Smith's Olde Bar

1578 Piedmont Ave NE, Atlanta
(404) 875-1522

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gabi

Went out with friends and wanted to go into the club-like room at the bar. We had two girls in our friend group that got stamps on their hands to go in without paying (note: they did not have guys with them when they were let in). The rest of our friend group (including guys and girls) went to go in and the short white guy with the pornstache said we had to pay 15 each. When we called him out for only letting girls in for free that don’t have guys around them, his tone got super aggressive. He also called us something super rude under his breath when we walked past him. Don’t get me wrong, I’m all here for girls getting in for free but be consistent. I’m also fine with paying but again, be consistent. And don’t act like you don’t know what you’re doing when people confront you about it. Not a good look for the business at all. I’ve had a good time at this bar before but this has ruined my experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Phil

Walked in, no sign or instruction on what to do to be seated (or to seat yourself), multiple workers looked at us but did not acknowledge us, so we finally sat ourselves, only to have multiple workers walk past us with zero acknowledgment. So we stood up and left! Will not be returning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lenicia Brentley Wilson

Nice vibe and great place to watch football PARTICULARLY steelers games. The new red booths are pretty nice. The chicken is pretty good. Fried wings, Tenders, grilled chicken great. Sides meh. Servers were great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Cheeseburger

Sabrina W

Derrick is phenomenal! He made it happen for me with a liquor i wanted without recipe

Keith Downs

Waitress and manager both committed credit card fraud. I was told I couldn’t run a tab so I paid by card when ordering tip was included when I placed my order. I paid for a round of drinks that my party didn’t receive. When I asked the waitress where my order was she claimed I had paid for drinks that were previously provided even though I was not running a tab and no receipt was given. I explained the situation and told the waitresses and manager when you close out a tab a receipt and signed copy are always provided before charges to a customer’s card are issued. I politely told the waitress I would take it up with my bank. As I was heading to the exit I was grabbed by the back of my neck and shoved to the door by whom I assumed were bouncers. I was never asked to leave and was in the process of leaving when I was grabbed from behind. I was never at any point aggressive or caused a disturbance in any way. I will filing legal action

Service: 1

Oli Johnson

Prices were a little high (8$ for a sam Adam's octoberfest on draft, but the crowd was vibey

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Shawn Pasley

I love this place! A legend in the Atlanta music scene! There's always a show from the newest up and comers to the bands you already know! Pool room, bar and dining room and two live music rooms!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andres Berrio

Great spot

Atmosphere: 5

Nick Barnes

Awesome music venue upstairs and bar staff is quick and knowledgeable

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Hollie Isbell

I came to smiths 2 night ago and the long haired bartender was so sweet and welcoming! If you see her you’ll definitely come back! She was amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Carter Speidel

Great classic bar when it comes to vibes and music, but the bartenders are the worst in the entire city. Rude, not very fast or good at making drinks, and it’s Smiths….lets be honest with yourselves.

Don’t expect warm service and don’t feel bad leaving a small tip. Everyone I know feels the same

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Ian Gaenssley

Always an experience here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alan Estis

Unique cool pub and bar. Didn't try the food but amazing posters everywhere and cool atmosphere would highly recommend this place for a good time.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

CJ Brown

Cool dive bar good music venue.

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 3

Justin Brown

Took my friends ID and said it was fake and would not give it back so had to have the cops come out!!! He’s 22

Loading...