I used to love the Benny blanco pizza, but the one i got tonight looks nothing like the picture or how i remember it. It is a sad pizza with super thin zucchini slices and soggy spinach piles that seem to be frozen from a bag… it’s missing like half the ingredients. I’m not sure if they were out of everything but there was no warning given and i would never order it again based on this
Daniel Navarro
The place is usually empty, which should have been a sign. The best thing about this place was the pizza. Yes, it's thin crust, almost cracker like, was really good. That's all though.
The wings were meh. Small, not crispy, sorta like baked wings. No ranch given, just lime which is strange. Could have been more saucy. Only three beers on tap, 1 local the rest from big beer companies.
It did seem, at first, that the server really didn't want us there. I asked if they had WiFi and she said she didn't know it. I tried engaging her but she seemed like she had better things to do despite the fact that we were the only ones there.
I'll come back for the pizza. I really did like it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Cave CCR
Ridiculously expensive for what you get. Pizzas were barely acceptable, but the wings and salad were just a joke! We had it for delivery though so we can’t rate service and atmosphere. But the food we had was just bad
Food: 1
Ivan Nev
Decent Wood Fired pizza. Hand tossed, sourced with local ingredients and made in a true wood fired oven. No gas, no Fryers etc but true wood fire. Great pizza and apps especially for someone like myself that comes from Chicago and we have amazing pizzas out there. The chicken wings were okay, no ranch was given just a slice of lime which was kinda weird, there isn’t any hot sauces either.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Nick
( PLEASE MAKE THE RANCH IN HOUSE)???
I would have given 5 stars if sparkling water was a beverage choice and if ranch was made in house.
Pizza and atmosphere is upscale.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Douglas Morse
Just got delivery of two pizzas and 6 wings. The pizzas were good/as expected. And the delivery (even though subbed to Doordash) was REALLY fast! But I really regret ordering the wings. I ate one, fed a couple of small pieces of meat to the cat ... took a bite out of what seemed to be yesterday's, or the day before's stale wing just to be sure and promptly threw the rest away. The cat didn't complain, but it was pretty obvious that those wings had been sitting for a VERY long time. Good thing the pizzas were pretty good. I'll need the pizza to take the taste of the wings out of my mouth. We'll be back, but def NOT for the wings.
Food: 2
Service: 5
Bill Kamil
Excellent pizza.
Jessica Thomas
After nearly five years in Savannah, we decided to try Squirrel’s Pizza on Bull Street, hopeful it might become our new go-to spot. Unfortunately, it turned out to be the worst pizza we've ever had—yes, even Pizza Hut and Domino’s serve better quality pies.
Ever seen those “Expectation vs. Reality” memes? Well, what we received was the sad, reality side of the meme—the kind people share for a good laugh because it's so bad.
Both pizzas had little to no sauce or cheese, with sparse toppings, especially on the Funghi pizza—disappointing given the price. The thin crust left much to be desired, adding to the overall letdown.
The Baked Chèvre, which we thought would be a saving grace, arrived fridge-cold. We received two golf ball-sized cheese balls sitting in ¼ cup of cold tomato sauce. The fact that someone packed this and thought, "Yeah, the customer will be fine with this," is truly baffling.
As you’re reading this, understand—I wouldn't bother typing this review if the meal hadn’t been as bad as I’m saying. Consider this a warning to fellow pizza lovers.
Squirrel’s Pizza is now officially crossed off our list, and we’ll be telling anyone who asks to steer clear.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Ximena Galicia
The pizza was awful because of the pizza dough. We ordered a margarita and the white one without veggies.
The margarita one was far from what it is a margarita pizza.
Neeever again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Nicole Reynolds
Usually their pizza is pretty good, not great, but decent. However, the delivery I just received was probably the worst I’ve ever gotten. This was supposed to be a margarita pizza in the photo! Cold, stale, burnt and not even a margarita. 2 pizzas delivered were $43! Sorry, squirrel. Won’t be wasting money with you anymore!
I ordered a pizza from there…it was so burnt that I couldn’t differentiate between sauce & cheese
Food: 1
Josh Winn
Pretty decent pizza. Thin, crispy crust, all the way to the edge. More cracker-like than yeasty (no chewy, bubbly crust). Sauce not too sweet. Pepperoni is pretty spicy. We liked the white pizza with lemon. Margaret(a) pizza was just ok (has red sauce). Service was fine. Parking is very limited.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Philip Brocious
Wow! Could not have been more disappointed in the flavor or the cost for the value. Very salty. First time ordering and will never order again. A $25 pizza that should have been maybe an appetizer somewhere. Or at least on the Small bites menu. Ordered tomato add-on and got maybe seven small pieces of tomato. For $3.25. About a third of the pizza had nothing on it. Just crust. The onions were ordered for $1.75 but I didn't see any on it. I think maybe five small pieces of onion. This place is a joke! If you want good local pizza go toVinny Van Go-Go's in City market. Excellent pizza and great value. Or just any where else. Sorry for the bad review but you guys deserve it.
VJ Gorri
Took order, took money, closed and never delivered.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
abbie reese
Service sucks or the girl working might not of liked me who knows, and her drink was not even drinkable. Asked her to fix it and she said that's what I ordered, she doctored it with water This has been the case EVERY time I've been there, so much for eastern wharf park days. The squirrel girls are going to run folks away. Find another job if you don't like people !!!
