Southern Baked Pie Company | Mail Order and Georgia Pie Shops
4300 Paces Ferry Rd SE #113, Atlanta
(404) 301-4854
Recent Reviews
Sort by
I served the chicken pot pie to my Canasta Card playing friends. It was excellent! The only negative was not allowing it to cool for 5 minutes before serving. After it set, it cut nicely.
I told the clerks who were very friendly that I was heading back to work in Douglasville, Ga and if the cherry pie and apple pie was good I would turn around and come back to by some more pie. They were delicious but the traffic was horrible so I didn’t turnaround but I will be back.
I bought a pie that was so tart that it gave you an immediate stomach ache. It was a blackberry pie. It was end of season probably but the crust was good, but it doesn’t matter cause you can eat the filling. I sent an email twice or an email on a message not sure but I did it twice and I get no response. I would not recommend this company so they’re 90% will have to drop lower
Tomato pie was delicious, but the flaky crust laid very heavy in my stomach. Lard?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great pie! Brought some apple pie and pecan pie back to my fam in New York. Everyone loved it
Loved the buttermilk mini pie. Tasty and not too sweet. Ate it as two servings.
The chicken pot pies tasted great but 40.00 per pie when they barely fed 3-4 people is crazy.
Incredible pies and customer service!
The employees were so so kind and the pies are delicious, 10/10
Individual chicken pot pies, very dry. If there had more filling and not so dry on the inside the crust would have been ok.
Restaurantji Recommends
We’ve tried several flavors of pies. All delicious! But the Salted Caramel Dutch Apple is our favorite. Packaged so well and ships fast. You won’t be disappointed with any of them.
The regular-size cherry pie looks beautiful, but the pastry is very thick—see below. It looks like the lower pastry had a single swipe of cherry filling. This could have been more aptly named, “a crust with some cherry .”
After cooking the pot roast pie for an extra 30 minutes beyond the recommended time, the bottom crust was still doughy and undercooked. I'm just glad it was a gift and not something I paid $45 plus shipping for, as it was one of the worst pies I've ever had.
Just discovered this gem and WOW! I brought a coconut pie for a party and it was a hit. I also purchased a vegetable pot pie and it was amazing. I will definitely be a repeat customer.
Pie was way overrated for price. Crust was good but over all the pot pie was dry. Threw half of it away. Arrived two days after desired day. Company didn’t really seem to care.
Loading...