Michael's Ali Coal Fired Pizza Winter Garden

Pies are average at best. Nice pics of them though 🤣. Service is excellent.

Super duper fresh hot pizza, so yummy, wonderful thin crust (super thin!) and the crust on the edges were made to perfection. Very gooey and cheesy, would suggest to eat it asap because that’s when it tastes best. I give it a 9/10 on my scale (: 10/10 if it had bigger or more bacon and ham bits and a slightly thicker crust. It was definitely enhanced when we added alll the condiments (parm, garlic powder, pepper flakes, Italian seasoning) 😍 It was busy yet it was made quickly. From what I read, I’d understand if their service isn’t the best, but keep in mind the location and busy-ness.

Decent pizza for a sunny day

Listen born and raised from NYC which as everyone knows the pizza is amazing up there but Michael’s Ali has some much favor shout out this place for making amazing Pizza I will say just try it!!! Hot & Spicy Pepperoni is a must

We really enjoy the Pizza at AJ's, but not being able to order online is a bit annoying. Today we went in to place an order at the bar, but we were told there would be no takeout orders because they are down an oven. Isn't an order an order? It wasn't very busy at the time. We're getting more and more frustrated!

Excellent

Waited 25 minutes and they gave my order to someone else. Def will not waste my time again. Just took my refund and left.

I ordered my meatball sandwich by scanning the QR code on the tabletop and received a text message when it was ready for pickup. I do wish there were pictures associated with the online menu/QR code menu. The QR/menu did advertise a 30 minute wait for the meal ahead of ordering, although I don't think it took that long since I didn't order a pizza.

The positives:
-The baguette was super fresh and light, with a nice crunch to it after being toasted in their oven.
-The meatballs were seasoned well and the sauce didn't overtake the flavor of the entire sandwich.
-It was super hot and came topped with fresh cheese and a side of sliced pickles to clean your palette.

I do wish the actual meatballs were larger. For $15, I felt like the bread filled me up the most. I'd love a better meatball to bread ratio to make the perfect meatball sub.

The pizzas here looked absolutely amazing. I'll have to try that next time - when I didn't bike here for lunch.

I had a colleague in town from Michigan tell me “I want pizza for lunch.” This is the best place I know so here we came. I got their spicy pepperoni pizza today with hot honey glaze. It was divine. Order this pizza. I rate it a 9.5 because I wish it was bigger, so there would be more to eat. But seriously I love it here: the thin and crispy crust, the delicious toppings, the nice staff. You order and they text you when it is ready. ??????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They gave my order to the wrong person, food is good but mistake was annoying. Need to pay attention.

Great pizza, always. Thin, crisp, light textured and flavorful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Peperoni and Bianca Pizza was delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great selections on pies, and great taste. Hardly a wait time even though I noticed there was a lot of orders. Really enjoyed it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Custom Pizza with Pepperoni Ham Olives and Extra Cheese

Margherita Pizza and wings are always my go to! You will not be disappointed.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Wings, Margherita Primo Pizza

Great flavor and texture. Excellent customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5