Michael's Ali Coal Fired Pizza Winter Garden

Service is plain as the pizza and have the gull to ask for gratuities at the POS SYSTEM when cashing out. I was hungry so i ate 2 pieces, my son didn’t finish his first because he didn’t like it. Having a great spot at a great neighborhood means that product and service should be Above that.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

The White pizza was delicious.....the crust was crunchy and great!

Ordered the kitchen sink pizza. Still was good, but mostly mushroom and peppers. Good luck finding any pepperoni or sausages on it. Just not like it use to be.this is the clermont location.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

This was our first time visiting the Plant City Market, and what a treat it was to discover Michael’s Pizza! We ordered two pizzas to-go, and I have to say—they exceeded all expectations.

Each pizza was made to order, and you could immediately tell they were crafted with care. The dough was fresh and had the perfect balance of chew and crisp, the sauce was flavorful and just the right amount, and the cheese was beautifully melted and stretchy—exactly what you want in a quality pizza. The toppings tasted incredibly fresh and were generously portioned, without overpowering the base. It’s clear they use good ingredients and take pride in their food.

Even though we took the pizzas to-go, they were still piping hot and maintained their freshness and texture until we got home. I imagine dining on-site would be even more delightful, especially with the lively atmosphere of the Plant City Market around you.

The service was quick, friendly, and efficient. We felt welcomed from the moment we placed our order. It’s always refreshing to interact with a team that enjoys what they do and values the customer experience.

If you’re in or near Plant City and craving delicious, authentic pizza, Michael’s is 100% worth the stop. It was a great intro to the market and definitely one of the highlights of our visit. We’ll be back for more very soon, maybe next time we’ll try something new from the menu and enjoy it there on the spot!

Highly recommended to pizza lovers and market explorers alike.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

We’ve had pizza here every week we are in Florida and really enjoy it.

It’s inside the building of the Crooked Can Brewery and tastes great with the beers they produce. Having lived in Italy for 3 years we learnt that not all pizzas are the same and the ones we like best have crispy bases and a good level of toppings - this is what you get here!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

My god never again. The service was horrible. Staff were so blah and no personality. The atmosphere is suppose to be fun but it didn't feel fun at all. From the greeting , which was none, to the ordering, no one smiled or spoke to you . Just a bunch of teens/you adults hanging out

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Pies are average at best. Nice pics of them though 🤣. Service is excellent.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Super duper fresh hot pizza, so yummy, wonderful thin crust (super thin!) and the crust on the edges were made to perfection. Very gooey and cheesy, would suggest to eat it asap because that’s when it tastes best. I give it a 9/10 on my scale (: 10/10 if it had bigger or more bacon and ham bits and a slightly thicker crust. It was definitely enhanced when we added alll the condiments (parm, garlic powder, pepper flakes, Italian seasoning) 😍 It was busy yet it was made quickly. From what I read, I’d understand if their service isn’t the best, but keep in mind the location and busy-ness.

Decent pizza for a sunny day

Listen born and raised from NYC which as everyone knows the pizza is amazing up there but Michael’s Ali has some much favor shout out this place for making amazing Pizza I will say just try it!!! Hot & Spicy Pepperoni is a must

We really enjoy the Pizza at AJ's, but not being able to order online is a bit annoying. Today we went in to place an order at the bar, but we were told there would be no takeout orders because they are down an oven. Isn't an order an order? It wasn't very busy at the time. We're getting more and more frustrated!

Excellent

Waited 25 minutes and they gave my order to someone else. Def will not waste my time again. Just took my refund and left.

I ordered my meatball sandwich by scanning the QR code on the tabletop and received a text message when it was ready for pickup. I do wish there were pictures associated with the online menu/QR code menu. The QR/menu did advertise a 30 minute wait for the meal ahead of ordering, although I don't think it took that long since I didn't order a pizza.

The positives:
-The baguette was super fresh and light, with a nice crunch to it after being toasted in their oven.
-The meatballs were seasoned well and the sauce didn't overtake the flavor of the entire sandwich.
-It was super hot and came topped with fresh cheese and a side of sliced pickles to clean your palette.

I do wish the actual meatballs were larger. For $15, I felt like the bread filled me up the most. I'd love a better meatball to bread ratio to make the perfect meatball sub.

The pizzas here looked absolutely amazing. I'll have to try that next time - when I didn't bike here for lunch.

I had a colleague in town from Michigan tell me “I want pizza for lunch.” This is the best place I know so here we came. I got their spicy pepperoni pizza today with hot honey glaze. It was divine. Order this pizza. I rate it a 9.5 because I wish it was bigger, so there would be more to eat. But seriously I love it here: the thin and crispy crust, the delicious toppings, the nice staff. You order and they text you when it is ready. ??????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5