Papa Johns Pizza

1860 Barnett Shoals Rd STE 602, Athens
(706) 354-4444

Recent Reviews

Hunter T.

Curly haired guy the night of May 5 at 7:20 pm wouldn't accept my Cash ($100 bill) and made me walk to Walgreens to get change. Legally you should have accepted my Cash and instead you committed illegal business practices. I'm not doing circles for your corporate business for 2 pizzas. Take my cash next time or I'm calling corporate. Have change on hand or don't run a business. I used US legal tender and you should have accepted it. Will be going to Domino's for now on. Broke ahhh

Leah Miller

Always good at this location.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Hand Tossed Pizza

Brandon Williams

Always fresh pizza, they haven't missed

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heather Duncan

It's a pleasure to shop here. Everyone is friendly and asks if they can help you find anything. The store is always clean, merchandised beautifully , and some great sales. Particularly their BOGO's!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Norma Stevens

Toppings is not equally distributed all over the pizza, worst pizza ever

Food: 1

Demario Smith

Great Food The Brownies Be Cooked Just Right....

Dwayne Marshall

Piping hot, fresh pizza delivered every time! Note: Please try to be fair when rating this location. I'm sure they have some extremely busy times depending on the hour of the day, ball games etc...

:3

Have ordered delivery from this location twice, months apart, and it got cancelled nearly an hour after I placed the order each time, with no explanation or notification. If I wouldn’t have attempted to track the order on my own, I would have never known it got cancelled (for no reason). Avoid ordering delivery from this location.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Leadville98

We ordered delivery which arrived on time with no issues. Our problem was the pizza. Papa John’s has gone downhill in the past few years. Most noticeable was the skimpy amount of toppings on the two pizzas we received. One piece of the pepperoni mushroom had no mushroom, the other seven slices had scarce amounts. The same went for the “Garden Fresh” specialty pizza which had so little topping that it was not discernible when eating that it was not a cheese pizza. Crust on the thin was cracker like. Original crust on the other pizza was thin in the center and doughy at the edges, There are a LOT of places to get pizza in this town. Several are worse (Marco’s, Domino’s). But don’t waste your money here when Mama Sid’s is as good/better and WAY cheaper and Johnny’s isn’t a whole lot more in price but 1000 times better.

Caner Kazanci

Ordered online. Got confirmation. Went to pickup half an hour later. The girl at the counter said no order was received. Asked me to place an order again! I showed them the confirmation email. The girl on the counter could not care less. I checked out my credit card and it was charged. I showed them that. Then they said they'll prepare the pizza. I said I don't want pizza and want my money back. They said you should get a refund within 24 hours, and I should call them if I do not receive a refund, but they did nothing for the refund. It was clear the money was gone, so I decided to wait for the pizza I ordered 45 minutes ago. Nice job!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lennord Carroll

The food was cold and the manger was horseplaing with dough and throwing it on the glass that looks like it has not been clean in a couple months what do y'all have working up there 3 year old

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie

Dwayne

The food was cold and the staff and manger was horseplaing you should not be hourseplaing around and you should not be towing dough if that's how a manger going to ack they need to be fired and y'all need to get new

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dwayne Smith

The food was cold and the manger was horseplaing with dough and throwing it on the glass that looks like it has not been clean in a couple months what do y'all have working up there 3 year old

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Hunter Swartz

Horrible experience. Ordered delivery which by itself took forever. Missing a pizza once arrived and could not get a hold of the store over phone. Had to drive to the store where the manager was walking around with a vape in her hand and the pizza chef was adding toppings to the pizza with his bare hands. No gloves. All we got was a store credit, not even a refund. Would not recommend.

Chris Steinberg

The service at this location is incredible! I made a mistake with my order and they were kind enough to fix it for me free of charge. Great people!

Load More