Johnny's New York Style Pizza

2445 Salem Rd SE Suite R, Conyers
(770) 922-1000

Recent Reviews

Kristine Henderson

Pizza is always made fresh. Homemade sauce and dough. Magnific, mmmmm. And the wings are the best around. You can’t go wrong. You can’t go wrong with this place. Try ‘em love em you will definitely keep coming back.Parking: Plenty of parking. Well lit if eating after dark

B Lorenzo

I'm very upset with the pizza I received while entertaining my guest. I received burned pizza. This was embarrassing because we had people out of town from NYC. The photo says it

V P

By far the BESTEST Pizza and wings ever! This is our 3rd time here and the food is delicious, fresh and you will not be disappointed! The owners are wonderful and hard working as well as their employees. They have football games going on and they sell beer. We will definitely keep coming here and supporting this business.

Monica Buitureida

I’ve been going to this place for years and today it was disappointments. I ordered four items 1 lg pizza a cheese calzone 20 wings and a basket of fries I got there and was charged $72 practically for four items I didn’t have a problem with the price until I got there and realize that my order was not complete. they forgot to put the order of fries. I clearly said a basket of fries. she argued with my husband about how it was not ordered. I know I had ordered it over the phone. she did not repeat the order and neither did I think to have her repeat the order since this has never happened to me before. When I called the first time to see what was the estimate time of food for a pick up and she stated it would be 15 minutes so I called later since I had a 1 Hour Drive. she stated the order would take no more than 20 minutes after placing the order. Either way my husband got stuck waiting for a longer period of time due to waitin for the fries. They did not provide him with it itemized receipt instead he had to ask for the receipt with the printed items. This place is so unprofessional when it comes to some employees working there. when the main owner is there is there’s never been an issue. only when he’s not there it’s always seems to be an issue.The employee name says it all on the receipt Da Boss 337 receipt has been posted under photos

Michelle G.

Great customer service! Food was delicious and fresh! I ordered the Cajun pasta with chicken, it was so flavorful! The owner, a very nice and polite gentleman made sure we were taken care of and had everything we needed!

Patrick SENDWE

This location definitely knows how to make it the right way! I have been to many Johnny’s but this location is wonderful. The lemon pepper wings extra crispy, just the way I like them.

Rusty R.

Pizza was overpriced didn't have valid menu had to use phone code to get order and then my brother added a desert that he didn't have enough for and she tried to force him to pay for it before we even received it. This place is a joke

Ann Walker Johnson

We ordered a large pizza and wings. The wings were tiny and dry with little meat on the bone. The pizza crust was salty. Very expensive for such poor quality. Recommend going to the Covington location.

Angel Lovely Stephens

Went in with my family and there was only one person working. He just stood behind the counter and stared at us for a minute so we just seated ourselves. He never said welcome in, hello, or anything. Once we were seated he came over and very nonchalantly said the menu is on the napkin container just scan the code. He then impatiently waited for our drink orders. My daughters drink had something in it when he brought it back and he got a whole attitude when she pointed that out to him and mumbled something under his breath. Moving on to ordering our food. Once again he impatiently waited for us to all order even after I said we are still looking at the menu. We ordered 1 large pizza, cheese sticks, fries, wings, a ceaser wrap, and a Flatbread pizza. Our total was $100 but our bill came up to $135. He added a $20 tip for himself knowing he was very rude and unprofessional with us and some how the taxes were $15. I gave them two stars because the pizza, cheese sticks and fries were good. The wings were supposed to be lemon pepper but had no seasoning at all and the ceaser wrap tasted like old cardboard. We also had to ask multiple times for refills on our drinks.

Kathleen K.

When ever I need a salad fix, the Mediterranean salad does the trick. The pizza and calzones are our go to favs !!

Amber Nichole

Awesome pizza & friendly service. ! Me and my daughter enjoyed everything about it. See you guys again ?

Shys2018

I had a bad review at first. After speaking with Sam I realized I ordered the kinda pizza for what I was looking for on my thin crust pizza. He explained it to me and I understood the process a lot better. And said he valued my patronage. And told me to mention me next time I come in. So with that being said I will be back because I've always like their pizza before. Thanks for paying attention to your customers!

Stephen White

very good dinner/ loved the fried ravioli too

Glen & Marion Barr

Thank You! The entire staff at the Conyers location was AMAZING! We came into the location near closing and the staff still greeted us in a welcoming fashion. We are from Michigan and the Great white pizza and the garlic knots were some of the best we’ve ever had! Thank you Sam and the entire staff! Blessings.

Kametrise Holt

This is the best pizza restaurant in Conyers, hands down. Not only are their pizzas delicious but their hot wings are as well! If you are looking for a friendly place that has a really cool laid back vibe, please visit here! Also please ask for Tionna! She was so awesome. She took care of me and my family as if we were the only customers she had. She even turned on a movie for kids to watch. She truly went above and beyond for us!

Load More