Best NY style slice pizza in ATL! No one can tell me otherwise!!! So good down to the crispness of the dough to the sauce, the cheese and pepperoni!! Every time Im in Ponce I get s slice. Their sandwiches are just as good too, we've had the Buffalo chicken sandwich and it was perfect!
Jay D.
We got lucky and were able to snag (over a small period of time) all the bar seats and got 2 pizzas and the breadsticks to share. I thought the pizza was good! I love the thin crust and large slices, and both of the ones that we ordered (pepperoni and a prosciutto one) were well made. I wasn't a huge fan of the breadsticks and didn't like the drink I got.. I think it was the Italian margarita but I'm not totally sure. I think next time I'll just order a different drink though because I did really enjoy the pizza. Also the staff were really friendly and it's such a cute vibe!
Chris A.
I ordered a cheese slice, was told they would have it right out. They talked and laughed for 20 or so Seconds, grabbed a cheese slice out of the case, said here is a hot slice for you, and walked away. It was cold, hard, chewy and not worth the time let alone the money it cost me! May have been good if the employees there had cared but they were busy talking and waiting to leave. This all took place Tuesday the 5th of March around 7:30 to 8:00.
Leslie T.
I really wanted to love this place as it's perfect spot for a pizza joint in Ponce but sadly it's just not good at all. I ordered the pepperoni slice and it tasted super off. Like sauce had no flavor, cheese lacked flavor and cheesiness you'd expect and it was pretty pricey. Also ordered the breadsticks...pretty disappointed and actually a little mislead by the word breadsticks since it was thinly sliced French bread soaked in olive oil (I presume) and doused in what I could also assume are salt flakes. It was extremely salted bread and if not for the marina, and super hunger pains I wouldn't have been able to ingest it. Super bummed I have nothing great to say about this superbly located restaurant.
Adam H.
I got the mall slice pizza. It is delicious! My favorite pizza. It think it is worth the drive. The store has a nice atmosphere and the music is really cool. I highly recommend and will be back
Monique' M.
Maybe I just had a bad pizza, because most reviews seem to rave about this place. I had a single slice of the margherita pizza. The crust was over-baked and too burnt in many areas to eat. Additionally, the crust was super tough were it wasn't burnt. The cheese was stagnant, it didn't stretch and the pizza was overall lacking in flavor. I am not a fan and would not return.
Kent K.
The 'mall pie' is as good as it gets in Atlanta........or NYC.....or even close to New Haven CT. Not sure what is going on in this little nook tucked into the incredibly cool Ponce City market but trust me, I'll be back again and again and again. Pizza Jeans has a very weird name but their crust is the perfect balance of crunch and chew. The sauce is spot on and the team working there is everything you'd want in a pizza temple. It's 6:30 AM as I write this and I'm about to go grab one of the two slices I have left in the box.
Scott N.
Super fun place. Great loud music, full bar, just a fun vibe. Slices looked amazing. Ordered a margarita pizza to go and it was good. Not my favorite pizza ever, but solid with a lighter airy crust. Definitely a place to check out at Ponce City Market!
S Hwang
My friends and I were really excited to try the pizza here, but it was a letdown. The dough was tough to the point where it was hurting to chew. Maybe the pizza had been out for a while or was overcooked because the cheese was also hard. It would’ve been nice if they had reheated it for a little. Also, the margherita pizza was missing basil. Maybe we just came on a bad day :/
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Adam Nelson
Great service, but I didn’t think the pizza was anything special. We ordered slices that were sitting under a heating lamp, they would’ve been much better fresh out of the oven I’m sure.
Absolutely loved Pizza Jeans! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ The pepperoni oyster mushroom pizza with Elijay Mushrooms was amazing, and the service was top-notch. A must-try for pizza enthusiasts! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony Calkins
A top notch pizza experience all around. The sourdough pizza was crisp and loaded with flavors. The sauce was zesty and I love the cup style pepperonis. The margarita pizza add roasted garlic and pepperoni is a 10/10 for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Brittni Pitts
The staff was rude the and pizza was too greasy. Will NOT be returning. Felinis up the street is MUCH better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Austin L.
Absolutely loved Pizza Jeans! The pepperoni oyster mushroom pizza with the Elijay Mushrooms was amazing, and the service was top-notch. A must-try for pizza enthusiasts!
Amani Hussain
I work at a retail store in pcm and i love coming here on my lunch break! The staff is always so cool and friendly and make sure to say hi to me everytime I stop by and have made efforts to learn my name. The pizza is great, quick and cheap(for the area).
