Mellow Mushroom Atlanta - Midtown

The pizza as always was amazing. But I was disappointed by the service. I set a pick up order online a few hours ahead of time, but when I got to this store the server had no idea what I was talking about despite my email confirmation. After about 10 minutes she finally located the ticket. She reached out to me and told they just got started on the order and I would have to wait and additional 20-30 minutes. It was very clear that they just hadn't done my order at all.

As I was waiting, I was hit with a paper football. 2 servers were killing time playing football nearby and hit it too far - despite the restaurant being busy.

Very disappointed and frustrating to watch several other people pick up their orders.

We ate outside. The waitress was nice, but not attentive. We sat for about 45 minutes before she took our orders. It was late afternoon on a Sunday. I didn't go inside so maybe she was slammed? When the food finally arrived it was okay. Pizza was greasy, not very flavorful. Would not eat there again. (It wasn't horrible, but there are so many other options that are better in the area.)

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

The staff is always nice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Don’t order to go

First time experience with this MM location, and thoroughly enjoyed our evening. Many thanks to Wallace for his great service, attentive nature and all-round a very nice gentleman. Just moved to the Midtown from the suburbs, and will definitely return for dinner or lunch again soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Just another great night at mellow mushroom!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Great pizza, subs, and calzones! They even have gluten-free crust pizza, which is great for my wife. Great prices too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered a calzone with vegan cheese and veggie insides.... The cheese was u melted in the inside.... Please change your vegan cheese! Miyokos pourable is better than this! Not only that - they gave me 2 slices of tomatoes.... Should have been diced. This was horrible! I paid extra for jalapeños and black olives. This looks a mess. I just left seeing as I had somewhere to be. Next time I'll go somewhere else. 👎🏿

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

waited over an hour for an order and was then told i wouldn't get it because the restaurant was closing

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Excellent vibes excellent spin on Taco Tuesday with the Taco Nirvana Pizza Half Chicken/Half Beef and a Spiked Mango Margarita. The server was excellent with speed and accuracy and the barmaid mixed the cocktail perfectly. Absolutely love the decorations and overall feel of these establishments. Highly recommend anything on the new Taco menu. The prices are a little higher than normal pizza parlors but well worth it.

so fire like usual!!

Amelia, gave the BEST 👉🏾 Customer Service ever! Amelia you ROCK 🫶🏾🤘🏾🤘🏾

It's a great pizza place very close to the park. The service is excellent, the place is clean, the pizza and beer are great. Wonderful place to go if you're in the mood.

Service and atmosphere are good. It appears that all restaurants have started slacking on food ....... I ordered a medium pizza with olives, jalapeno, and spinach..... I could literally count the pieces of each on the pizza. At this point it's best to eat at home if you expect things to be as they should.

Another good experience at mellow