We had a bit of a mixed experience at The Hartley. The ambiance was lovely, and our server, Rori, was fantastic and attentive. The fries were absolutely delicious, but unfortunately, the steak was inedible. The restaurant did make up for it by comping the steak and offering dessert, which we appreciated. Also, note that only valet parking is validated, so we ended up paying $10 for self-parking. Overall, we’re giving it three stars.
Kaia Brown
We chose The Hartley for our anniversary dinner, and it was truly unforgettable. From the moment we arrived, the staff made us feel celebrated with a thoughtful handwritten “Happy Anniversary” card and complimentary champagne to toast the evening. That kind of personal touch set the tone for a night that felt incredibly special.
To start, we shared two delicious appetizers: the Crawfish & Jalapeño Croquettes and the Crispy Jambalaya Arancini—both were perfectly crisp, flavorful, and a great way to begin the meal.
For entrées, I had the Alaskan Halibut, which was delicate, buttery, and beautifully prepared. My husband ordered the Rainbow Trout, which was equally impressive—fresh, flavorful, and expertly cooked.
We paired our meals with two standout cocktails: the Grant Park and the Southside Sipper. Both were refreshing, well-balanced, and elevated the entire experience.
A live guitarist was performing and singing throughout the evening, creating a warm, romantic atmosphere that made the night even more memorable.
And the dessert? Absolutely unforgettable. The Peach Almond Cream Tart was divine—so good, I joked that I could’ve eaten seven. It was the perfect sweet ending to a flawless meal.
From the food and drinks to the service and ambiance, The Hartley exceeded every expectation. It’s the kind of place that makes a special occasion feel even more meaningful. We would absolutely recommend it and can’t wait to return.
Nessa Sherysse
A time was had. We absolutely loved our waitress Tahj. We were at The Hartley brunch downstairs and there is a nice later venue upstairs. The whole restaurant was a great quiet vibe. When they get music and an actual brunch vibe it’ll be even better. Had the shrimp and grits 1️⃣0️⃣! Bottomless mimosa for $20 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. The biscuit was good and crispy. If you’re used to soft biscuit this is a different vibe. The potatoes were seasoned and I absolutely loved them. My friend had the Benedict but fried hard. She loved it. I had coffee and she had an iced coffee with oat milk. A great quiet vibe with good food. A little basic variety but no complaints on taste. When they get a vibe in here it’ll be top tier!
Sindy P
Food was very good. Terrible service, today, 1pm, young waiter, so rude, not interested at all on serving us. Not sure how management don’t notice this behavior. Anyway, food was great so it deserves another try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Edwin
Came here on a work dinner with a few of my colleagues. I was optimistic at first, the ambience was very swanky, but those warm feelings quickly dissipated as we waited 45 minutes for drinks... This place charges very premium prices but their service or rather their lack* of service is absolutely deplorable.
Throughout the night i noticed quite a few managers roaming around the restaurant, not quite sure what they were managing exactly... Maybe sub out one of your 4 managers for an extra server and or bartender.
In short, i would not recommend. Take your hard earned money, more importantly take your time elsewhere. Park Colony Square is an earshot away.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Terrance Hill
Best experience and surprisingly some of the best Breakfast in ATL. I wouldn't have obstacles at the hotel and I would still go and eat breakfast here. Great customer Service and great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hartley Breakfast
iscariot TF
I really, really wanted to like this place. It came highly recommended by several people but I was sadly disappointed. My wife and I showed up on time for our reservation, then waited somewhere between five and ten minutes to be seated. We didn't get our drinks for half an hour, and even then, after part of our dinner order came out. Oh, and this was Valentine's day, so a set menu so nothing exotic. All in all, we spent nearly two hours there, probably about 1.5 of that waiting. I don't blame the waitress, she was completely overloaded. Kept hearing "the bar is backed up" despite seeing other people ordering. We didn't even order anything strange, just wine. The only thing that they managed to do in a timely manner was run our credit card. It even took 15 minutes to bring us a check. Atmosphere was ok. They had a live musician but he was so incredibly loud that my wife and I were almost shouting at each other, despite a wall being between us and him. It did finally get a little quieter though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Talmak Owl
Off the beaten track and a little hard to find however the food that excellent; service was really good and attentive and while it is attached to a bar the music level allowed for casual dining and conversations
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagyu Beef Burger
Bailey Xan
Asked the waiter if they had hot chocolate on the menu, he said no but he ended up asking the bar to make one for me spontaneously out of ingredients they had.
