Saw the little pie shop after having lunch across the parking lot. Upon walking in you see the display case filled with cold pies and next to it a plethora of additional pies. A nice woman came out the back to help and she said she was the owner. They have small pies and large pies. So many choices. We got 4 small pies to go. They are best heated up with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top. Enjoy
Jose
My wife just got me a couple pies from here for my birthday and my mind cannot process how exceptional it was! I can’t wait to try more options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel S
Outrageously delicious pie! It's hard to get true artisan delicious pie anywhere. The grocery store is fine but this is TOP TIER! The mini ones are so awesome and the flavors are awesome. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
John Kitchens
Love the coconut cream
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mally I
Cute little shop! Plus they can all be made gluten-free—recommend calling ahead as they typically only bake a few at a time.These are my personal faves/go-tos depending on my mood.? For the Traditionalist: Apple Pie→ The generous crumble topping over the cinnamon-y and tart apples are a no-brainer. I usually bring these out for the holidaysto appease the in-laws.(Pro-tip: Ask about the Cloud 9.)? For the Chocoholic (Nut-Free): Chocolate Cream Pie→ Chocolate mousse, whipped dream, and oreo crust... yeah.? For the Nutty Chocoholic: I-40→ If you like Almond Joy like me I feel like you'd enjoy. Chocolate, pecan, coconut, and shortbread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie, Chocolate Cream, Cloud 9, I-40
Joey
Tried the coconut cream pie, key lime pie, and the Cookie… they completely lacked any flavor. The filling of the coconut and key lime were extremely thick, they’re very dense pies and lacked flavor… worst pies I’ve ever had. Other locations out of ATL are good, this store just is not. Very disappointed with how off the pies were. We ended up throwing them out after a couple bites. They just don’t taste good at all.
Food: 1
Elizabeth Fletcher
Worse Buttermilk Sky Pie ever!!! I normally go to the original store in Knoxville but was in atlanta and went to this store. DONT GO! I got a coconut pie and cherry and both were horrible. The crust was nothing lurk the original which was shortbread. My sister who loves the pie at the original store in Knoxville said it taste like a whole blend of sugar. Run from this franchise
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Christina Kim
They have the best pie in town!! I just love their pies. They are all great!! Love it. I definitely recommend this place !!
Toya Coker
The pies are ok. I got the pecan, key lime, coconut, apple. They were all ok. Will not be coming
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Monica Mora
"An absolute gem of a pie shop! The taste exceeds expectations. Each pie was delicious, and the variety is simply outstanding. Friendly service and a cozy atmosphere make it the perfect spot for any pie enthusiast." (We tried the chocolate chip cookie pie, key lime pie, Buttermilk pies and peanut butter pie)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Key Lime Mini, Coconut Pie and Pecan Pie, Peanut Butter Cream, Chewy Chocolate Chip
My mother who's a senior person entered the doors of this establishment yesterday October 14, 2023. It was approximately between 6:00 - 6:30 PM. There were no other customers, but my mom. The young man at the cash register didn't even greet my mother. This was her first visit and she really wanted to try your pie, but she refuse to spend her money where she didn't feel welcome. So, she turned around and went out the door.I hope by alerting you, this can be used as a training opportunity for your employees.
Amber Dunn
Wasn't blown away. Tastes OK. Not worth it when there are amazing bakeries like The Pie Hole in Roswell or Alpine in Alpharetta
Sande F.
We had already eaten across the street but the name was too enticing to pass. Glad we stopped. There were regular sized pies but we opted for the individual ones. Three of us got apple. I'm not into cooked apples. The customer in front of me informed me that the turtle pecan pie was seasonal. Sounded good to me. So glad I chose wisely. There were raves about the apple. Mine was a cloud of sweetness. Also not a crust person but I was all in. Don't know what else to say. Get here!
Gavin Morrissey
This pie shop is absolutely delightful, and the workers are incredibly nice. I had such an amazing experience with Sofia who helped me pick out the perfect pie for me. (She deserves a BIG raise)
Tinisha Bennett
The best pies ever!!! Customer service, check! Do yourself a favor and get the pecan pie!!! You won’t be disappointed.
