Michelli's Pizzeria

1ST I see dirty tables and bugs in the floor then I paid close to $12 for 2 slices and a soda. I gave it a shot anyways and no way in hell those 2 slices are worth $10. Didn't even taste good it was mediocre at best. Not even Johns Cafè in Elizabeth NJ is this expensive and they've been open since 1968. They so good that the NY Mets and Knicks orders from them. And you can get 2 slices of REAL pizza and a soda for $7 in JERSEY!!!! This place should sell $1 slices at best. And CLEAN UP THE FILTH IF YOUR GONNA CHARGE THAT MUCH... I THOUGHT I WAS AT YANKEE STADIUM WITH THISE PRICES

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

I've tried every Italian restaurant between Vero and Daytona in my opinion michellis has the best Alfredo sauce in brevard i can t recommend them enough

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Real good authentic NY pizza with great thin crust. Extremely nice staff that are on top of customer needs. Feels like ole time Italian family place. See you next time.

Wonderful experience!! The service was fantastic (as always)- Eileen and Amber were so sweet to my little one. They were friendly, fast and welcoming. I picked up takeout and even after a 25 minute drive home the food was still hot and fresh, which really says a lot about the quality and care they put into their food. They even had a delivery driver help me walk out to my car. All the dishes tasted amazing and was perfectly cooked. Stuffed shells, baked ziti and fettuccine Alfredo and garlic knots. Michellis truly goes above and beyond. Highly recommend anyone looking for great food and excellent service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered online and was given a 35-minute pickup time. When I arrived, my order hadn’t even been printed or started. The staff acted annoyed, made excuses, and showed zero concern for the inconvenience.

I asked for a refund and was met with complete indifference. Saying “it’s football Sunday” is not an excuse for poor customer service. I wasn’t offered an apology at any point.

Clearly, once they get busy, customer service goes out the window. I've been coming here for years and I won’t be returning.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

They have great food and friendly people. You can't ask for more that. I've been eating at Michelle's since they opened.And they are the best pizza parlor. Then make a fantastic and apostate salad as well. I tried almost every dish in there , and they're all perfect.

Grandma pizza is best we ever had. We like extra marinara with ous

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

We love Michelli’s, we stumbled across this wonderful place one night when shopping next store at Publix, and thought let’s try it! We have been repeat customers and order almost every Friday night. We moved here about 2 years ago so we don’t know of a lot of places in the area since we are fairly new here. I’m Italian and love traditional Italian food, mind you we’ve tried many other “Italian New York style pizza” places in Palm Bay and Melbourne and Michelli’s is always our go to! We love coming here, we have dined in a few times and the staff is great and so friendly every time custom service is amazing! The food i to die for fried ravioli for an appetizer, Caesar salad and traditional NY pizza (I am picky as my whole family is from NY lol), cannolis for dessert. Calzones are also great my 7 year old will only eat the calzones from here everything we have tried is great! We love supporting family owned places, and don’t mind spending $20-60 depending on what we decide to order for our family of 3, we’re always full and have leftovers to eat the next day!
I would recommend to friends and family! Thank you Michelli’s we love your food, atmosphere and staff! 10/10!!!!

I just had the best Stromboli possible since moving to Melbourne from South Jersey. Fantastic! Dough was perfectly baked—best sausage I’ve had in ages too. Have had everything from pizza to garlic knots to chicken parm from here and everything is phenomenal. Excellent service and friendly smiles every time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Side of Marinara Sauce, Meatball, Pepperoni Pizza, Large Cheese Pizza, Always Fresh, Supreme, House Salad, Onion Mushroom and Green Peppers, Garlic Rolls

I just had the best Stromboli possible since moving to Melbourne from South Jersey. Fantastic! Have had everything from pizza to garlic knots to chicken parm from here and everything is phenomenal. Excellent service and friendly smiles every time.

They never give you what you order. They always send the wrong things you order a white pie. You get a regular pie New York style. No, it’s not even New Jersey style worst ever.

Ordered a large pizza to go... on busy Friday night... you would think dough would be fresh ...It was like shewing on Leather! Frozen dough or Over worked!

Pizza was phenomenal. Crispy and light. Sauce just right. Good NY style pizza. Prices are fair and the service was good and friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Bayside Lakes location is really nice

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

First time trying this place. 2 thumbs up! Will go again! 👍👍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Salads