Food tasted great but steak came warm, not hot. Food took a bit long to deliver when the restaurant was empty but the restaurant looked great and had a nice, inviting atmosphere.
Parking: Valet for the hotel or parking in a separate garage that does not belong to the hotel or restaurant.
The service was disappointingly inattentive, and the staff exuded an air of disinterest that bordered on rudeness. It felt like we were an inconvenience rather than valued guests. The bacon, rather than being crisp and flavorful, arrived limp and unappetizing, as if it had barely been introduced to the griddle. The eggs, intended to be the centerpiece of the plate, were sadly undercooked, with runny whites that made it impossible to enjoy.
As for the grits—well, calling them watery would be generous. They were a soupy, flavorless mess, drenched in enough butter to conjure nightmares of cholesterol spikes, yet somehow still lacking any depth or seasoning. Eating them felt less like a treat and more like a dare. This meal was a disappointment from start to finish, with neither the food nor the service making a case for a return visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jasmine O'Conner
This restaurant, located inside the Kimpton The Shane Hotel in Atlanta | Midtown, is stunning. I loved the ambiance and overall vibe. Every server and hostess who helped me during my stay was incredibly welcoming, friendly, and helpful—I couldn’t have asked for a better dining experience at a hotel. I tried breakfast, lunch, and dinner here and would highly recommend them all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Lesperance
Hartley used to have great bartenders but I was recently there and the bartender Caitie was extremely rude. I love this hotel but the food and service at hartley are horrible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jim Rossiter
We had their burger and beer special. They had good live music too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Adonai
Great food and an even better service from David!! Thank you for making our night!
We had a bit of a mixed experience at The Hartley. The ambiance was lovely, and our server, Rori, was fantastic and attentive. The fries were absolutely delicious, but unfortunately, the steak was inedible. The restaurant did make up for it by comping the steak and offering dessert, which we appreciated. Also, note that only valet parking is validated, so we ended up paying $10 for self-parking. Overall, we’re giving it three stars.
We chose The Hartley for our anniversary dinner, and it was truly unforgettable. From the moment we arrived, the staff made us feel celebrated with a thoughtful handwritten “Happy Anniversary” card and complimentary champagne to toast the evening. That kind of personal touch set the tone for a night that felt incredibly special.
To start, we shared two delicious appetizers: the Crawfish & Jalapeño Croquettes and the Crispy Jambalaya Arancini—both were perfectly crisp, flavorful, and a great way to begin the meal.
For entrées, I had the Alaskan Halibut, which was delicate, buttery, and beautifully prepared. My husband ordered the Rainbow Trout, which was equally impressive—fresh, flavorful, and expertly cooked.
We paired our meals with two standout cocktails: the Grant Park and the Southside Sipper. Both were refreshing, well-balanced, and elevated the entire experience.
A live guitarist was performing and singing throughout the evening, creating a warm, romantic atmosphere that made the night even more memorable.
And the dessert? Absolutely unforgettable. The Peach Almond Cream Tart was divine—so good, I joked that I could’ve eaten seven. It was the perfect sweet ending to a flawless meal.
From the food and drinks to the service and ambiance, The Hartley exceeded every expectation. It’s the kind of place that makes a special occasion feel even more meaningful. We would absolutely recommend it and can’t wait to return.
