Nancy's Pizzeria
$ • Pizza, Italian
Hours:
5295 Whittlesey Blvd, Columbus
(762) 524-7525
About Nancy's Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
Nancy's Pizzeria Reviews
Share your opinion about Nancy's Pizzeria
We drove 3hrs just to have “real” pizza! Relocating from Bflo, NY to Alabama we haven’t had real pizza! Although i love my NY style, this Chicago stuffed was amazing! The Buffalo wings were just as good! A new travel destination for the summer!!
We drove 3hrs just to have “real” pizza! Relocating from Bflo, NY to Alabama we haven’t had real pizza! Although i love my NY style, this Chicago stuffed was amazing! The Buffalo wings were just as good! A new travel destination for the summer!!
Fantastic pizza and great service!!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 2 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 1 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 1 - 8PM |
People in Columbus Also Viewed
Nancy's Pizzeria is known for its delicious pizza, with the Chicago deep dish being a standout. The restaurant has ample parking and is ADA compliant, but currently offers limited seating. Despite this, customers have praised the helpful service and plan to return when a sitting area becomes available. The pizzeria has also attracted visitors from out of state, who have enjoyed the authentic pizza and buffalo wings. Recent visitors have expressed love for the pizza, calling it real pizza made from the heart, and appreciated the friendly service. Many have praised the takeout service, noting their orders are always ready on time. Fans of deep dish pizza consider it a life-saver and look forward to a dine-in option being available soon. Overall, Nancy's Pizzeria remains a favorite for its authentic, flavorful pizza and welcoming atmosphere. Customers have shared that the service was amazing and the food still meets the high standards from years ago. The quality has returned to what it once was, making the experience special again. The pizza is fantastic with quality ingredients, and the beef sandwiches remind many of Chicago, especially when dipped in extra au jus. Though prices are a bit high, the ingredients make a noticeable difference in taste. The restaurant also offers some pretty good sides, adding to the overall experience.