Horrible experience drove over an hour paid for parking and only to find our the restaurant is closed for a private event!! The server was so rude and was didn't care.
Dale
The whole experience was great. The food was outstanding. Our bartender was great, friendly and done a great job explaining the food and specials. Very good experience and would recommend to anyone in Midtown Atlanta.
Brittany D
Wonderful for brunch and drinks! Please know this restaurant and bar is tucked away in the Kimpton Shane Hotel. It is quite lovely but the parking is a bit pricey. About $14 for 2 hours and $22 for 2.5+ hours.
I was here for a brunch hosted by the Yelp Elite program. This place is great to host your next private event or dine with people. They served us an incredible spread of food. We had: oysters, shrimp, an omlette station, fruits, salad, French toast, crawfish salad sliders, grits, egg bites, overnight oats, etc. Everything was prepared/cooked to perfection and delicious. The bartenders were also working hard to serve up delicious drinks. I had the Rose Colored Glasses and it was exceptional - especially if you like gin.
The patio was the star of the show after the food. They decorated it with stunning flower atriums around the tables. It was a perfect day to sit out there and marvel at the sunshine. It was such a gorgeous and relaxing environment for a Sunday afternoon. It felt like there was no better place in Atlanta to be.
The staff went above and beyond to create a pleasant experience for us to enjoy. The Shane is where you need to go for your next time dining out or to catch drinks. This is one of the few places that are worth the value in Atlanta.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alan
Great service, but food quality was just OK. If you plan to attend brunch, please go after 11 am. Whereas most brunches have both breakfast and lunch options available the entire time, Hartley doesn't bring out the brunch items (which are the best) until 11 am.
Christopher
The menu and pictures online oversell the experience. It is at beat a hotel food spot. Not necessarily a restaurant. The food was very bland no flavor (much like hospital cafeteria food) very disappointing. Maybe this venue gets better for dinner but Lunch is not it!
Colbey Reagan
I ate here first and foremost because I was a guest of the hotel and I needed an easy dinner. I was the only person in the restaurant and that gave me some apprehension, but my dinner was absolutely fantastic. Ordered the veal meatloaf which was incredibly delicious. It sat atop buttery mashed potatoes and truly perfectly cooked broccolini. A nice gravy tied it altogether. If this place was in my hometown I would be a regular for that dish alone. Zero notes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth
Could not find the place. No neighboring establishments were familiar with it. The listed phone number did not work
Andrew Hodges
We had a bit of a mixed experience at The Hartley. The ambiance was lovely, and our server, Rori, was fantastic and attentive. The fries were absolutely delicious, but unfortunately, the steak was inedible. The restaurant did make up for it by comping the steak and offering dessert, which we appreciated. Also, note that only valet parking is validated, so we ended up paying $10 for self-parking. Overall, we’re giving it three stars.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Lisa
We grabbed dinner before a show. Food was well prepared and seasoned well. Nothing fancy. Prices were high, but not unexpected for the convenience of eating where we stayed and in downtown ATL. Service was so warm and accommodating. We'd pay the prices every time for the ease, convenience and quality.
We chose The Hartley for our anniversary dinner, and it was truly unforgettable. From the moment we arrived, the staff made us feel celebrated with a thoughtful handwritten “Happy Anniversary” card and complimentary champagne to toast the evening. That kind of personal touch set the tone for a night that felt incredibly special.
To start, we shared two delicious appetizers: the Crawfish & Jalapeño Croquettes and the Crispy Jambalaya Arancini—both were perfectly crisp, flavorful, and a great way to begin the meal.
For entrées, I had the Alaskan Halibut, which was delicate, buttery, and beautifully prepared. My husband ordered the Rainbow Trout, which was equally impressive—fresh, flavorful, and expertly cooked.
We paired our meals with two standout cocktails: the Grant Park and the Southside Sipper. Both were refreshing, well-balanced, and elevated the entire experience.
A live guitarist was performing and singing throughout the evening, creating a warm, romantic atmosphere that made the night even more memorable.
