Buttermilk Pie Company

302 Broad St SE, Gainesville
(678) 971-2555

Recent Reviews

Vicki Johnston

We loved the chicken pot pie and the spinach quiche! They were delicious and were so easy to prepare. It made for a fast family dinner. The crust is very good.

Matthew C.

Such a beautiful pie shop with great decor and atmosphere. The employee who helped us was very nice and informative. We enjoyed the pies we purchased. Highly recommend.

Tabitha Hall Cathey

The mini sweet pie four pack assortment that I received was super yummy and delicious. They came packaged well and timely. Can't wait to try the savory pies for a supper meal

Nettie Blount

Ordered the 4 sweet pie sampler. Not a fan of the crust. Way too salty and greasy on the bottom.

Hank Uzzell

The chicken ranchero pie is delicious! Also, they have great customer service!

Jennie-Owen Stapleton

The chicken pie is so good! The crust is delicious and flaky and the the chicken filling is wonderful!

Marcia Henry

Just tried your chicken pot pie that I received as a gift. Omg, was that so delicious. It made me weep a little, so good. Thank you for the great dish.

Dana Roberts

I ordered 3 pies. They came right to my door. Haven’t used them, but will for Thanksgiving!

Julie Doughty

We love the pies here and have been customers for years. We grabbed a Chicken Pot Pie today, because my father was visiting. He said it was the best Chicken Pot Pie he had ever had and since he is almost 80 years old, that’s a lot of pie. He is now trying to talk me into cancelling my Thanksgiving turkey and just having two of your Pot Pies for Thanksgiving Dinner!

Kate VM

Ordered the Chicken Ranchero Pie and it was inedible. Very soupy and had to be thrown out. When I reached out to there customer service with pictures asking for either a refund or a new pie NO ONE got back to me. Horrible customer service and will not be ordering from them again

Kc Emberson

Wonderful option to send as a care package. Delicious pies!

Kathleen Burgreen

Just received my supper pie pack and four mini dessert pack. I made the tomato pie first. Out of this world delicious. Savory filing, outstanding pie crust and special topping! So, so tasty. Can’t wait to try my other two supper pies, chicken pot pie and Southwestern taco pie. Oh and try my dessert pies. Yum yum! All received in great shape in the packing

Maritza P.

Love this place! The pies are incredible - such a simple and delicious choice for a group get together, dinner with family or as a meal for a new mother. We picked up a few recently on the way to Hilton Head and had an easy dinner for the first night when all the restaurants were packed. The tomato pie has been a big hit but they have loved the Southwest and Chicken Pot Pie as well. Try them next time you need to bring something to a dinner party or need a last minute gift. Highly recommend!

Joan Weaver

These pies are amazing! My husband and I had the Chicken Pot Pie today. We are still talking about how good it was. Highly recommend!

Courtney Mustian

I ordered 4 pies from the company. One came damaged and defrosted, so I had to throw it out. The spinach and mushroom quiche came out of the oven super watery. Even after letting it sit, the crust was soggy. The chocolate chess pie was a weird texture and, again, the crust was soggy. I followed all the directions on the packaging, and I’ve had to throw away 3 out of 4 pies.

Load More