ship me some to Ohio?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

EXCELLENT food, DELICIOUS pizza and PHENOMENAL service. My family and I were visiting relatives in the area and we’d driven 3 hours from our home, so we were famished and needed to eat something before our drive back home. We ordered pizza (with spinach, mushroom, artichoke), meatballs, and Greek salad, and everything was fresh and delicious. The staff was also incredibly friendly and punctual. As someone who’s been living in Boston/the Northeast area, I can confirm that this is true New York pizza, with a staff that takes pride in its work.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5