Saw the little pie shop after having lunch across the parking lot. Upon walking in you see the display case filled with cold pies and next to it a plethora of additional pies. A nice woman came out the back to help and she said she was the owner. They have small pies and large pies. So many choices. We got 4 small pies to go. They are best heated up with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top. Enjoy
My wife just got me a couple pies from here for my birthday and my mind cannot process how exceptional it was! I can’t wait to try more options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outrageously delicious pie! It's hard to get true artisan delicious pie anywhere. The grocery store is fine but this is TOP TIER! The mini ones are so awesome and the flavors are awesome. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Love the coconut cream
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cute little shop! Plus they can all be made gluten-free—recommend calling ahead as they typically only bake a few at a time.These are my personal faves/go-tos depending on my mood.? For the Traditionalist: Apple Pie→ The generous crumble topping over the cinnamon-y and tart apples are a no-brainer. I usually bring these out for the holidaysto appease the in-laws.(Pro-tip: Ask about the Cloud 9.)? For the Chocoholic (Nut-Free): Chocolate Cream Pie→ Chocolate mousse, whipped dream, and oreo crust... yeah.? For the Nutty Chocoholic: I-40→ If you like Almond Joy like me I feel like you'd enjoy. Chocolate, pecan, coconut, and shortbread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie, Chocolate Cream, Cloud 9, I-40
Tried the coconut cream pie, key lime pie, and the Cookie… they completely lacked any flavor. The filling of the coconut and key lime were extremely thick, they’re very dense pies and lacked flavor… worst pies I’ve ever had. Other locations out of ATL are good, this store just is not. Very disappointed with how off the pies were. We ended up throwing them out after a couple bites. They just don’t taste good at all.
Food: 1
Worse Buttermilk Sky Pie ever!!! I normally go to the original store in Knoxville but was in atlanta and went to this store. DONT GO! I got a coconut pie and cherry and both were horrible. The crust was nothing lurk the original which was shortbread. My sister who loves the pie at the original store in Knoxville said it taste like a whole blend of sugar. Run from this franchise
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
They have the best pie in town!! I just love their pies. They are all great!! Love it. I definitely recommend this place !!
The pies are ok. I got the pecan, key lime, coconut, apple. They were all ok. Will not be coming
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
"An absolute gem of a pie shop! The taste exceeds expectations. Each pie was delicious, and the variety is simply outstanding. Friendly service and a cozy atmosphere make it the perfect spot for any pie enthusiast." (We tried the chocolate chip cookie pie, key lime pie, Buttermilk pies and peanut butter pie)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Key Lime Mini, Coconut Pie and Pecan Pie, Peanut Butter Cream, Chewy Chocolate Chip
Restaurantji Recommends
My mother who's a senior person entered the doors of this establishment yesterday October 14, 2023. It was approximately between 6:00 - 6:30 PM. There were no other customers, but my mom. The young man at the cash register didn't even greet my mother. This was her first visit and she really wanted to try your pie, but she refuse to spend her money where she didn't feel welcome. So, she turned around and went out the door.I hope by alerting you, this can be used as a training opportunity for your employees.
Wasn't blown away. Tastes OK. Not worth it when there are amazing bakeries like The Pie Hole in Roswell or Alpine in Alpharetta
We had already eaten across the street but the name was too enticing to pass. Glad we stopped. There were regular sized pies but we opted for the individual ones. Three of us got apple. I'm not into cooked apples. The customer in front of me informed me that the turtle pecan pie was seasonal. Sounded good to me. So glad I chose wisely. There were raves about the apple. Mine was a cloud of sweetness. Also not a crust person but I was all in. Don't know what else to say. Get here!
This pie shop is absolutely delightful, and the workers are incredibly nice. I had such an amazing experience with Sofia who helped me pick out the perfect pie for me. (She deserves a BIG raise)
The best pies ever!!! Customer service, check! Do yourself a favor and get the pecan pie!!! You won’t be disappointed.