I've been in several times. They are so nice, and their bakery items are ALWAYS delicious and reasonably priced.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Carrot Cake, Butter Croissant
Zaqri C.
My 5 year old: "Best cupcake ever!" This place is a gem. Island forward pastries with the classics as well. Super kid friendly service and ambiance, with many treats for grown ups only which I appreciated. Will be back for sure. Carrot cake next time, but Vienna cake was just so good.
Kerry-Ann McLean
Not impressed. Neither I nor my kid wanted to finish our cupcakes. Not tasty.
C W
My dad's favorite cake was carrot cake. I have never been a fan of it. I originally tried theirs solely for nostalgic purposes, when I moved to the area. However, now their carrot cake cupcakes are my guilty pleasure. I try to order 2 once a week and they are both in my belly before I make it back home. I could literally eat the frosting in a bowl with a spoon. They are quite popular because they are sometimes out of them by the time I get there, which makes me sad. It also helps that the owner and staff are always genuinely pleasant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Carrot Cake
Cynthia Bassett
My daughter ordered her 20th birthday cake from this establishment and it was the most professional experience. The cake was beautifully customized per my daughter’s request. The cake was amazing it fed the entire party and the guest all spoke about how good the cake was. It was not sweet and overbearing. It was just the right Amount of everything! Thank you Sugar Mill Bakery you have a customer for life! It was worth the price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Aniya Bassett
Thank you so very much you made my birthday great!!!!!! The cake was sooooo good and soo big it fed my entire party of 18 with left overs! I cannot thank you all enough. The baker, the cashier, and the sweet lady that took my order and made sure everything was done exactly how I wanted. I even called in two days prior to when my cake was supposed to be ready to modify my order and they made that so easy. I will be coming back for future birthdays and events, this place is affordable and did everything last thing I asked them to. No complaints what so ever. Thank you to the moon The SugarMill!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chandra
The key lime cupcakes are delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rhonda M
First time visiting. It's a little gem, Been passing this place for a while. There was so much to choose from I had to get several items. The oreo cheese cake was ok. It had a sour smell, so it was hard to enjoy. The pound cake was and cinnamon bun was very good! The cake was a little dry, but the icing made up for it. It was good, though. I would definitely visit again and try other things.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caramel Cinnamon Rolls
Watisha Farrington
I wanted to support a fellow Virgin Islander. I was not disappointed! The staff was very friendly and inviting. My red velvet cupcake was AMAZING! I didn't eat it until almost 3 days after I bought it, and it was still moist & fluffy. My cousin got a chocolate chip cookie, and she LOVED it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Taliyah Johnson
There cakes are pretty good service is great and the owners are friendly! Definitely recommend the lemon blueberry cake it’s so good!
Ohh so good !! So moist !! I ordered the red velvet and cookies and cream. I will definitely be back .
Melanie Kramber
Photos do not do these justice. These rolls are larger than my hand and give you that wow factor when opening the box. These are made fresh and were so soft. Please support this family business. From their cakes, to pastries, to cupcakes, they never disappoint and their customer service is top notch!
Ericka-Denise N.
Had a sweet tooth the other day, so I decided to try to bakery out since I was in the area. I asked if they had caramel cake (my favorite), but they didn't, so I chose the caramel cinnamon roll instead! It was very tasty! Very flaky and moist at the same time! The icing was great! My husband got the red velvet cake. I tried a piece of it, ....ok., not a big fan of red velvet though. I will be back again to try their other delicious looking goodies!
Ashley L
I've been ordering cakes from them for about six years now. Their cakes are ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. I have never been disappointed and as long as they're in business I will ALWAYS order from them.
Joel Gilbert
If you're looking for some delectable pastries, desserts, cakes, cupcakes, or anything to satisfy your sweet tooth, this is definitely the place to achieve that. The staff is very welcoming and pleasant.
I've been in several times. They are so nice, and their bakery items are ALWAYS delicious and reasonably priced.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Carrot Cake, Butter Croissant
My 5 year old: "Best cupcake ever!" This place is a gem. Island forward pastries with the classics as well. Super kid friendly service and ambiance, with many treats for grown ups only which I appreciated. Will be back for sure. Carrot cake next time, but Vienna cake was just so good.
Not impressed. Neither I nor my kid wanted to finish our cupcakes. Not tasty.
My dad's favorite cake was carrot cake. I have never been a fan of it. I originally tried theirs solely for nostalgic purposes, when I moved to the area. However, now their carrot cake cupcakes are my guilty pleasure. I try to order 2 once a week and they are both in my belly before I make it back home. I could literally eat the frosting in a bowl with a spoon. They are quite popular because they are sometimes out of them by the time I get there, which makes me sad. It also helps that the owner and staff are always genuinely pleasant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Carrot Cake
My daughter ordered her 20th birthday cake from this establishment and it was the most professional experience. The cake was beautifully customized per my daughter’s request. The cake was amazing it fed the entire party and the guest all spoke about how good the cake was. It was not sweet and overbearing. It was just the right Amount of everything! Thank you Sugar Mill Bakery you have a customer for life! It was worth the price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Thank you so very much you made my birthday great!!!!!! The cake was sooooo good and soo big it fed my entire party of 18 with left overs! I cannot thank you all enough. The baker, the cashier, and the sweet lady that took my order and made sure everything was done exactly how I wanted. I even called in two days prior to when my cake was supposed to be ready to modify my order and they made that so easy. I will be coming back for future birthdays and events, this place is affordable and did everything last thing I asked them to. No complaints what so ever. Thank you to the moon The SugarMill!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The key lime cupcakes are delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time visiting. It's a little gem, Been passing this place for a while. There was so much to choose from I had to get several items. The oreo cheese cake was ok. It had a sour smell, so it was hard to enjoy. The pound cake was and cinnamon bun was very good! The cake was a little dry, but the icing made up for it. It was good, though. I would definitely visit again and try other things.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caramel Cinnamon Rolls
I wanted to support a fellow Virgin Islander. I was not disappointed! The staff was very friendly and inviting. My red velvet cupcake was AMAZING! I didn't eat it until almost 3 days after I bought it, and it was still moist & fluffy. My cousin got a chocolate chip cookie, and she LOVED it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
There cakes are pretty good service is great and the owners are friendly! Definitely recommend the lemon blueberry cake it’s so good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Restaurantji Recommends
Ohh so good !! So moist !! I ordered the red velvet and cookies and cream. I will definitely be back .
Photos do not do these justice. These rolls are larger than my hand and give you that wow factor when opening the box. These are made fresh and were so soft. Please support this family business. From their cakes, to pastries, to cupcakes, they never disappoint and their customer service is top notch!
Had a sweet tooth the other day, so I decided to try to bakery out since I was in the area. I asked if they had caramel cake (my favorite), but they didn't, so I chose the caramel cinnamon roll instead! It was very tasty! Very flaky and moist at the same time! The icing was great! My husband got the red velvet cake. I tried a piece of it, ....ok., not a big fan of red velvet though. I will be back again to try their other delicious looking goodies!
I've been ordering cakes from them for about six years now. Their cakes are ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. I have never been disappointed and as long as they're in business I will ALWAYS order from them.
If you're looking for some delectable pastries, desserts, cakes, cupcakes, or anything to satisfy your sweet tooth, this is definitely the place to achieve that. The staff is very welcoming and pleasant.