Ordered 3 pieces of cake with some friends. Every one of them, all different cakes, were dry as dirt and crumbling apart upon arrival. One of the slices, carrot cake, was so dry the icing in between layers was practically non existent because the cake tried to absorb the moisture (I guess). If you’re looking for the best single slice, most moist, delicious carrot cake in town - McAlister’s Deli. Hands down the tops. Does not disappoint ever. And it’s chilled properly, not left out so you’ve no idea how old the slice you’re getting is.
Pat A
The cake is moist and the frosting is delicious. My favorite flavors are white chocolate, caramel, and orange. Go on Tuesdays - it’s buy one slice get one half off.
Kay Jackson
Best service!!!!!! Best cake!!!! Hands down!!! Will be my location for sure!!!!
John Hatch
I'm very particular when it comes to cake, but Piece of Cake can pretty much always delivers. The white chocolate is a favorite as well as the Oreo and Strawberry. The chocolate is okay. Could be a bit more fudgy and dark for my taste. The poundcakes are also quite good.
It's not the most amazing cake ever, but it is very good, and always fresh in my experience. Thus, it's a favorite for special occasions when we need a cake.
Sherry Ollison
Samantha was helpful.
Zane Pramudji
Went to Piece of Cake for the first time today. It was my first time, and I got slices that I enjoyed with friends.
Cake was great! Customer service phenomenal! The woman that was working was incredibly friendly and kind to my friends and I, and let me know that I could get a free cupcake if I signed up for the rewards program.
Great experience, great employee, reasonable prices. I will absolutely be back.
Kirill Makarenko
Gave this place another try after my first slice tasted like the desert outside Amarillo. My second try ended in a canceled order for no discernable reason. The location may try to blame their Doordash integration or the customer, but we placed the order on the Piece of Cake site.
This location treats accountability like a foreign concept that overstayed its visa. I'm not knocking Piece of Cake generally, since some locations are genuinely good, but this one should not be anyone's first choice.
Kendra Shante
Had a cake delivered roadie the company they used took a picture of a cardboard box and said delivered and took my cake home. 80$ for a cake I never received
Ana Krohn
Very disappointed with the German Chocolate Cake. May try another flavor or stick to traditional next time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Ada Safiya
My parents stop in from daytona because my brother gf told them how great the cupcakes are. However, they are dry. The icing is hard. Please take this criticism and go back to the drawing board. Even the german cake is not that good. Overall the food was really bad.
Whenever I have a cake cravings, I go to the best place that sells the best White Chocolate Cake and that’s here at Piece of Cake. We usually go to a different outlet but this was our first time here and we felt so welcomed because of how friendly this lovely lady behind the counter was hence we got 3 slices this time around; White chocolate, Birthday slice & Strawberry. Love all of it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Slice, White Chocolate No Nuts Slice
Christian Hensley
Best cupcakes I've ever had
Jennifer Perry
I’ve been going to piece of cake for years. In the past it was such a treat because they were always delicious.But the Dunwoody store is just not good.Their slices are dry and seem old. I have a hard time believing they are fresh baked daily for this location. Every once in a while, I will get a moist slice, but not often enough to go back, unfortunately.Might try Buckhead location again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Felicia Manigault
I love the Mt Vernon location. This is my 2nd visit here and I have been pleased every time. I usually go to the location near Decatur. Theresa at the Mt Vernon location makes me feel so welcomed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Ball
Brought vanilla/chocolate icing and a carrot cake(my ? favorite)..wasn't as moist or tasty as usual ?
Ordered 3 pieces of cake with some friends. Every one of them, all different cakes, were dry as dirt and crumbling apart upon arrival. One of the slices, carrot cake, was so dry the icing in between layers was practically non existent because the cake tried to absorb the moisture (I guess). If you’re looking for the best single slice, most moist, delicious carrot cake in town - McAlister’s Deli. Hands down the tops. Does not disappoint ever. And it’s chilled properly, not left out so you’ve no idea how old the slice you’re getting is.
The cake is moist and the frosting is delicious. My favorite flavors are white chocolate, caramel, and orange. Go on Tuesdays - it’s buy one slice get one half off.
Best service!!!!!! Best cake!!!! Hands down!!! Will be my location for sure!!!!
I'm very particular when it comes to cake, but Piece of Cake can pretty much always delivers. The white chocolate is a favorite as well as the Oreo and Strawberry. The chocolate is okay. Could be a bit more fudgy and dark for my taste. The poundcakes are also quite good.
It's not the most amazing cake ever, but it is very good, and always fresh in my experience. Thus, it's a favorite for special occasions when we need a cake.
Samantha was helpful.
Went to Piece of Cake for the first time today. It was my first time, and I got slices that I enjoyed with friends.
Cake was great! Customer service phenomenal! The woman that was working was incredibly friendly and kind to my friends and I, and let me know that I could get a free cupcake if I signed up for the rewards program.
Great experience, great employee, reasonable prices. I will absolutely be back.
Gave this place another try after my first slice tasted like the desert outside Amarillo. My second try ended in a canceled order for no discernable reason. The location may try to blame their Doordash integration or the customer, but we placed the order on the Piece of Cake site.
This location treats accountability like a foreign concept that overstayed its visa. I'm not knocking Piece of Cake generally, since some locations are genuinely good, but this one should not be anyone's first choice.
Had a cake delivered roadie the company they used took a picture of a cardboard box and said delivered and took my cake home. 80$ for a cake I never received
Very disappointed with the German Chocolate Cake. May try another flavor or stick to traditional next time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
My parents stop in from daytona because my brother gf told them how great the cupcakes are. However, they are dry. The icing is hard. Please take this criticism and go back to the drawing board. Even the german cake is not that good. Overall the food was really bad.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Whenever I have a cake cravings, I go to the best place that sells the best White Chocolate Cake and that’s here at Piece of Cake. We usually go to a different outlet but this was our first time here and we felt so welcomed because of how friendly this lovely lady behind the counter was hence we got 3 slices this time around; White chocolate, Birthday slice & Strawberry. Love all of it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Slice, White Chocolate No Nuts Slice
Best cupcakes I've ever had
I’ve been going to piece of cake for years. In the past it was such a treat because they were always delicious.But the Dunwoody store is just not good.Their slices are dry and seem old. I have a hard time believing they are fresh baked daily for this location. Every once in a while, I will get a moist slice, but not often enough to go back, unfortunately.Might try Buckhead location again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
I love the Mt Vernon location. This is my 2nd visit here and I have been pleased every time. I usually go to the location near Decatur. Theresa at the Mt Vernon location makes me feel so welcomed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brought vanilla/chocolate icing and a carrot cake(my ? favorite)..wasn't as moist or tasty as usual ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Loading...