When we arrived, my child needed to use the restroom. A staff member followed my child into the restroom with gloves on, and then exited still wearing the same gloves. This is extremely unhygienic and raised serious concerns for us. I spoke with the manager about this, expecting a basic acknowledgment of the health issue. Instead, the manager was dismissive and didn't seem to think it was a problem. Given the lack of care from both the employee and management, we decided to leave. Sanitation and customer respect should be taken seriously — unfortunately, neither were present during our visit.
Zac
Not all food items came out that were ordered. Drinks from the bar took almost the entire meal time before they arrived. Salads arrived at the same time as entrees.
Ken
Frequent this restaurant when I'm in Atlanta . Always great food good service and a wonderful place to enjoy your evening 
Dick
Lovely setting with lively Italian music. Great service and food. Every bite delicious. Sea salt caramel cheesecake was out of this world
Mark
Place got good reviews and thought we would give it a try this time in Atlanta. We were just not impressed. Service was weird and they seemed unprepared. Quality of food was disappointing. My pasta was WAY overcooked and basically just mush, my coworkers pizza was soggy and the desserts were subpar. It's one to mark off the list here.
Erin
Absolutely amazing food and atmosphere. Better yet was the service. Aysia who served our party two consecutive nights was remarkable. Would definitely recommend! Get the limoncello!!
Loretta
Delicious food, friendly staff, and fun ambience all came together for a enjoyable dinner experience.
David
Amalfi was a last-minute dinner decision after spending the day visiting Atlanta, and it was fantastic. From drinks and appetizers to our meal to dessert, everything was delicious and thoughtful. Thank you for a wonderful night.
Amanda Clemens
Pasta dish was flavorful but pasta was mushy. Bread basket was not what you expect; unfortunately this restaurant did not match with the online rating. I guess I ordered the wrong dish.
Dylan
We had a great experience and our server Abbie was great! She had great recommendations and great energy. A few complaints, which for the sake of the business won't affect the stars in this review, but should be considered by the management/owners... first, the host seemed flustered and unprepared, even though the tables were around 35% full. She seated us and spilled water on the table which splashed my date who instantly asked for a napkin to clean herself up. After a few minutes, we decided to look around and she was setting tables, with nobody in queue to be seated. So I decided to get up and take napkins from empty tables to get it done myself even while I'm doing this she walks by, sees what I'm doing, and says nothing. Totally inept. Also, the Spotify bill needs to be be paid because hearing commercials in the middle of a meal is absolutely ridiculous. Otherwise, we loved it here. If we come back it'll be to see Abbie again!
We were seated quickly upon arriving for our reservation. Our waiter, Wyatt was attentive and pleasurable the entire time. Overall the experience was good. The only thing we had an issue with was the temperature of the food. It was rather lukewarm. And I get that to expect piping hot food is a lot, and the chicken on one person's meal was hot because of the melted cheese. Aside from that, not too tempting. We were all hungry and needed sustenance. Perhaps if in the area again on a weeknight for dinner the food will be hot.
Kim Luna
Absolutely Outstanding – A Must-Visit!
From the moment I walked in, I felt genuinely welcomed by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was incredibly attentive and kind—by the end of the first night, it felt like I was dining with family.
The food was absolutely delicious every single time, and the custom drinks were a creative and flavorful bonus. With dozens of dining options within a mile of my hotel, the fact that I chose to return here 4 out of the 5 nights I was in town says everything you need to know.
There was never any pressure to rush through a meal—the team made sure every experience was relaxed and enjoyable. Fabulous customer service, top-notch hospitality, and unforgettable meals. I can’t wait to come back next time I’m in town!
Heath
The food was fantastic but they brought out 2 entrees and it took another 20 minutes to bring the other 2 entries. The 2 of us were done dining by the time we received the rest of our order. No manager table visit and lack of communication about the delay. Upon asking to speak with the manager Seth gave mouth service and blamed his staff for the issue.
Lee
Had a great experience! Loved the entrance as it resembles being in Italy. My date loved sitting in the booth as we were able to sit next to each other, not too many of those anymore. The food was well priced, hearty/delicious, and a great sized portion. Drinks were good. Our waiter referred us to the downstairs bar (sshhhh) where we continued the evening with more cocktails!
Matthew
Food was great overall, especially the entrees. Charcuterie board felt more like many blocks of cheese with a couple slices of meat. The bread with it was great though. The chicken Parmesan was incredible, highly recommend. Love the wine selection. Our server was fantastic, present when needed but did not hover at all.
