I Love NY Pizza & Bar Dawsonville

helped me notarize a document and the food was pretty good 10/10

Amazing people and amazing food. I’m very happy me and my friend stopped by here!

Empty, Sad, & Unhygenic. We ordered the meat lovers, and it came with sparse toppings

It's hard to find decent pizza in the mountains and they do a great job. The service is great and so is the food. Enjoy!

Pizza is great. Everyone is working hard to get the place back in order.

The pizza is expensive and never cooked all the way. Got a large pepperoni pizza and it was $25 and it was not very good. The cheese wasn’t completely melted and it didn’t have much flavor at all.

Food was amazing to be honest, I loved the wings, fries and the cheese pizza, all the food was excellent

Horrible experience dealing with this place! They really need Bar Rescue or go somewhere else beside Dawsonville. The bar itself seems well taken care of by the single tender on duty Friday night.. Other than that, if you’re there for food, forget about it! The staff (of one) and the Manager (the dude that was fondling some device behind the bar and at some point several minutes into my visit at least made eye contact with me before…) ignoring you. 2-3 tables occupied in the 30 minutes I wasted there and I wasn’t even acknowledged (directly at least; plenty of talk among the 1 staff member and her whole 2 tables about me). This place is an absolute JOKE! Don’t hire anyone but the bar tender when they fail, soon enough.

Disappointed in their subs. Also was told take-out ready in 20-25 minutes; had to wait over 1 hour.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza

Tried many times and mostly very disappointed. Either under cooked or over cooked

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Undercooked pizza! Horrible!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

We picked up dinner last night, which was 2 pizzas, salad, and 2 orders of garlic knots. The pizza was dry and the orders of "garlic knots" ($8) ...consisted of two yeast rolls with a small cup of marinara. Not worth $80!

Food: 2

Service: 2

If I could leave 0 stars I would.
l asked for a slice I got a Tostitos heat up pizza with fake cheese
Then I look over to my left and another party has a real pizza with real cheese
Hmmm I wonder if it's because of my skin color nevertheless, it's pitiful that you would serve someone this
& the live music is absolute deafening to the ear is literal ear rape. 0/10 across the board
THEN the waitress said I gave you this because we didn't have slices so I just gave you KIDS cheese pizzas because it's cheaper, who said I needed something cheaper ? Ok strike 1.
Why would you not tell me slices aren't available and make a decision for me without telling me when I ordered 3 slices of pizza, Strike 2.
I'm just trying to figure out how any of this made sense but ALL I can say is maybe they were racist
I hope no one EVER eats here, terrible terrible TERRIBLE

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Placed an order for pickup at 6pm and showed up and waited well over an hour to pick it up. They claimed they were short staffed. Guess what? That excuse doesn’t really fly anymore. I don’t hear that mentioned at any place anymore 4 years removed from COVID. Chick-fil-a, Mellow Mushroom, <insert any other place here> they’ve figured the staffing thing out. We ordered 2 pizzas (Lasagna Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza) and 20 Lemon Pepper Wings. The food was absolutely terrible and disappointing. The wings had nothing on them. Just naked wings. The pizzas barely had any toppings and were under cooked. The worst part? All of that terrible food cost $87. I’ll never order from this place again. Save yourself the disappointment and go someplace (any place) else.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Placed an online order. 30 minutes later app said order was ready. Went to pick up order and waited over an hour to be told they hadn't even started making the order. Worst service!!!!!

Service: 1