facebook instagram facebook instagram

I Love NY Pizza

$ • Pizza, Italian

Hours:
980 Birmingham Rd, Alpharetta
(770) 442-9699

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

I Love NY Pizza Reviews

3.7 (53)

I don't know where some of these reviews are coming from. Best Pizza hands down that we have found in Milton, Woodstock, Alpharetta, holly springs area. Same with the other menu items. If you want to pay $5 for a sandwich loaded with preservatives - go somewhere else. Owner is so nice and not sure if people are expecting Michelin star service & ambiance at a pizza joint. Love this place.

By far the best pizza I’ve ever had, no lie! The pizza was huge and it was perfectly made, nice and thin and perfectly topped! The people who worked there were very nice, I recommend getting there early as they are very busy!!Owner was nice he came to us had a nice conversation. I always love family own business. Some pizza places use premade sauces. Here everything is home made. I love it!!!5 Star...

Tried their Stromboli for the first time and it was good! Two suggestions to make things 5 star which are easy- 1. Heat up the dipping sauce (it was served ice cold) and 2. Close the door. While you maybe warm your customers are freezing and so order to go. Two people walked in while I was there and changed their minds because it was cold. Easy fix guys!

More Reviews(182)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 10AM - 9PM
Tuesday 10AM - 9PM
Wednesday 10AM - 9PM
Thursday 10AM - 9PM
Friday 10AM - 9PM
Saturday 10AM - 9PM
Sunday 10AM - 9PM
Updated on: