Emmy Squared Pizza: West Midtown - Atlanta, Georgia

The chicken pizza we ordered was really good. Everything else was just ok. It is a cool place to hang for a casual bite with friends

Food was amazing. The service was lacking, sadly. We waited at the host stand for several minutes before anyone acknowledged we were there. The restaurant was empty, with the exception of one other table of two. When we were finally acknowledged and seated, the hostess/waitress seemed bothered that we were there and barely spoke to our party as she seated us. The music was very loud, so she might have said something important, but we definitely did not hear it. She did not mention or ask about our reservation. As other diners and food couriers started arriving, they also had to wait several minutes at the host stand before being acknowledged - the hostess kept disappearing into the back. She definitely was not customer service focused. As I mentioned, the food was great. Sadly we won't visit this location again. If we try Emmy's again, it'll be at another ATL location.

Negligent service. They served me a cocktail when I ordered a mocktail and I'm pregnant. Then, tried to blame it on me saying she didn't hear me when she did because she repeated my order back to me. Then, had the audacity to try to get my friends to pay for my bill. Truly messed up place.

It was the perfect place to go to for Father's Day. There was something on the menu for everyone.

The food was good but the cook on the food was where there were some issues. The pizza looked cooked but it was raw unfortunately.. It did taste good but I couldn't overlook having a mouth full of raw dough. The chicken bite things were also super burnt and inedible. The garlic bread sticks were good but there was way too much pesto which made them a bit soggy. The service was great but the food was subpar. May revisit in the future but I wasn't super enthusiastic about the food there due to the way it was cooked.

It took about 10 minutes for someone to come to my table and provide service. It took another 30 minutes for our salad to come out. When I mentioned it to the server, her words were “Perfect.” What type of nonsense is that? We were never offered an apology.

The service was terrible. Our waitress was not attentive at all. Took 20 minutes before she even brought our drinks and two of them were in bottles so why it took that long, we'll never know. Whenever she walked by her tables she never made eye contact to see if we needed anything. Food was great but the waitress needs a refresh.

I ordered Uber eats and they sent me a burnt pizza.

Everything was great! The food was so fresh and delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries, Cheesy Garlic Sticks, MVP Pizza

I love the pizza here so we came back for my birthday dinner! However our waiter was extremely inattentive then TWO time during our dining we had a man from the outside come into the restaurant and ask us for money. Our waiter asked him to leave and he immediately came back asking again it took a few minutes for our waiter to come back and get him to leave. Very uncomfortable eating experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 3

Good sandwiches, but not enough to come back alone for.
I just tried their chicken pesto via delivery and unfortunately it is completely inedible. The bag arrived with the lid not being closed all the way so the pesto oil drowned out the other 2 orders. The amount of oil used for the small serving was 30% oil and the rest pasta shells, little cheese. Again, please avoid the chicken pesto. A reminder to just try pizza places pizza.

This food is so amazing here I can’t write about it enough. I tried the brussel sprouts and butternut squash for my appetizer and the chopped cheese for my entree.
I can’t wait to come back and try a pizza or something.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries

Sydni was a great waitress and was very attentive. We got the vodka pizza, deluxe pizza, Cesar salad and washed them down with a coke and the perfect pair gin cocktail. Amazing experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pepperoni Pizza, Margherita Pizza

This could be such a great spot, but the lackadaisical attitude by the staff is maddening. The first time we went, it took so long for a server to acknowledge us we left. They weren’t busy. Gave them the benefit of the doubt and tried again. Second time was fine. Our third try was an online order for pick up, and an item was missing from the order when I arrived. It took about 30 minutes for them to get me the single item - cheese sticks. The guy helping had BOTH AirPods in his ears. This was probably or last try with this place. But the pizza is good. It’s a shame.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: MVP

We had a delicious drink at the bar while waiting for our pizza. Good times. Cool staff. Our bartender, Adam, was awesome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Colony Pizza