Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Always tasty and great service. It's a pleasure to dine here!

We love this place! Great pizza and calzones. Always good beer on draft also!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Johnny’s Pizza is our go-to spot! My wife and I eat here often, and they always recognize us and remember our specific requests. The food is consistently spot-on, and the service is outstanding. Tonight, Libby had just gotten off for the night but still offered to prepare our food—talk about going above and beyond! We absolutely love this place and the people.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

worst store to pick up doordash‘s from all of the employees are extremely rude. If you forget a Dasher bag, they will refuse to give you the order which just causes chaos within the DoorDash app because there’s no way to cancel. You have to call Support, which takes up more time. I have picked up 100+ orders without a pizza bag and there was never an issue. EVEN AT OTHER JOHNNYS LOCATIONS. store needs to hire some new employees with a different attitude and mindset.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Stay away if you’re a delivery driver! I came by here to pick up an order and the employees refused to give me the food. Had to unassign the order and that’ll hurt your rates as a driver.

Service: 1

Placed a order by calling the restaurant because the online ordering didnt work for 2 pizzas and cheese bread. my husband went to pick up and still wasn't ready he waits for 35 more mins When he gets home with the pizza the dough isn't cooked on any of it the pizza was supposed to be double pepperoni and there was barely any pepperoni. we had to throw it all away 50.00 worth. I am very upset and would never recommend to anyone

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The pizza is amazing

Staying at the nearby Holiday Inn, and walked over to Johnny’s. The staff were really friendly and the chicken Parmesan was delicious. Cold draft beer hit the spot too. I highly recommend this place.

Went in to grab my doordash order and was told that they refuse to give it to me because I didn't have a doordash pizza bag, so I went out to my car to grab my pizza bag and went back inside and the manager said that I had been extremely rude and to get out before they call the cops.. wow great service someone should give you a golden star!!! ⭐⭐
I don't suggest eating here I would go to mod pizza before I would ever chose Johnny's New York style pizza. If they treat a door dasher like that imagine how they treat their customers? They need to get there customer service in check.

If quality of food is not that great for the price. 1 year ago when I ate here it was outstanding it now is no good.

Staff is always friendly, pizza is always done on time and it always tastes great and fresh.

The pizza I ordered through DoorDash was amazing! Just the right amount of sauce, cheese, spices, and toppings. And, the crust was cooked to perfection. So glad I chose Johnny’s for my pizza craving!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food is great

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

I ordered for delivery, after waiting nearly 2 hours I called. Met with immediate attitude the second the phone was answered. I told her I wanted to just cancel the order, she said she can't do that because she can't reach the driver. I've ordered here before, food was mediocre but thought I'd give them another shot. Never again, pizza from Brooklyn Joe's or Grandma's New York Pizza is far superior and their employees are prompt, professional, and kind.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1