My favorite salad: Betty's Salad...lettuce, bacon bits, grilled chicken, tomato, onion, green peppers, and cucumbers. Your choice of available dressings. Just delicious all by itself.Parking: This restaurant is part of a 'strip mall' of stores proximate to a super Walmart.Wheelchair accessibility: The entrance is wheelchair accessible and the interior is very roomy...plenty of maneuver space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Betty Salad
Dwain Peaden
The pizza was good, and the server was friendly and helpful. The atmosphere was clean, a little basic but nice. 4 different pizzas and butterballs.Parking: Plenty of parking.
Had the worst pizza of my 68 year life today. Ordered a large BBQ Chicken pizza that was barely warm, on a crust that is worse that frozen pizza with virtually no topping. A BBQ chicken pizza should have CHICKEN AS A TOPPING. I could not even find it on the pizza. Will never go back. How you stay in business is a mystery. Frozen pizza at Kroger is better. My one star rating is too generous. What a waste of $18. Marcos Pizza is much better.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Allen McGouirk
Our favorite pizza is the buffalo chicken, never
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butter Balls
Justin Taylor
Lunch was great. Remodeled interior and it looks amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rich Powell
Great locally owned pizza chain. The buffet is a great lunch option. Blt pizza is absolutely delicious. Not the cheapest but it's good food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sean Hendrix
Ordered a broccoli pizza...It had VERY little broccoli in it. I called to inquire and was met with the most pleasant and understanding employee. Will try again.
Jeffrey Dodd
They’re incredibly stingy on the toppings. So I order a large pepperoni pizza and you’d swear there’s some international embargo on pepperoni. Each slice has a single pepperoni if not none at all. This is horrible. To pay as much as you do here, you’d think they’d do better. I used to come here a lot but this is ridiculous.
Never had a bad experience at American Pie! I frequented the restaurant when I stayed close and regularly make the drive for it now. I ordered delivery from another pizza restaurant and after my food was delivered incorrectly twice, I ordered American Pie online with 45 min left until closing. I arrived 20 min before they closed and the employees greeted me and were as kind and helpful as could be. From the owner to the employees, I always have a 5 star experience.
Kimberly Newman
I ordered a medium pizza and butter balls. Asked for marinara sauce and didn’t get it. But, the worst part…. I paid $2 PER TOPPING and I got a lot of nothing. Half the pizza only had cheese on it, almost as if I had requested half of the pizza a certain way (I did not). It had maybe 4 pieces of pepperoni and the same amount with the small pieces of crumbled beef. I understand that restaurants have had to increase their prices due to the cost of food, but if you raise your prices to cover inflation then you should still be providing appropriate portions to your customers. Taste wise, it was just ok. Staff was fairly friendly, better than most places as of late. Probably won’t go back though.
Mark Cain
Got the pepperoni and got a Buffalo chicken pizza. Crust was great. Flavor was good. Service was awesome. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
C Wilson
The service is good, but the pizza is a rip off. I paid for extra pepperoni, but there's not even enough pepperoni for a single.
Heather Smith
$3 Buffalo butter balls are great! So is pizza. Small pizza is $5. Clean and friendly!!
All you can eat m-f love
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quick and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
My favorite salad: Betty's Salad...lettuce, bacon bits, grilled chicken, tomato, onion, green peppers, and cucumbers. Your choice of available dressings. Just delicious all by itself.Parking: This restaurant is part of a 'strip mall' of stores proximate to a super Walmart.Wheelchair accessibility: The entrance is wheelchair accessible and the interior is very roomy...plenty of maneuver space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Betty Salad
The pizza was good, and the server was friendly and helpful. The atmosphere was clean, a little basic but nice. 4 different pizzas and butterballs.Parking: Plenty of parking.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Pizza Crust, Pepperoni Pizza, Butter Balls
Had the worst pizza of my 68 year life today. Ordered a large BBQ Chicken pizza that was barely warm, on a crust that is worse that frozen pizza with virtually no topping. A BBQ chicken pizza should have CHICKEN AS A TOPPING. I could not even find it on the pizza. Will never go back. How you stay in business is a mystery. Frozen pizza at Kroger is better. My one star rating is too generous. What a waste of $18. Marcos Pizza is much better.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Our favorite pizza is the buffalo chicken, never
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butter Balls
Lunch was great. Remodeled interior and it looks amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great locally owned pizza chain. The buffet is a great lunch option. Blt pizza is absolutely delicious. Not the cheapest but it's good food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a broccoli pizza...It had VERY little broccoli in it. I called to inquire and was met with the most pleasant and understanding employee. Will try again.
They’re incredibly stingy on the toppings. So I order a large pepperoni pizza and you’d swear there’s some international embargo on pepperoni. Each slice has a single pepperoni if not none at all. This is horrible. To pay as much as you do here, you’d think they’d do better. I used to come here a lot but this is ridiculous.
Restaurantji Recommends
Never had a bad experience at American Pie! I frequented the restaurant when I stayed close and regularly make the drive for it now. I ordered delivery from another pizza restaurant and after my food was delivered incorrectly twice, I ordered American Pie online with 45 min left until closing. I arrived 20 min before they closed and the employees greeted me and were as kind and helpful as could be. From the owner to the employees, I always have a 5 star experience.
I ordered a medium pizza and butter balls. Asked for marinara sauce and didn’t get it. But, the worst part…. I paid $2 PER TOPPING and I got a lot of nothing. Half the pizza only had cheese on it, almost as if I had requested half of the pizza a certain way (I did not). It had maybe 4 pieces of pepperoni and the same amount with the small pieces of crumbled beef. I understand that restaurants have had to increase their prices due to the cost of food, but if you raise your prices to cover inflation then you should still be providing appropriate portions to your customers. Taste wise, it was just ok. Staff was fairly friendly, better than most places as of late. Probably won’t go back though.
Got the pepperoni and got a Buffalo chicken pizza. Crust was great. Flavor was good. Service was awesome. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
The service is good, but the pizza is a rip off. I paid for extra pepperoni, but there's not even enough pepperoni for a single.
$3 Buffalo butter balls are great! So is pizza. Small pizza is $5. Clean and friendly!!