The Pizza Press - Winter Garden

I recommend very good pizza, fresh ingredients and good attention.

Great staff, pizza and atmosphere!

From the moment we walked in, the service was top-notch! The staff was friendly, welcoming, and truly made us feel like valued guests. The restaurant is clean, stylish, and has a fun, newspaper-themed vibe that’s perfect for families, dates, or casual hangouts.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza — WOW! You can build your own masterpiece with fresh, high-quality ingredients, or choose from their creative signature options. The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings generous, and everything tasted incredibly fresh. Our kids loved the interactive experience of choosing their own ingredients, and even our picky eater cleaned his plate!

We also tried their salads and desserts — everything was delicious. To top it off, they have local craft beers on tap, which was a nice bonus.

Highly recommend The Pizza Press in Winter Garden for anyone looking for great food, fast service, and a friendly atmosphere. We'll definitely be back (probably way too often)!

Welp… we tried. And we regretted it.
We walked in with high hopes and walked out wondering if we had just been punk’d. No greeting for 10 minutes. The pizza took an eternity, only to arrive doughy, undercooked, and—wait for it—garnished with a surprise hair. Yum.

The wings? Chewy little rubber stress balls. The patio? A nature documentary. Bird poop everywhere, old crusts on the cushions, and furniture that looked like it had survived a food fight.

Inside wasn’t much better. The soda machine blasted syrup like it was trying to start a sticky revolution.

Final thoughts? Don’t do it. Walk across the street to Ford’s Garage and thank us later. This was our first visit and our very last. We came for dinner. We got an experience. Just not the one we wanted.

Pizza is good. Pasta and salads are available. Chocolate chip cookies are particularly delicious. Good selection of beers. Freestyle machines with lots of choices for non-alcoholic drinks. Service is hit or miss. Employees do a poor job of keeping the dining area clean. Nevertheless, this is one of our favorite pizza joints. We pass by at least five others on our way to Pizza Press because it's better than the rest.

Excellent food and experience!! Great customer service!

I had an incredible experience at The Pizza Press! The concept is simple but brilliant—you get to create your own custom pizza with a wide variety of fresh, high-quality ingredients. The crust is perfectly crisp, and the flavors really come together to create something special.

The staff was super friendly and efficient, making sure our order was just right. The restaurant itself has a great vibe, with a modern, clean look that makes it a comfortable place to enjoy a meal with friends or family. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pizza or want to try something unique, The Pizza Press has you covered. Highly recommend checking it out if you haven’t already!

Delicious pizza made to order before your eyes! Always delicious!

My boyfriend and I went in and waited for 10 mins before we were helped. We were the ONLY ones in there and no one greeted us, no one even looked at us. There was a boy with curly hair and glasses who was making our pizzas and rushing the both of us, as if he didn’t want us to keep on adding more toppings? They were also low on cheese and another boy that was working with a sideways hat on was pissed he had to go and get more cheese. They also wouldn’t get more olives for me. Then all of their friends kept coming in and distracting them to the point where I didn’t even get to add sauce at the end because they took our pizzas out and put them right into a box WHILE they were laughing and talking with their friends that kept coming in, not to mention their friends were going behind the counters and grabbing cups to get sodas from the freestyle machine. It was obnoxious. We ended up leaving with mediocre pizzas. We used to come to this place all the time for years but the service has gone wayyyyy down hill.

Love the Chronicle! So good. My go-to for pizza!

This place was amazing the food was really good and this place was really organized

Very good pizza for a kinda or “subway” of pizza, but I was surprised how good the pizza actually is. Its a great choice for a quick lunch.

Went to The Pizza Press around 5:30 on a Friday with my daughter. One person ahead of us finished ordering, then we waited in line for about 10 minutes without a single word or acknowledgment from the staff. I don’t mind waiting, but being completely ignored—especially as the only ones in line—just felt rude. The employees seemed focused only on online orders and didn’t even glance our way. We ended up leaving without ordering. The pizza’s decent from past experience, but the level of service has declined significantly.

Great pizza, good selection of beer on tap.

Hard to find good quality pizza around Winter Garden but Pizza Press makes it easier. Always clean and attentive. Definitely recommend