And the dessert? Absolutely unforgettable. The Peach Almond Cream Tart was divine—so good, I joked that I could’ve eaten seven. It was the perfect sweet ending to a flawless meal.
From the food and drinks to the service and ambiance, The Hartley exceeded every expectation. It’s the kind of place that makes a special occasion feel even more meaningful. We would absolutely recommend it and can’t wait to return.
Nessa Sherysse
A time was had. We absolutely loved our waitress Tahj. We were at The Hartley brunch downstairs and there is a nice later venue upstairs. The whole restaurant was a great quiet vibe. When they get music and an actual brunch vibe it’ll be even better. Had the shrimp and grits 1️⃣0️⃣! Bottomless mimosa for $20 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. The biscuit was good and crispy. If you’re used to soft biscuit this is a different vibe. The potatoes were seasoned and I absolutely loved them. My friend had the Benedict but fried hard. She loved it. I had coffee and she had an iced coffee with oat milk. A great quiet vibe with good food. A little basic variety but no complaints on taste. When they get a vibe in here it’ll be top tier!
Philip
Had no idea they were part of an IHG hotel. I make it a practice to not eat in hotel restaurants so once I arrived I knew we were in for a lackluster dinner. Service was very slow and we had to ask for water twice. Wine List was very weak - the Tuscan red was bitter - stick with the Cab. I had the Butternut squash Bolognese and added a chicken breast for protein. The Pasta was overcooked, the chicken was way over cooked and tough and the butternut squash was undercooked. Don't waste your time on this place. If you do go, stick to a burger or something simple enough that they possibly can't destroy the dish. Very disappointed.
Sindy P
Food was very good. Terrible service, today, 1pm, young waiter, so rude, not interested at all on serving us. Not sure how management don’t notice this behavior. Anyway, food was great so it deserves another try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Randall
I really like dining here but something has change with the service. We waited for a very long time to get drinks for the table from the bar, the first and second round. The kitchen was running behind even though there was hardly anyone in the restaurant. I really used to love this place, so I am hopeful that it was just an off night for them.
Great service and food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible experience drove over an hour paid for parking and only to find our the restaurant is closed for a private event!! The server was so rude and was didn't care.
The whole experience was great. The food was outstanding. Our bartender was great, friendly and done a great job explaining the food and specials. Very good experience and would recommend to anyone in Midtown Atlanta.
Wonderful for brunch and drinks! Please know this restaurant and bar is tucked away in the Kimpton Shane Hotel. It is quite lovely but the parking is a bit pricey. About $14 for 2 hours and $22 for 2.5+ hours.
I was here for a brunch hosted by the Yelp Elite program. This place is great to host your next private event or dine with people. They served us an incredible spread of food. We had: oysters, shrimp, an omlette station, fruits, salad, French toast, crawfish salad sliders, grits, egg bites, overnight oats, etc. Everything was prepared/cooked to perfection and delicious. The bartenders were also working hard to serve up delicious drinks. I had the Rose Colored Glasses and it was exceptional - especially if you like gin.
The patio was the star of the show after the food. They decorated it with stunning flower atriums around the tables. It was a perfect day to sit out there and marvel at the sunshine. It was such a gorgeous and relaxing environment for a Sunday afternoon. It felt like there was no better place in Atlanta to be.
The staff went above and beyond to create a pleasant experience for us to enjoy. The Shane is where you need to go for your next time dining out or to catch drinks. This is one of the few places that are worth the value in Atlanta.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service, but food quality was just OK. If you plan to attend brunch, please go after 11 am. Whereas most brunches have both breakfast and lunch options available the entire time, Hartley doesn't bring out the brunch items (which are the best) until 11 am.
The menu and pictures online oversell the experience. It is at beat a hotel food spot. Not necessarily a restaurant. The food was very bland no flavor (much like hospital cafeteria food) very disappointing. Maybe this venue gets better for dinner but Lunch is not it!