Best NY style slice pizza in ATL! No one can tell me otherwise!!! So good down to the crispness of the dough to the sauce, the cheese and pepperoni!! Every time Im in Ponce I get s slice. Their sandwiches are just as good too, we've had the Buffalo chicken sandwich and it was perfect!
We got lucky and were able to snag (over a small period of time) all the bar seats and got 2 pizzas and the breadsticks to share. I thought the pizza was good! I love the thin crust and large slices, and both of the ones that we ordered (pepperoni and a prosciutto one) were well made. I wasn't a huge fan of the breadsticks and didn't like the drink I got.. I think it was the Italian margarita but I'm not totally sure. I think next time I'll just order a different drink though because I did really enjoy the pizza. Also the staff were really friendly and it's such a cute vibe!
I ordered a cheese slice, was told they would have it right out. They talked and laughed for 20 or so Seconds, grabbed a cheese slice out of the case, said here is a hot slice for you, and walked away. It was cold, hard, chewy and not worth the time let alone the money it cost me! May have been good if the employees there had cared but they were busy talking and waiting to leave. This all took place Tuesday the 5th of March around 7:30 to 8:00.
I really wanted to love this place as it's perfect spot for a pizza joint in Ponce but sadly it's just not good at all. I ordered the pepperoni slice and it tasted super off. Like sauce had no flavor, cheese lacked flavor and cheesiness you'd expect and it was pretty pricey. Also ordered the breadsticks...pretty disappointed and actually a little mislead by the word breadsticks since it was thinly sliced French bread soaked in olive oil (I presume) and doused in what I could also assume are salt flakes. It was extremely salted bread and if not for the marina, and super hunger pains I wouldn't have been able to ingest it. Super bummed I have nothing great to say about this superbly located restaurant.
I got the mall slice pizza. It is delicious! My favorite pizza. It think it is worth the drive. The store has a nice atmosphere and the music is really cool. I highly recommend and will be back
Maybe I just had a bad pizza, because most reviews seem to rave about this place. I had a single slice of the margherita pizza. The crust was over-baked and too burnt in many areas to eat. Additionally, the crust was super tough were it wasn't burnt. The cheese was stagnant, it didn't stretch and the pizza was overall lacking in flavor. I am not a fan and would not return.
The 'mall pie' is as good as it gets in Atlanta........or NYC.....or even close to New Haven CT. Not sure what is going on in this little nook tucked into the incredibly cool Ponce City market but trust me, I'll be back again and again and again. Pizza Jeans has a very weird name but their crust is the perfect balance of crunch and chew. The sauce is spot on and the team working there is everything you'd want in a pizza temple. It's 6:30 AM as I write this and I'm about to go grab one of the two slices I have left in the box.
Super fun place. Great loud music, full bar, just a fun vibe. Slices looked amazing. Ordered a margarita pizza to go and it was good. Not my favorite pizza ever, but solid with a lighter airy crust. Definitely a place to check out at Ponce City Market!
My friends and I were really excited to try the pizza here, but it was a letdown. The dough was tough to the point where it was hurting to chew. Maybe the pizza had been out for a while or was overcooked because the cheese was also hard. It would’ve been nice if they had reheated it for a little. Also, the margherita pizza was missing basil. Maybe we just came on a bad day :/
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Great service, but I didn’t think the pizza was anything special. We ordered slices that were sitting under a heating lamp, they would’ve been much better fresh out of the oven I’m sure.
Food: 3
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely loved Pizza Jeans! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ The pepperoni oyster mushroom pizza with Elijay Mushrooms was amazing, and the service was top-notch. A must-try for pizza enthusiasts! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A top notch pizza experience all around. The sourdough pizza was crisp and loaded with flavors. The sauce was zesty and I love the cup style pepperonis. The margarita pizza add roasted garlic and pepperoni is a 10/10 for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
The staff was rude the and pizza was too greasy. Will NOT be returning. Felinis up the street is MUCH better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Absolutely loved Pizza Jeans! The pepperoni oyster mushroom pizza with the Elijay Mushrooms was amazing, and the service was top-notch. A must-try for pizza enthusiasts!
I work at a retail store in pcm and i love coming here on my lunch break! The staff is always so cool and friendly and make sure to say hi to me everytime I stop by and have made efforts to learn my name. The pizza is great, quick and cheap(for the area).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza