Fishmonger

674 North Highland Avenue Northeast Suite A, Atlanta
(678) 705-9358

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Caesar Salad with Blackened Grouper
Blackened Grouper Caesar Salad
Blackened Grouper Sandwich
Crab and Avocado Sandwich
Fishmonger Tuna Melt
Fishmonger Chowder
Hot Fish Sandwich
Tuna Melt Sandwich
Shrimp Cocktail
Lobster Roll

Menu

SANDWICHES & STARTERS
Blackened Grouper Sandwich
Florida Sauce, Pickled Peppers, Herb Salad, Tomato, Butter-Toasted Martin's Seeded Bun
Hot Fish Sandwich
Mississippi Catfish, Chili Oil, Celery Salad, Buttermilk Dressing, Butter-Toasted Martin's Seeded Bun
Maine Lobster Roll
Connecticut Style, Served Warm on a Split-Top Bun w/ Drawn Butter, Coleslaw, & Pickle
The Fishmonger
Smoked Whitefish or Gin Cured Salmon, Everything Bagel w/ Cream Cheese, Beets, Tomato & Sprouts
Tuna Melt
FM Tuna Salad, Tomato, Sprouts, Pickled Onion, Gruyère, Sourdough Bread
Crab & Avocado
Blue Crab, Avocado, Radish, Citronette, Sprouts, Sourdough (Served open face)
Gulf Shrimp Roll
Seared Gulf Shrimp, Mayo, Fried Shallot, Dill, Lemon, New Bae, Herbs, Tobiko, Butter-Toasted Martin's Seeded Bun
Peel & Eat Shrimp
White Wine, Shrimp Stock, Butter, New Bae Seasoning w/ Coleslaw, Sopping Toast and Cocktail + Florida Sauce
FM Special: BRANZINO SAMMY
Pan-Fried Branzino, Pickled Peppers, Grated Radish and its Sprouts, Tonkatsu Sauce, Potato Bun
Rock Shrimp Ceviche
Florida Rock Shrimp, Lime, Habanero, Mango, Avocado, Tostadas
Shrimp Cocktail
Gulf Shrimp poatched in our Court Bouillon, Beet Cocktail Sauce

SOUP & SALAD
Seafood Chowder
Shrimp, Bay Scallops, Mussels, Clams, Market Fish, Fumet, Yukon Gold Potatoes, Nori Butter Sourdough Bread
Caesar Salad
Romaine, Parmesan, Calabrian Chili, Anchovy Dressing, Bottarga, Bacon Bread Crumb [Add Blackened Grouper +12]
Gumbo
Andouille Sausage, Blackened Shrimp, Crawfish, Okra, Rice

SIDES, ALA CARTE & EXTRAS
Cucumber Salad
Lightly Pickled Cucumber Salad w/ Onions, Black Pepper, Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Beet Salad
Pickled Beets w/ Horseradish, Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs
Coleslaw
Cabbage Slaw with our house New Bae Seasoning
Potato Salad
German Style
Pasta Salad
Calabrian Chili, Black Olive
Curried Corn Salad
Blackened Grouper Filet
Solo Grouper Filet w/ Black Bae Saesoning
Side Sourdough Bread
Side Buttermilk Dressing
Aka Housemade Ranch
Side Florida Sauce
Aka Fishmonger Signature Tarter Sauce
Side Caesar Dressing
Housemade w/ Anchovy and Calabrian Chilis
Side Cocktail Sauce
Housemade Beet Cocktail Sauce
Zapp's Chips

DESSERT
Key Lime Pie
Florida Key Lime Pie w/ Whipped Cream, Lime Zest, Cherry

BEVERAGES
Topo Chico (12oz)
GuS: Valencia Orange Soda (12oz)
Mexican Coca-Cola (12oz)
Mexican Sprite (12oz)
Jarritos: Guava (12.5oz)
Diet Coke (12oz Can)
La Croix (12oz Can)
Saratoga: Still Water (12oz)
Pure Leaf Tea (18.5 oz)
Mineragua (12.5oz)
Maine Root Beer (12oz)

Photos

Photo credit: ubereats
Photo credit: ubereats
Photo credit: google
+20 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+19 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Customer service was on point, we are still talking about the food. It’s a small venue but who cares. The food was so good, fresh and seasoned to perfection, the book on the fish was excellent. The potatoes were so good. Went with my sister and cousin but will be back with my husband! Mad I didn’t take a picture I had the grouper sandwich and the potatoes
December 2025
Hands Down a Gooood Sandwich ….. I got the blackened grouper sandwich and cucumber salad… Delicious…. It’s not a lot of space in there to sit but it’s ok. The food makes up for it. Love the jazz music that was played and lastly the young lady at the front is a sweet heart ❤️ …. We will be back
July 2025
Stopped in at the Poncey-Highland location for lunch. Easy to park in the lot behind at $5 an hour. We had the lobster roll, a blackened grouper sandwich, a cucumber side salad and beet side salad. The lobster roll was tiny and just ok by my New England standards. At $42 “market price” (we should’ve asked before ordering) it was just not with it. The blackened grouper was served hot and was delicious… perfectly spiced. The two side salads were both pickled which wasn’t...
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

JINYA Ramen Bar - Poncey Highland - 676 North Highland Avenue Northeast Suite #3-ABC
Ramen, Bar, Tapas/Small Plates, Vegan
Tio Lucho's - 675 North Highland Avenue Northeast Suite 6000
Peruvian
Sweet Auburn BBQ - 656 North Highland Avenue Northeast
Barbecue, Barbeque, Asian Fusion, Pet Friendly, Vegan

Fishmonger

674 North Highland Avenue Northeast Suite A, Atlanta, GA 30306
(678) 705-9358