I ate here first and foremost because I was a guest of the hotel and I needed an easy dinner. I was the only person in the restaurant and that gave me some apprehension, but my dinner was absolutely fantastic. Ordered the veal meatloaf which was incredibly delicious. It sat atop buttery mashed potatoes and truly perfectly cooked broccolini. A nice gravy tied it altogether. If this place was in my hometown I would be a regular for that dish alone. Zero notes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Could not find the place. No neighboring establishments were familiar with it. The listed phone number did not work
We had a bit of a mixed experience at The Hartley. The ambiance was lovely, and our server, Rori, was fantastic and attentive. The fries were absolutely delicious, but unfortunately, the steak was inedible. The restaurant did make up for it by comping the steak and offering dessert, which we appreciated. Also, note that only valet parking is validated, so we ended up paying $10 for self-parking. Overall, we’re giving it three stars.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
We grabbed dinner before a show. Food was well prepared and seasoned well. Nothing fancy. Prices were high, but not unexpected for the convenience of eating where we stayed and in downtown ATL. Service was so warm and accommodating. We'd pay the prices every time for the ease, convenience and quality.
Restaurantji Recommends
We chose The Hartley for our anniversary dinner, and it was truly unforgettable. From the moment we arrived, the staff made us feel celebrated with a thoughtful handwritten “Happy Anniversary” card and complimentary champagne to toast the evening. That kind of personal touch set the tone for a night that felt incredibly special.
To start, we shared two delicious appetizers: the Crawfish & Jalapeño Croquettes and the Crispy Jambalaya Arancini—both were perfectly crisp, flavorful, and a great way to begin the meal.
For entrées, I had the Alaskan Halibut, which was delicate, buttery, and beautifully prepared. My husband ordered the Rainbow Trout, which was equally impressive—fresh, flavorful, and expertly cooked.
We paired our meals with two standout cocktails: the Grant Park and the Southside Sipper. Both were refreshing, well-balanced, and elevated the entire experience.
A live guitarist was performing and singing throughout the evening, creating a warm, romantic atmosphere that made the night even more memorable.
And the dessert? Absolutely unforgettable. The Peach Almond Cream Tart was divine—so good, I joked that I could’ve eaten seven. It was the perfect sweet ending to a flawless meal.
From the food and drinks to the service and ambiance, The Hartley exceeded every expectation. It’s the kind of place that makes a special occasion feel even more meaningful. We would absolutely recommend it and can’t wait to return.
A time was had. We absolutely loved our waitress Tahj. We were at The Hartley brunch downstairs and there is a nice later venue upstairs. The whole restaurant was a great quiet vibe. When they get music and an actual brunch vibe it’ll be even better. Had the shrimp and grits 1️⃣0️⃣! Bottomless mimosa for $20 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. The biscuit was good and crispy. If you’re used to soft biscuit this is a different vibe. The potatoes were seasoned and I absolutely loved them. My friend had the Benedict but fried hard. She loved it. I had coffee and she had an iced coffee with oat milk. A great quiet vibe with good food. A little basic variety but no complaints on taste. When they get a vibe in here it’ll be top tier!
Had no idea they were part of an IHG hotel. I make it a practice to not eat in hotel restaurants so once I arrived I knew we were in for a lackluster dinner. Service was very slow and we had to ask for water twice. Wine List was very weak - the Tuscan red was bitter - stick with the Cab. I had the Butternut squash Bolognese and added a chicken breast for protein. The Pasta was overcooked, the chicken was way over cooked and tough and the butternut squash was undercooked. Don't waste your time on this place. If you do go, stick to a burger or something simple enough that they possibly can't destroy the dish. Very disappointed.
Food was very good. Terrible service, today, 1pm, young waiter, so rude, not interested at all on serving us. Not sure how management don’t notice this behavior. Anyway, food was great so it deserves another try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
I really like dining here but something has change with the service. We waited for a very long time to get drinks for the table from the bar, the first and second round. The kitchen was running behind even though there was hardly anyone in the restaurant. I really used to love this place, so I am hopeful that it was just an off night for them.
Loading...