I used to love the Benny blanco pizza, but the one i got tonight looks nothing like the picture or how i remember it. It is a sad pizza with super thin zucchini slices and soggy spinach piles that seem to be frozen from a bag… it’s missing like half the ingredients. I’m not sure if they were out of everything but there was no warning given and i would never order it again based on this
The place is usually empty, which should have been a sign. The best thing about this place was the pizza. Yes, it's thin crust, almost cracker like, was really good. That's all though.
The wings were meh. Small, not crispy, sorta like baked wings. No ranch given, just lime which is strange. Could have been more saucy. Only three beers on tap, 1 local the rest from big beer companies.
It did seem, at first, that the server really didn't want us there. I asked if they had WiFi and she said she didn't know it. I tried engaging her but she seemed like she had better things to do despite the fact that we were the only ones there.
I'll come back for the pizza. I really did like it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Ridiculously expensive for what you get. Pizzas were barely acceptable, but the wings and salad were just a joke! We had it for delivery though so we can’t rate service and atmosphere. But the food we had was just bad
Food: 1
Decent Wood Fired pizza. Hand tossed, sourced with local ingredients and made in a true wood fired oven. No gas, no Fryers etc but true wood fire. Great pizza and apps especially for someone like myself that comes from Chicago and we have amazing pizzas out there. The chicken wings were okay, no ranch was given just a slice of lime which was kinda weird, there isn’t any hot sauces either.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
( PLEASE MAKE THE RANCH IN HOUSE)???
I would have given 5 stars if sparkling water was a beverage choice and if ranch was made in house.
Pizza and atmosphere is upscale.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Just got delivery of two pizzas and 6 wings. The pizzas were good/as expected. And the delivery (even though subbed to Doordash) was REALLY fast! But I really regret ordering the wings. I ate one, fed a couple of small pieces of meat to the cat ... took a bite out of what seemed to be yesterday's, or the day before's stale wing just to be sure and promptly threw the rest away. The cat didn't complain, but it was pretty obvious that those wings had been sitting for a VERY long time. Good thing the pizzas were pretty good. I'll need the pizza to take the taste of the wings out of my mouth. We'll be back, but def NOT for the wings.
Food: 2
Service: 5
Excellent pizza.
After nearly five years in Savannah, we decided to try Squirrel’s Pizza on Bull Street, hopeful it might become our new go-to spot. Unfortunately, it turned out to be the worst pizza we've ever had—yes, even Pizza Hut and Domino’s serve better quality pies.
We ordered:
- Baked Chèvre
- Funghi Pizza
- Cupping Pepperoni Pizza
Ever seen those “Expectation vs. Reality” memes? Well, what we received was the sad, reality side of the meme—the kind people share for a good laugh because it's so bad.
Both pizzas had little to no sauce or cheese, with sparse toppings, especially on the Funghi pizza—disappointing given the price. The thin crust left much to be desired, adding to the overall letdown.
The Baked Chèvre, which we thought would be a saving grace, arrived fridge-cold. We received two golf ball-sized cheese balls sitting in ¼ cup of cold tomato sauce. The fact that someone packed this and thought, "Yeah, the customer will be fine with this," is truly baffling.
As you’re reading this, understand—I wouldn't bother typing this review if the meal hadn’t been as bad as I’m saying. Consider this a warning to fellow pizza lovers.
Squirrel’s Pizza is now officially crossed off our list, and we’ll be telling anyone who asks to steer clear.
Food: 1
Service: 3
The pizza was awful because of the pizza dough. We ordered a margarita and the white one without veggies.
The margarita one was far from what it is a margarita pizza.
Neeever again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Usually their pizza is pretty good, not great, but decent. However, the delivery I just received was probably the worst I’ve ever gotten. This was supposed to be a margarita pizza in the photo! Cold, stale, burnt and not even a margarita. 2 pizzas delivered were $43!
Sorry, squirrel. Won’t be wasting money with you anymore!
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered a pizza from there…it was so burnt that I couldn’t differentiate between sauce & cheese
Food: 1
Pretty decent pizza. Thin, crispy crust, all the way to the edge. More cracker-like than yeasty (no chewy, bubbly crust). Sauce not too sweet. Pepperoni is pretty spicy. We liked the white pizza with lemon. Margaret(a) pizza was just ok (has red sauce). Service was fine. Parking is very limited.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Wow! Could not have been more disappointed in the flavor or the cost for the value. Very salty. First time ordering and will never order again. A $25 pizza that should have been maybe an appetizer somewhere. Or at least on the Small bites menu. Ordered tomato add-on and got maybe seven small pieces of tomato. For $3.25. About a third of the pizza had nothing on it. Just crust. The onions were ordered for $1.75 but I didn't see any on it. I think maybe five small pieces of onion. This place is a joke!
If you want good local pizza go toVinny Van Go-Go's in City market. Excellent pizza and great value. Or just any where else. Sorry for the bad review but you guys deserve it.
Took order, took money, closed and never delivered.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Service sucks or the girl working might not of liked me who knows, and her drink was not even drinkable. Asked her to fix it and she said that's what I ordered, she doctored it with water
This has been the case EVERY time I've been there, so much for eastern wharf park days. The squirrel girls are going to run folks away. Find another job if you don't like people !!!
Service: 1
Loading...