Potlucks New York Street Eats

1884 Keys Ferry Rd, McDonough
(678) 814-4633

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Mild Lemon Pepper Wings
Fried Green Tomatoes
Philly Cheese Steak
BBQ Wings and Fries
Cheese Cake Slice
The All American
Banana Pudding
Chicken Philly
10 Piece Wings
Chicken Wings

Menu

Sandwiches
The Texan Sandwich
Smoked brisket on a Kaiser roll with provolone cheese, red onions, slaw and smokehouse sauce
The Reuben Sandwich
Corn beef and pastrami on marble rye with mustard, Swiss cheese, Rueben sauce and sauerkraut
The Hog Heaven Sandwich
Slow smoked pulled pork on a Kaiser roll with provolone cheese, slaw and smokehouse sauce
The Cubano Sandwich
Slow smoked pork and sweet ham on Cuban bread with Swiss cheese, mustard, mojo sauce and pickle
The All American Sandwich
Smoked turkey on a Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, cranberry sauce and choice of cheese
Philly Steak
Chopped Ribeye, Cheese, Green Pepper, Onions, Mayo on French Bread
Shrimp PO Boy
Fried Shrimp, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Potlucks Sauce,Pickles On French Bread
Chicken Philly
Chopped Chicken, Cheese, Green Peppers, Onions, Mayo On French Bread
Double Smash Burger
2 Beef Patties,Cheese,Lettuces, Tomatoes,Mayo

Desserts
Banana pudding

Drinks
Coke Produtcs
Flavored Lemonade

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+9 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+8 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

OK, now that I've visited this spot more than once, these guys know what they are doing in that kitchen. I don't much care for salmon, but I found myself ordering the Salmon Philly on two separate occasions. Don't take my word, come on over to Pot Luck's and see what I'm telling you!
March 2025
Excellent cheat day food! If you enjoy smoked sausages, loaded fries, and a good smash burger. This is your place! I've been looking for a good junk good spot! My wife had the Chopped Salmon sandwich, which was phenomenal! I'm still working on trying everything here, but in the meantime, all of their food has been on point!!!
March 2025
We were a party of 11 and our server, Hope was absolutely amazing! Same for the bartender, Sage! Hope kept our drinks filled, mixed none of our orders, and was nothing but sweet the entire time! We had the best time playing karaoke songs, and simply enjoying the atmosphere! I had the smash burger with chillie cheese fries! Both the fries and burger were excellent. The only negative i could say is the chillie tasted a bit freezer burned, but I'm not gonna complain when everything...
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Los Portales Mexican Grill & Bar - 1894 Keys Ferry Rd
Mexican, Vegetarian
River & Roost - 3710 Hwy 81 East
Southern, Salad
GRITZ N BBQ - 4606a E Fairview Rd SW
Barbeque, Hot Dogs

Potlucks New York Street Eats

1884 Keys Ferry Rd, McDonough, GA 30252
(678) 814-4633