Edgar's Proof & Provision

659 Peachtree St NE, Atlanta
(404) 897-5045

Recent Reviews

Lauren E.

A great option for a quick bite/drink before a show at the Fox! Pretzel was delicious. Also had the hummus and burger. Everything came out quickly and service was good.

Ben Kell

Hard to find the entrance but once inside it was great! We came here to blow some time before going to the Fox. Drinks were great (wife ordered a mojito and I had a beer…no beer on tap here btw. Only cans). Cool vibe, great service. Ordered a quesadilla and it was great. Will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Keith G.

service was fair. 18% gratuity was automatically added to our bill for 2 people. Grilled cheese sandwich was mediocre - tasted off. Pickle was stale. Espresso martini overpriced. No soap in the bathroom.

Kevin I.

Fantastic little pub in the lower level of the Georgian Terrace. So good we hit it up twice. The only knock I give it was on Saturday night they were running out of food and drink. Terry the manager and our server (whose name escapes me) treated us well and made for good company. Highly recommended.

Lucas Graham

Fantastic environment, fantastic food and drink! Eric the bartender is an incredibly nice guy! He will take care of you and make sure you have a good time. All of the staff were phenomenal. I’ll be back in a year for Eric alone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

C Free

Great lemon pepper wings and gumbo.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Koya Tyson

Cute little speakeasy style bar. I didn't order any drinks but I did get the BLT. It was tasty. Come with chips. Fries are on the menu but they no longer serve fries. I was extremely disappointed about that but the BLT was really good. My friends ordered the burger and pretzle and said they were great. Another friend ordered the gumbo and said it was okay. I'd recommend for a late night snack.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Deviled Eggs, Burger

rebecca polhamus

We were staying at the hotel and visited after a show at the Fox. It was def busy walking in, but we were able to share a large booth with a very sweet couple. Our server Jessica was wonderful and we found a new favorite - Hot Tequlia Cosmo and had several and enjoyed a fun evening. The hummus plate was a great late night snack - the other couple had a GIANT pretzel that they enjoyed - def a stop if you are in the area.Vegetarian options: Hummus plate was good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brittany Planovsky

Awful management. Went to dine before a show at Fox 12/17/23. Waited over 45 minutes and when it was time for our table, hostess(manager) was rude and unprofessional. STAY away. I will never dine here again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Elle J.

The service was not well done. We did not get all of our order and the server Barbie was extremely mean and inattentive. We were ignored and fanned off as we attempted to order. It was an overall failure at service, food, and drinks. not interested in coming back.

T Lang A.

do not come here ever. service is below mediocre. poor customer service. poor listening. poor delivery. poor performance.

Brittany P.

Awful management. Went to dine before a show at Fox 12/17/23. Waited over 45 minutes and when our time for table, hostess(manager) was rude and unprofessional. STAY away. I will never dine here again.

DJ H.

This place is in the basement, well the lower level, of the Georgian hotel. The hotel is beautiful and this place is quaint and quiet. I wanted to check it out. It's actually a little difficult to get to. I think they would have bigger crowds if they had easier access directly from the street but it seems like they have that locked. Small but nice menu of small bar bites and craft cocktails. It's a very inviting space and the staff was welcoming though not inspiring bartenders. I was really hoping for a delicious old fashioned but they were out of bitters. I shifted gears, went for a Mezcal Mule. It was fine but not amazing. Menu said it was made with house made ginger beer and honestly, if you are going to that kind of effort, it just wasn't spicy and gingery enough. The smoky mezcal was nice so it was not a complete loss. It's fine. It's perhaps above average for a hotel bar but it's otherwise pretty average or just below for a cocktail bar. I'm not mad at the place it' has a ton of potential if you ask me. It just doesn't reach its potential. In full disclosure and fairness, I did not have any food.

James Donnahoe

Oh boy. We went to Edgar's last night prior to seeing Wiz at the Fox. Edgar's, a Fox Theater partner, was not a good experience. After being seated we waited 30 minutes before notifying the manager that we had not seen our server. He had our server come over and take our order. She was polite, but after taking our order we never saw her again. after waiting an additional 20 minutes and not having our drink orders, I went to find the manager. The bartender saw me waiting, and said that he didn't have any drink orders for us and said he would take our order and bring it to the table. The bartender basically took over for our server, who at this point had no other tables. She was more concerned with her tips and bussing tables, than serving us as the last customers. Even with the bartender helping us, our food was very delayed, and came out piece by piece. The bill was $200, and for the quality of service was not worth it. It was a very terrible experience. After the bartender brought our check, the server came over and asked us if we needed anything. Yikes. The terrible service we received caused us to be late to our show. We were at Edgar's 90 minutes before the show started. No apologies from the manager. PLEASE don't waste your time on this restaurant. Plan and get reservations somewhere else.

Dan N

It's a cool, brick tavern in the basement of the Georgian. Points just for that. The atmosphere, the food, and the service were all excellent.

Load More