A time was had. We absolutely loved our waitress Tahj. We were at The Hartley brunch downstairs and there is a nice later venue upstairs. The whole restaurant was a great quiet vibe. When they get music and an actual brunch vibe it’ll be even better. Had the shrimp and grits 1️⃣0️⃣! Bottomless mimosa for $20 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. The biscuit was good and crispy. If you’re used to soft biscuit this is a different vibe. The potatoes were seasoned and I absolutely loved them. My friend had the Benedict but fried hard. She loved it. I had coffee and she had an iced coffee with oat milk. A great quiet vibe with good food. A little basic variety but no complaints on taste. When they get a vibe in here it’ll be top tier!
Food was very good. Terrible service, today, 1pm, young waiter, so rude, not interested at all on serving us. Not sure how management don’t notice this behavior. Anyway, food was great so it deserves another try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Came here on a work dinner with a few of my colleagues. I was optimistic at first, the ambience was very swanky, but those warm feelings quickly dissipated as we waited 45 minutes for drinks... This place charges very premium prices but their service or rather their lack* of service is absolutely deplorable.
Throughout the night i noticed quite a few managers roaming around the restaurant, not quite sure what they were managing exactly... Maybe sub out one of your 4 managers for an extra server and or bartender.
In short, i would not recommend. Take your hard earned money, more importantly take your time elsewhere. Park Colony Square is an earshot away.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Best experience and surprisingly some of the best Breakfast in ATL. I wouldn't have obstacles at the hotel and I would still go and eat breakfast here. Great customer Service and great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hartley Breakfast
I really, really wanted to like this place. It came highly recommended by several people but I was sadly disappointed. My wife and I showed up on time for our reservation, then waited somewhere between five and ten minutes to be seated. We didn't get our drinks for half an hour, and even then, after part of our dinner order came out. Oh, and this was Valentine's day, so a set menu so nothing exotic. All in all, we spent nearly two hours there, probably about 1.5 of that waiting. I don't blame the waitress, she was completely overloaded. Kept hearing "the bar is backed up" despite seeing other people ordering. We didn't even order anything strange, just wine. The only thing that they managed to do in a timely manner was run our credit card. It even took 15 minutes to bring us a check. Atmosphere was ok. They had a live musician but he was so incredibly loud that my wife and I were almost shouting at each other, despite a wall being between us and him. It did finally get a little quieter though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Off the beaten track and a little hard to find however the food that excellent; service was really good and attentive and while it is attached to a bar the music level allowed for casual dining and conversations
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagyu Beef Burger
Asked the waiter if they had hot chocolate on the menu, he said no but he ended up asking the bar to make one for me spontaneously out of ingredients they had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagyu Beef Burger, Roasted Potatoes
Food tasted great but steak came warm, not hot. Food took a bit long to deliver when the restaurant was empty but the restaurant looked great and had a nice, inviting atmosphere.
Parking: Valet for the hotel or parking in a separate garage that does not belong to the hotel or restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
The service was disappointingly inattentive, and the staff exuded an air of disinterest that bordered on rudeness. It felt like we were an inconvenience rather than valued guests. The bacon, rather than being crisp and flavorful, arrived limp and unappetizing, as if it had barely been introduced to the griddle. The eggs, intended to be the centerpiece of the plate, were sadly undercooked, with runny whites that made it impossible to enjoy.
As for the grits—well, calling them watery would be generous. They were a soupy, flavorless mess, drenched in enough butter to conjure nightmares of cholesterol spikes, yet somehow still lacking any depth or seasoning. Eating them felt less like a treat and more like a dare. This meal was a disappointment from start to finish, with neither the food nor the service making a case for a return visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
This restaurant, located inside the Kimpton The Shane Hotel in Atlanta | Midtown, is stunning. I loved the ambiance and overall vibe. Every server and hostess who helped me during my stay was incredibly welcoming, friendly, and helpful—I couldn’t have asked for a better dining experience at a hotel. I tried breakfast, lunch, and dinner here and would highly recommend them all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hartley used to have great bartenders but I was recently there and the bartender Caitie was extremely rude. I love this hotel but the food and service at hartley are horrible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
We had their burger and beer special. They had good live music too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and an even better service from David!! Thank you for making our night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...