When we arrived, my child needed to use the restroom. A staff member followed my child into the restroom with gloves on, and then exited still wearing the same gloves. This is extremely unhygienic and raised serious concerns for us. I spoke with the manager about this, expecting a basic acknowledgment of the health issue. Instead, the manager was dismissive and didn't seem to think it was a problem. Given the lack of care from both the employee and management, we decided to leave. Sanitation and customer respect should be taken seriously — unfortunately, neither were present during our visit.
Not all food items came out that were ordered. Drinks from the bar took almost the entire meal time before they arrived. Salads arrived at the same time as entrees.
Frequent this restaurant when I'm in Atlanta . Always great food good service and a wonderful place to enjoy your evening 
Lovely setting with lively Italian music. Great service and food. Every bite delicious. Sea salt caramel cheesecake was out of this world
Place got good reviews and thought we would give it a try this time in Atlanta. We were just not impressed. Service was weird and they seemed unprepared. Quality of food was disappointing. My pasta was WAY overcooked and basically just mush, my coworkers pizza was soggy and the desserts were subpar. It's one to mark off the list here.
Absolutely amazing food and atmosphere. Better yet was the service. Aysia who served our party two consecutive nights was remarkable. Would definitely recommend! Get the limoncello!!
Delicious food, friendly staff, and fun ambience all came together for a enjoyable dinner experience.
Amalfi was a last-minute dinner decision after spending the day visiting Atlanta, and it was fantastic. From drinks and appetizers to our meal to dessert, everything was delicious and thoughtful. Thank you for a wonderful night.
Pasta dish was flavorful but pasta was mushy. Bread basket was not what you expect; unfortunately this restaurant did not match with the online rating. I guess I ordered the wrong dish.
We had a great experience and our server Abbie was great! She had great recommendations and great energy. A few complaints, which for the sake of the business won't affect the stars in this review, but should be considered by the management/owners... first, the host seemed flustered and unprepared, even though the tables were around 35% full. She seated us and spilled water on the table which splashed my date who instantly asked for a napkin to clean herself up. After a few minutes, we decided to look around and she was setting tables, with nobody in queue to be seated. So I decided to get up and take napkins from empty tables to get it done myself even while I'm doing this she walks by, sees what I'm doing, and says nothing. Totally inept. Also, the Spotify bill needs to be be paid because hearing commercials in the middle of a meal is absolutely ridiculous. Otherwise, we loved it here. If we come back it'll be to see Abbie again!
Restaurantji Recommends
We were seated quickly upon arriving for our reservation. Our waiter, Wyatt was attentive and pleasurable the entire time. Overall the experience was good. The only thing we had an issue with was the temperature of the food. It was rather lukewarm. And I get that to expect piping hot food is a lot, and the chicken on one person's meal was hot because of the melted cheese. Aside from that, not too tempting. We were all hungry and needed sustenance. Perhaps if in the area again on a weeknight for dinner the food will be hot.
Absolutely Outstanding – A Must-Visit! From the moment I walked in, I felt genuinely welcomed by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was incredibly attentive and kind—by the end of the first night, it felt like I was dining with family. The food was absolutely delicious every single time, and the custom drinks were a creative and flavorful bonus. With dozens of dining options within a mile of my hotel, the fact that I chose to return here 4 out of the 5 nights I was in town says everything you need to know. There was never any pressure to rush through a meal—the team made sure every experience was relaxed and enjoyable. Fabulous customer service, top-notch hospitality, and unforgettable meals. I can’t wait to come back next time I’m in town!
The food was fantastic but they brought out 2 entrees and it took another 20 minutes to bring the other 2 entries. The 2 of us were done dining by the time we received the rest of our order. No manager table visit and lack of communication about the delay. Upon asking to speak with the manager Seth gave mouth service and blamed his staff for the issue.
Had a great experience! Loved the entrance as it resembles being in Italy. My date loved sitting in the booth as we were able to sit next to each other, not too many of those anymore. The food was well priced, hearty/delicious, and a great sized portion. Drinks were good. Our waiter referred us to the downstairs bar (sshhhh) where we continued the evening with more cocktails!
Food was great overall, especially the entrees. Charcuterie board felt more like many blocks of cheese with a couple slices of meat. The bread with it was great though. The chicken Parmesan was incredible, highly recommend. Love the wine selection. Our server was fantastic, present when needed but did not hover at all.
Loading...